Santa Cruz City Council 03/22/22

Is our city clerk prepared? – Thank you, all right.
of the March 22nd, 2022, meeting of the City Council. , if you would such as to comment

on a shut session item, currently is the time to employ the
instructions on your display. In this component of the conference,
the council will receive public testimony, thereafter, the public line
will certainly be closed and also inaccessible.Please mute your tv or streaming gadget when you contact and also listen through the phone.
Please note, there is a delay in streaming.
So if you continue to listen on your television or streaming device, you may miss your opportunity.
I would like to ask the staff, to please call the role.
(indistinct). (indistinct) (indistinct) (indistinct) Watkin. Okay, allow'' s go out to guests.
( indistinct) Okay. We are almost to begin. our mid-day session.
Just returning from shut session. As well as it looks like, staff,. Okay, so allow ' s start.
I want to ask the. clerk, please call duty.
(indistinct) Johnson. (indistinct) – Right here. (indistinct) Okay, thank you, so let'' s see.
declaring March 2022, Red Cross Month for the city of Santa Cruz. and also have Anita, (indistinct).
As well as (indistinct) here with us. [Male guest 1] Hi,.
I'' m right here, we ' re right here. -Welcome. -[. Staff] Mayor Anita ' s having– -Okay. I will go in advance and.
present the proclamation. Whereas in times of situation,. people in Santa Cruz come together to look after each other. This humanitarian spirit becomes part of the foundation of our area. as well as is exhibited by American Red Cross.
volunteers and donors.And whereas

in 1881, Clara Barton started the American Red Cross, turning her unfaltering.
devotion for assisting others right into a strong objective of preventing.
as well as relieving suffering. And also whereas today, a lot more.
than 140 years later, we honor the compassion in.
our Red Cross volunteers right here in Santa Cruz that.
remain to execute Clara Barton'' s life saving legacy. Signing up with the countless.
individuals across (indistinct) that offer, provide.
blood, contribute economically or find out essential life offering.
abilities through the Red Cross. As well as whereas country of.
regional Red Cross volunteers, 189 in the region, give.
really hope one of the most at risk in their darkest hrs. Last year in Santa Cruz.
county volunteers aided 33 residence affected by 24 home fires by resolving their immediate.
like food as well as lodging, as well as offering healing support, collecting over 3,900 blood contributions, supplied first aid as well as CPR training to over 1,400 citizens. Helped households of over.
500 pupils get ready for calamities with Cushion Situation task and also assisted over 40.
family members of our armed pressures. And whereas just worked as well as.
alleviating suffering is essential strength in our– And we devote this month of March, all those (indistinct) the noble heritage of American Red Cross.
Quote.
Now, therefore, I Sonja Brunner, Mayor of the city (audio.
decreases), thus proclaim the month of March.
2022, as Red Cross month in the city of Santa Cruz, and also encourage all resident to connect and (indistinct) mission. As well as, I'' d like to invite,.
once again, if you'' re right here and also you ' d like claim any kind of. words as the board participant American Red Cross. – [Dan] Yes, great mid-day. I believe Anita joined us. – Hi, yes, good afternoon. – Welcome Anita. – Wan na go ahead and also begin, Anita? Yeah, I'' ll kick it off. Thank you for having us.So yeah, my name'' s Anita Clarice and also I'' m with the Central Article Chapter of the American Red Cross. And also as you see, joining me is Dan Rippy. I'' m the vice chair of the chapter. So it'' s a great honor to.
accept the unique promotion, proclaiming March as Red Cross.
Our goal wouldn'' t be possible. Throughout our yearly Red Cross.
Month celebration in March, we honor their commitment.
to sustain people as well as households in demand. And also on somebody'' s darkest.
day, be that (audio drops). When head of state Franklin Roosevelt provided the very first national, this custom began almost 80 years back.
Red Cross Month proclamation, and each head of state has.
followed ever since. Today, our work is.
powered 90% by volunteers, together with generous.
monetary and also blood donors, (indistinct).

As well as we are constantly wanting to.
include added volunteers. I'' m incredibly proud to.
share a few highlights of what we'' ve achieved.
together over the previous year. we'' ve reacted to the worst fire disaster our area has ever experienced, a historical blood lack.
as well as are now looking at exactly how we can (indistinct) environment. I think what may be at the.
top of our minds today, is the crisis in Ukraine. And I want to share.
update with our Red Cross and also International Red Cross Assistance. International Red Cross.
groups are ground in Ukraine providing urgent aid. For the past 8 years,.
International Red Cross have actually provided food, gas for feeding, clinical products as well as support for real estate, those living objectives as well are.
on the line of call. which was the Eastern.
border of Ukraine with– As dispute spreads, Red.
Cross teams are enhancing their support throughout the country, giving first (indistinct).

When assistance can'' t wait throughout emergency situations, American Red Cross.
volunteers and blood contributors step up to guarantee individuals in.
requirement receive alleviation care. Your neighborhood Red Cross.
along with region partners has supplied shielding.
feeding as well as healing to those impacted by the current wildfires as we flow evacuees from Santa.
Cruz as well as Monterey area. And those homeowners displaced after the (indistinct).
tidal wave that hit Santa Cruz. and also for the recovery effort after the CZU, River Dolan as well as (indistinct) wild fires, plenty of Red Cross provided.
over two as well as a fifty percent million in grant support to regional.
partner companies where assisted locals.
with recuperation structure. In terms of support,.
directly to those citizens influenced by the 2020 wild fires, the Red Cross sustained.
17 situations for 55 individuals in Monterey county. As well as 244,591 people in Santa Cruz area, offering instant.
help and also sources for lengthy term recuperation. The Red Cross set up a shelter.
at Carmel Intermediate school in action to Colorado fire in January. Showing that our fire periods.
have no (indistinct) season, as well as we need our neighborhoods prepared for one more (indistinct).
Anne'' s gon na take over and
. – Thank you, Anita. As well as again, thank you for welcoming us and also for acknowledging Red Cross Month.
the United States needs blood, and one contribution by you can aid conserve as much as three lives. Red Cross holds blood.
drives across country for volunteer blood benefactors who.
obviously assist those in demand. Over the previous year, our.
blood supply has actually diminished to a vital degree, number.
of elements, consisting of COVID. And also we ask you to please.
support the initiative to bring the capacity as well as.
support blood drive quickly. It'' s basic to make an appointment at redcrossblood.org.
and redcrossblood.org. And discover a hassle-free drive. Along with this, we supply,.
Red Cross provide services (indistinct) force and also.
global services.Red Cross volunteers. offer 24/7 global assistance to aid army households,. consisting of a number of who have experienced several. implementations over the past. Additionally, as part. of the world ' s largest humanitarian network, Red Cross employees reply to global catastrophes and help neighborhoods. prepare for emergency situations around the globe. Locally, we helped over. 130 active duty members and
their family members with. their emergency circumstances, consisting of monetary aid and emergency situation interaction solutions. We were additionally able to. provide convenience to veterans and National guard participants. who might request( indistinct).
training as well as solution,. the Red Cross offer training solution staff, rapidly. adjusting local areas to the COVID restrictions as well as continuing to educate. and also re-certify individuals in a modified atmosphere,. enabling our very first responders
to remain current.( indistinct )demand.
They were able to do. In response to environment change, Red Cross (indistinct )playing our component present altruistic effect on climate. We will certainly develop the durability.
out of proportion results of environment.

Delighted to share that
our. at our Santa Cruz office has actually just gotten certification. as an environment-friendly service as well as will certainly be included in our the National Green. Organization Directory site. (laughs )Volunteer setting, every.
day people in our community count on the Red Cross.
volunteers for assistance. There are numerous ways you.
That ' s the feedback volunteers required. Every 8 minutes, Red. Cross responds to catastrophes across the United States.
Who have an interest in volunteering please go, excuse me, please check out redcross.org/volunteertoday. for your most required positions( indistinct). And allow me go over that to you,. redcross.org/volunteertoday.
I like to make use of the quote,. today decides tomorrow, if you would such as volunteer tomorrow, I ask that you please indicator. as much as volunteer today.We do need to get you right into our systems as well as be able to supply.

you with vital training. Again, redcross.org/volunteertoday.
On part of the American Red Cross, we thank you for this announcement. Most of all, we would like. to thanks and also the several of your city team. members that function carefully
with the American Red Changeover the years to be a better prepared city. for all kinds of emergency along with calamity.- Thanks so a lot.
We appreciate you. sharing that information. Thanks. Any kind of council participants have any kind of concerns? Hey, going on to our following discussion, we have Connie( indistinct),. Economic Development department with a presentation as well as upgrade on the collection real estate. auto parking advancement job.- Thanks, Mayor and excellent.
( indistinct) council participants. I ' m Bonnie Lipscomb director. And also I ' m going to share my screen.
As well as specifically, just talk. A little bit concerning the.
I ' ll give you an upgrade. We ' ve really gotten. As well as I ' ll give you a little.
( indistinct) and assistance. As you can see pushback.
lower size of the wide, added real estate on the top, truly.
increased the square video of the library on the ground.
or included the rooftop yard as well as rooftop space, I desired.
to offer you simply a preview of where we are right now.We … These are most definitely in progression. These are prepared, yet these.
are still what ideally we'' ll be refining a bit a lot more throughout the rest of this.
month as well as have the ability to existing completely created (indistinct).
design degree drawings idea. And also both for a collection of.
( indistinct )So this is a sneak peek, as I. stated, this really much draft, but this is truly concentrated on what you saw in just the conceptual.
with a few of the materials, in fact what it will look.
like just as if are standing in the Cedar Street auto parking great deal today. Your following (indistinct) right throughout to the mid block collection. There'' s it from a somewhat angle, simply a little even more to the south. So, (audio drops) and also.
looking across the means. As you see up below, you start.
to see what it would certainly look like on the roof covering deck which is.
connected with the collection. That'' s 4,500, 5,000 feet.And now quickly, I ' m simply. gon na provide you an upgrade on the grants that our. groups did on Monday.
Library Infrastructure Grant. California State Library
, it ' s a competitive affordable give. The max grant for the collection.
The bulk section of the. give, close to eight million will certainly be especially for. protection of the library.
We ' re rather delighted concerning this. This will honor and enable. us on these functions, with the photovoltaic panels and also. the green roof, really
, to our goal of net absolutely no (indistinct) from the library project. We'' re rather thrilled to have this, we listen to there'' s a great deal of. rate of interest in our task as for grant in this give program.So there'' s a relatively quick turnaround, we could satisfy on Monday to.
support from the library too, and also our project right here.
in financial development and also are wishing to be back within the next, I'' d state within the next. few months, possibly, even a little sooner. We'' ll update you following month. If we hear anything back by then, on. Then simply briefly a.
task timetable update where we are right currently,.
Forward to you in (indistinct).

We had simply completed the.
conceptual style stage. To make sure that was those sketches.
that last time for principle, where we are currently is our following phase, after most likely a pair months in advance, we'' ll be our( indistinct ). As well as so we'' ll be onward that phase. Following action we have quite a couple of, we are anticipating by.
completion of next week to be staying up there intending. And also this is a preapplication.
for our formal application of that planning for the various other departments about the job, an.
chance to deal with those (indistinct). As I claimed for the end of next week, we'' re likewise preparing for.
our following round of outreach as well as we'' re expecting this will get on this thematic layout.
stage, actually focusing on the collection, the library layout offer as well as the.
collection therefore we'' re checking out mid month, mid. April for that update, for having that outreach.
and also concerning council with feedback from that outreach for the (indistinct).

We'' re likewise have actually been. having continuous conferences, they'' ve been very productive.
with the farmer'' s market. We are right now concentrated on whole lot 7, this whole lot behind and the.
Delmar that goes between city part is one parcel.
in, (indistinct) Cathcart. So from behind the Delmar.
completely to Cathcart. And also we'' re doing … we had actually done some preliminary designs in car park counts as well as they.
were called overhead structures they'' re developed for the farmer'' s market.
We ' re taking another look at those, got. Parking and not the farmer'' s market, yet likewise with the other.
So we have some really amazing ideas currently that with the farmer ' s market, I think we ' re in a truly great place. And we'' re dealing with an expediency research of a couple different.
designs now. That'' s something that with any luck in the close to future in the following few months we can bring onward to you as well.We ' re likewise functioning on.
the updated cost version. That'' s why the application is. actually important to us. We have some things in
there. that we require to transform, get that right into bent on our experts. They can see and upgrade if.
there are any type of expense effects before we go onward. That'' ll be ongoing remainder.
of thematic design stage. As soon as we get with somatic.
design and also that first preliminary back on our.
pre-app application, truly be able to actually.
company up some of our price, and get that information.
Back to you. So, as I stated, our next meeting on 4/26, I believe it'' s mosting likely to be. a rather durable upgrade. It is an off cycle update.
as opposed to waiting, 3 months we intended to you below due to the fact that we believe we'' ll. have plenty of points following month to offer you.
updates on on the project.We ' ll likewise on 4/26,'be. asking you to approve a grant resolution relevant.
to the structure ahead give settle. And also after that we are targeting.
for around May 23rd give or take couple of days,.
Towards the end of may for the complete application. That concludes my upgrade.
and also I'' m happy to address– – Thank you a lot for that update. some of my inquiries for.
responding to that upgrade. I will bring out (indistinct). – Thanks for that, Bonnie. I just had a remark, I understand, well, I'' ve been chatting with. neighborhood regarding this job and one point that.
people obtain excited around is not just the potential for green roofing, but if there'' s a capacity. for that eco-friendly roof space to be used for farming.
functions by citizens that live in the real estate units.So that ' s

an extremely … Kind of I put on'' t know the word for it. Yet when you think of.
having reduced revenue real estate with access to education and learning child care as well as after that health food.
production for households that people actually get delighted.
concerning that as a possibility. Just something to.
think about when considering the environment-friendly roofing,.
that can be something to that the locals can.
That'' s a benefit that people.- Great.
on top of the collection with several of the glass and kind of day lighting. Nonetheless, we are that could.
there be locations where we– That in addition to have.
We ' re looking at all those up. – There is one various other.
question slash remark. I was thinking about.
within the context of solar is has there, has it additionally been considered, potentially placed wind generators on the top? '' Cause I recognize that they.
And so I was simply assuming about that. – Thank you, council participant, Cummings as well as council participant, Terry Johnson. – Thanks so much for the.
discussion, Bonnie, that'' s truly awesome to see.
all the work that'' s been done. If you, I ' m wondering.
might offer an update on the discussions on the.
neighborhood interaction as well as conversations on the.
present time library site for this reason the usage of that. – Sure, so we completed.
that process back in June for the existing library site. And we do have and also I can.
Emphasize that with a link following discussion as well.
we do have referral that came out of that process, which for the existing.
library website suggestions are to take a look at that as a.
real estate website, inexpensive real estate site with the Plaza area that possibly can be a future home for the farmer'' s market. So the farmer ' s market, I will say, is delighted concerning that site. One of their concerns is simply the timing. And considering whole lot 7, it.
And also acknowledging that they.
Well, collection finished. and the collection relocates right into the brand-new area. We were going through a. schedule introduction with them and also sort of that requirement of, they ' re gon na require to. have'an acting place.
What ' s the very best place for them?

I'' m right here, we ' re below. There'' s it from a somewhat angle, simply somewhat more to the south. That'' s 4,500, 5,000 feet.And now briefly, I ' m just. We'' re quite excited to have this, we listen to there'' s a lot of. And so we'' ll be onward that stage.It also provides an
possibility to determine they like, so that'' s that ' s our plan with the farmer ' s market as well as
for existing collection site, we have those suggestions. And also I do think that ultimately
it would certainly be a great site, cost effective real estate task
and also to have that element of a plaza as well. So we'' re concentrated on the existing project for the brand-new job currently, but
as soon as we surpass a point, we will certainly return and look
on the existing collection site and start planning for that. – Great, thanks. And do you have a feeling of, I mean, do you have a sense of like timing of when we would go
revisit the suggestions for the present website? I indicate, I understand one step at a.
time as well as one project at a time, we'' ve obtained a plate full,.
Simply a general feeling.

– I assume most likely it would be sometime, my guess would certainly be sometime,.
my hunch will be squeamish. I assume we desire to go sufficient.
down the path for that, have that strategy which we'' re qualified for the present suggested site. As well as then as soon as we recognize that'' s. on that particular path (indistinct) Yet our present quotes,.
based on the timeline that the move from current website, one likely wouldn'' t occur. till late 5 approximately.
There is a long time before that. task could in fact begin.- Yeah, got it, thank you, that ' s practical.- Thanks, next, I. have council member Myers and also'after that council member Brown.
Member Myers you ' re muted. -Genuine quick question, you.( laughs )- It ' s in between 18 as well as 24 months.
– And right currently we ' re looking,. pursuing tax credits most likely January of( indistinct). So preferably it would be next.
As well as we'' re still envisioning that the city would still hold on to budget-friendly. We would certainly still be the supervisor.
of the cost effective housing– In terms of all the– I mean, we may deal with a personal entity, but we would certainly still be recording.
all those restrictions (audio drops) Those conditions will be. – Absolutely have the commitment on site.And our vision

similar to.
several of our various other projects with our cost effective.
real estate partners investment is that we have that.
For the (audio declines) and also each housing, they would be managing the project. They'' d project would certainly be.
website and also the library building and the various other (audio decreases). So more than likely we'' re still. functioning through the framework, but more than likely it would be.
That'' s something that in come ahead when we'' re a little additional.- Thank you, council member Myers. – Mayor Brunner and also say thanks to.
you, Bonnie for the upgrade. And also as always creating an actually clear presentation and giving us a lot of info. I have a number of.
questions that are associated to the big image of the.
site, the building envelope. As well as I'' m simply questioning. where you ' re at conversations regarding establishing what the strategy.
I ' ll just ask that initial after that.- Thank you, council member Brown.
has functioning on this task. He absolutely has been.
entering as well as going deep into the task. You will certainly begin seeing.
And also he'' s actually doing really. I did wan na acknowledge him as well As far as the library size, you.
Yeah, we'' re holding the 35,000 for the indoor programmable area. We in fact right now
.
be bigger than that. We'' re actually checking out putting some of the heating and cooling mechanical.
components of the library that usually would be in that footprint. We'' re in fact putting.
that on the framework side as well as while that takes much more.
rooms for assessing, it gives us much more efficient as well as.
more area for the collection. We'' re working through that right now, but, we have actually committed inside and also dedicated as a project group that we wear'' t wan na go listed below the 3, 5,000 if at all possible.And we ' ve been holding'to that. Then on top of that,.
we have the collection, extra roofing deck.
space and we'' re attempting to maintain that as adaptable as possible, but that is undoubtedly, household.
element might reserve that through the library and also use that area. However you really are seeing.
that as people by the library offered for booking or neighborhood events, but really, library programmable.
area in addition to alright. Inquiries on the overall funding and I identify that a lot of this is due process as well as you pointed out.
this give opportunity and that would certainly be a.
significant contribution million dollars job,.
yet I also am wondering so what advise us, or existing price quote on exactly how much of measure.
S financing is readily available for the task and after that just extra normally or, or holistically, I guess, the, where we'' re at with the budget sets you back costing out on the numerous aspects of the project.

– Sure, so we have actually 25.5 set.
aside for the downtown branch off of it'' ll roughly 31.5, a million readily available for the Santa branches, they have actually not finished say they, the type of collection accountants.
are dealing with this, place'' t totally liquidated the branch and the 2 various other areas, our field. There might be hundred.
thousand that returns that we reprogram and also.
Right currently, we'' re simply. I wear'' t know if those will certainly be shut out end of this monetary year, but ideally, we'' ll have better additional.
Last we heard about a month back, they were that there would certainly be some, they thought they'' d be able to close out, yet I put on'' t believe they'' ve obtained with all they ' re to be identified on that. Most definitely that ' s rather why we ' re so excited for.
more town library area. Also though the collection website, is roughly 40,001,000 provide take there'' s about 14,000, that back of home area is not open public.
and it'' s rather in. So when you ' re comparing the existing, the library to the previous collection, we in fact have a net.
gain of hundred to 2000 and type of expanding of.
We simply didn'' t understand. It was truly important as.
far as the spending plan includes certainly, as we obtain part,.
locate several of the exterior features we have right.
currently are and also fantastic, however I will state all that glass job quite costly, so right now we'' re holding pretty strong on the.
budget, yet that procedure can be found in will certainly be actually vital for us.There are

some points there that we can do some worth.
engineer, our budget plan right now, we'' re hopeful that we can.
It comes via', I think that ' s really great,( indistinct) going ahead and also in addition to that, we.
sharing, construction monitoring that actually actually comes via as well as saves us a fair bit of and total the spending plan with the collection would just alone or doing a so, I believe we'' re getting a much bigger, far more state of the.
art materials library than we ever before would certainly'' ve. been with the existing site '' cause of all this. So quite delighted about that, yet obviously we require to.
obtain this next phase phase to ensure that we can as well as really.
have our specialists go deep on the price products and afterwards we'' ll be able to come back to council and really show you, alright, right here ' s the standard,.
here'' s the expense of these,'right here ' s some alternatives which ' s the degree of information that we'' re truly wanting to and after that not.It ' s excellent, it was truly.
Thank you value.- Thank you council, looks like that presentation.
Thank you, Bonnie lip. appreciate the update. Anticipate the next one, April 26th. Okay, we ' ll now go on to. our next discussion thing, this is a Mayoral pronouncement stating March 22nd is Jane
Day. present, welcome Jane, I will proceed as well as review the proclamation and afterwards where.Whereas Jane me

a half a century Santa head of state has actually offered with the San Lorenzo river estuary Reve job, SLV indigenous environment reconstruction program valley ladies'' s club as well as served on the city of Santa Cruz park and entertainment since.
thousand 8, including acting as vice turn 2020 and Karen 2021. And whereas Jane dish has engaged thousands of volunteers in environmental reconstruction job along the San Lorenzo river through the San Lorenzo river estuary job and also whereas for the past five years, Jane meal has led long-term effort along the ES reef of San Lorenza river, her initiatives brought about the removal of.
huge areas of invasive as well as the growing and also care.
of hundreds of plant.Jane has put

in lots of days of tough labor herself and also extra significantly has leveraged the source.
of other organizations and also in the procedure connected numerous people with the river,.
the river rock river walk and whereas Jane has engaged with as well as brought in team job together with her on the San Lorenzo river, including the local valley ladies'' s club, AmeriCorps, California conservation.
Corps, college group, girl Scouts and also the museof NA. As well as whereas being homeless.
have been a significant situation and also their influence have actually been acute along the San Lorenzo river, one of Jane'' s most discover remarkable collaboration has been with the midtown nonprofit organization that functions with individuals,.
experience homeless with our life with them. Jane has actually run a program.
introducing road participants, San Lorenzo River'' s indigenous. plant as well as wildlife habitat as well as has provided training and skills on their maintenance care as well as whereas the bench component of the San Lorenzo river flooding airplane and previous homeless encampment in the area have damaged hole habitat at the river'' s side and released waste and also particles right into the river itself, this has actually been an issue of fantastic concern as well as with the assistance of personnel produced a program to involve camp homeowners throughout that.
area, whereas in 2021 environmental group additionally understood as best, there for certain damaged.
areas of the San Lorenzo Beland shore adjacent.
to the encampments in lower San Lorenzo park, this program has participants of the.
house and also unhoused works side by our lovely Ripan habitat of San Lorenzo river as well as.
has far better environment as well as the lives and also whereas Maine Neo has actually been chosen and also freshly.
recognized as champ of this area by California parks and leisures awards program and also whereas Jane puts our heart and spirit into overdue job, the environment.and and the community currently therefore

Ionia heater Mayor the city of Santa proclaim, March 22nd, 22 as Jane Day in the city.
of Santa in acknowledgment of the previous 5 years, plenty of hours has volunteered her time while also engage with numerous companies and also volunteers to boost the neighborhood and the habitat along the reduced San Lorenzo river for her recurring dedication, our setting park for her work as parks as well as.
commissioner, leisure and chair and her special solution creating conventional environmentals is actually a champion of welcome, – Oh, Mayor. (laughs) Sorry, I do want to claim that is with actual deep happiness and also humbleness that I receive the announcement.
of the Jane Mu day. I so grateful approve the honor and the nationwide females'' s background by saling all previous existing, future
. ladies who follow their interest of engaging.
their varied area construct comprehensive atmosphere,.
I'' m also unbelievably happy with all individuals that, oh God, I hope I wear'' t. have a cry that might sustain me day pass because this info is a testimony of their.
work, courage.i and also assistance celebrate each and every single individual with all my heart, for their. contribution for making
this state feasible.( laughs) As well as thanks for every one of. you, every person that made the feisty delighted, say thanks to like council member Myers and council member coming have actually Delighted that we have a day named after you this year.( laughs) You and also I recognized each. various other for 25 years on that particular river as well as we ' ve planted plants as well as chilly weeds and also done all type of insane points and attempt to show as many individuals regarding that river and just how unique it. is as high as feasible. Therefore you, you just.
lug this torch each and every single day, when you walk on that river as well as solitary person that you instruct regarding the birds which you speak about the history river as well as you explain all the unique turfs that most of us, we both know where they are and also that they ' re they ' re natives and also they'' ve survived 20'years of practically just abuse, so I simply, I can'' t thank the Mayor more for identifying you and you are tough. as well as you are a difficulty maker and also you do have one of the greatest hearts I'' ve ever known.So congrats to you my dear, thank you. We have been included how we done. Thanks, council member.
Myers, council participant. As well as I simply desire to thanks.
for plenty of years of job as well as love that you take into our river and the I staying in the coastline flats most likely wear'' t know this, yet I would certainly drive by you kinda servicing the river levy planting native plants would.
wan na claim and quit hello, yet there'' s not, there ' s truly no place. You can stop along the street, but simply wanted to recognize, I see you out there as well as I'' ve heard a lot of great points from individuals in the neighborhood who have actually gone down to deal with you as well as with the homeless individuals who remain in the bench finishes to assist clean up the location down there on the weekend breaks as well as instruct the people down there about the indigenous plants.And I assume it ' s via those type of efforts, we can actually aid, reveal peoples that they can contribute something to our community and also they can make a distinction as well as aid up with individuals that are in actually dark areas. So thank you significantly for. every little thing you ' ve done. You ' ve done as well as remain to do, thank you. Thank you, I appreciate that a whole lot. Council member Brown, you.
Jane, what can I, what to state? I'' m simply so thrilled.
what'' s happening today that we are identifying your.
actually impressive payments to our, your commitments to social as well as ecological justice are just steady, and you the big heart, big vision, and you dream and.
you function towards that vision daily as well as you bring various other.
people in our community, our setting. That vision of a.
sustain maintain lasting for river and and also all around. I simply, I like you Jade and I'' m so delighted to see you here as well as for all you do. Thanks, thank you,.
Thank you, I'' m still figuring out Zoom. I actually appreciate the possibility.
to celebrate Jane'' s gains the last decade. Primarily Jane as well as I understood.
each various other for around twenty years. Not just has she always been an environ, began out calling not,.
Over the last years, he and I have a big friendship and contributed not only.
ecological advantages, however additionally social benefit. I'' ve volunteer also the.
residence make those of worth for their task, make.
them feel like individuals to actually include them in every little thing. Doing and also instruct them concerning value of all-natural setting on the river. And after that Jane as well as our like friends (laughs) so congratulations, Jane, such an excellent day for you and.
all your dedication.So thank you a lot for. permitting Leslie Arbor, the parks, remedy? Yeah, yeah, she ' s I'' m. the city ' s urban forest, for some of you more recent council.
Oh, you'' re so welcome. Yeah, she'' s my lead.
is my wind under my wing. (laughs) Wonderful. Well, Jane has actually been an.
honor also are familiar with you as well as work alongside you. Xmas day, you were.
You'' re remarkable to be what you. (indistinct) Thank you, thank you, I so value it. The words place'' t been and also been (laughs).
member, telephone call Terry Johnson to introduce the pronouncement concern honoring the brand-new year as well as to.
show to us arranged occasions celebration of today.

– Great, thanks, Mayor. First, I wan na thanks, Mayor Brunner for bringing this.
I think it'' s the first ever before. Persian new year occurred on Sunday and it'' s in Fari, it ' s. noun, which suggests brand-new day. It notes the beginning of springtime as well as it'' s celebrated
by.
of the season and appearing of the darkness of.
winter months as well as right into the light as well as the appeal of spring. It'' s been celebrated for over.
3,000 years throughout the world and also I'' m actually thrilled, our.
community right here in Santa Cruz is now honoring and celebrating.
the Persian brand-new year. So we are partnering with.
the Museof Art as well as Background as well as the society of Iranian.
literature and arts.And we ' re

organizing an event this Sunday, March 27th, from 12 to 3 o'' clock at the museof art and also background. We'' ll have a half sea of.
the 7 SS showed and there'' ll be a discussion about the Hine and also we have an unique, special, recognized guest that will be there. Her name is Simon B Devon,.
she'' s transforming 96 and also she is gifting the ma an and also silk woven rendition of the Cooper house very same day. So there'' s gon na be lots to celebrate as well as I wish that all of you around will certainly have the ability to join us, happy Persian new year to all those available. No following (indistinct) – Thanks for sharing that.Okay, now we ' ll carry on in the schedule as well as I have a few prior to we. move into our normal conference. Today ' s conference is being'broadcast live on tv channel. 25 as well as likewise streaming on the city ' s website,. cityofSantacruz.com.
If you desire to comment. Please silence your tv.
When you call as well as. listen through the phone.Please note
there is a delay in streaming.

If you continue to. listen on your tv or streaming gadget, you. may miss your opportunity.
As well as it ' s your time for public comment. Elevate your hand either.
Currently public remark is heard just on items. Advice is activity on and. not normal upgrade products that will certainly be open for. public remark, throughout today ' s conference are. numbers 32 on our schedule.
As well as our program is the city I ' d like to ask council participants. I ' d like to ask, like telephone call on attorney, offer a record on closed session.
responsibility insurance claims liability claims of Neil Bernardi Wright and also the cases of Armand Joseph ti, those are also detailed this mid-day on your authorization program as product number 18, council also had a conference with. its labor negotiation, labor negotiators.
concerning all bargaining teams as noted on. your blog post schedule, there was no reportable action,
. thanks, council will now review the conference, schedule the program as well as modify it as required a call get in touch with the city clerk. provide any kind of updates.There are no None this currently the moment for council members who report out on

at outside board committees and joint powers authority conferences that we have actually participated in for future meetings, please come prepared, offer an update on. any conferences or activities that took place since the. last council meeting to make sure that the council and. public.( indistinct) I will certainly start my left council member
Brown.- Mayor, I have a very short report today, initially I wished to not report. out on the (indistinct) county regional significant things at our last conference, our policy. workshop, we place ' t satisfied regular conferences. aren ' t my last report.But I did wan na highlight for folks who are listening and also. we all receiv a news release about this and

I ' m sure there will be a growing number of news coming regarding this, yet the city of Santa together with the local transf goal, will certainly be organizing a digital. open home, review section to 8 and 9 of the coastal rail route and also these. are the segments heading piece as you transcend the boardwalk.

Last we heard concerning a month back, they were that there would certainly be some, they thought they'' d be able to close out, but I don'' t think they'' ve gotten via all they ' re to be determined on that. Definitely that ' s quite why we ' re so thrilled for. You can quit along the street, but just desired to identify, I see you out there as well as I'' ve heard so several good things from individuals in the area who have actually gone down to function with you and with the homeless individuals who are in the bench ends to help clean up the area down there on the weekend breaks and also teach the individuals down there concerning the native plants.And I believe it ' s via those kinds of initiatives, we can actually aid, show individuals that they can add something to our community and they can make a distinction as well as aid up with individuals that are in actually dark places. Yeah, yeah, she ' s I'' m. the city ' s city woodland, for some of you more recent council.
Persian new year occurred on Sunday and it'' s in Fari, it ' s. noun, which indicates new day.Those that will certainly be occurring March 1st from 5 to 6:30
PM and also public dialogue is truly essential welcomed, give us your ideas on the style of rail route sections, so I.
just desired to highlight those, you can discover that I, it may get on the city'' s internet site,. but it ' s announced at our web site and I likewise intended to state that at our last maybe area, air source, area board meeting, we obtained an upgrade regarding funding.
for this (indistinct) electrical vehicle motivation programs for, companion public agency partners in Santa Cruz, Monterey and San Bernard.So this is this is moneying for electric lorries also for never ever bear in mind the real innovation, (laughs) sorry, I'' m gon na look it up truly promptly. (laughs) I'' m back on the air board, but'I ' m kind of still attempting to go the tidy air monitoring program, so and the city of Santa has actually received moneying with the cleaner monitoring program in the past. we'' re it ' s sustaining our work at the major coastline for the Bathroom, s and also parking location and we'' ll, I imagine our team will programs and also attempting to obtain some assistance for our shift to electric automobiles, so that which'' s concerning 1.6 million overall for the reach, so it'' s not a substantial quantity of money, but it, it has actually sustained our initiatives to pass, so.
points like ambiguous traffic and also assisting sustain public who are attempting to for.
light light vehicles. That was exciting information.
Okay, Council participant, Mayor. – Allow'' s see, a pair things to note, we we did have a Metro board conference last month, as well as there will be some extra products relocating ahead concerning some of the resources financial investments that are configured over the following years, some of those being including added electric buses fleet, as well as looking at actual hydrogen fuel cell buses as a possibility as well, there is a need for variety in the, as different, carbon reduced types of automobiles come online, so the resources resources board, which I sit on did approve a 10 year resources, spending plan financial investment reason me, capital budget simply in last week as well as that will be coming to the board on Friday this month, the City board conference is Friday at 9:00 AM, so that we products relocating ahead on that and also I believe additionally there'' ll be some news in some cases doing relating to the search for the new Chief executive officer for Metro as well, the various other product that I the other conference that I attend this month was the standard Cruz area groundwater agency and that body has submitted the groundwater sustainability strategy for the locations prepared seawater, those, those.
strategies have that strategy was submitted January and also city took on budget plan this past Wednesday evening as well as additionally is approving a 7.6 million grant from the state of The golden state and also bringing projects online for that, during the conference this month, also the there was a news.
that there is a dry spell drought advisory that the area, needed to create and also I'' ve seen statements in the paper however they are seeking people to sign up with that, that course consultatory board that does require to be, can be by state law state legislation that was passed in January, so any kind of members of the general public that may be interested in, joining that ought to view the business site restricted, limited sites restricted on that, on that committee.The just various other point

I have is the telephone call working group has not fulfilled, just recently, yet pertaining to phone calls past year as well as likewise that will be lots of their operate at the 10th anniversary of the San cruise ship world surfing get, which is gon na be hosted out at lengthy Marine laboratory, there'' ll be a community party, I five to 8:00 PM on Friday, April 9th as well as the, throughout the day period before the party, there ' ll be a, can be of different Marine and also seaside supporters, surfs as well as hosted by to conserve the waves and also they'' ll be doing additional deal with creating a new 10 year type of resource administration prepare for the world surfing,.
so once more, the general public event is a 5 day as well as the CEL, the party anniversary.
Santa Cruz was called the fourth globe surfing exist'' s 11 now worldwide and so that'' s a terrific event and also the.
cowork team information during that, throughout that daytime nighttime Directly missed the downtown management company conference, that'' s my report, thank you, Mayor. -Thanks, council Myers, council member Brown,.
did you have an inquiry? – I in fact had one more news, extremely timely news,.
sorry, I forgot I did this last that'' s That ' s. Okay, let ' s switch back and also have that announcement. Okay, I'' ll be actual. fast, so today those of you, several of you.
have, I recognize, have actually done this in the past, but meals on wheels has resumed it, your eating website and also we'' re commemorating this week and they are welcoming elected officials, join no support for these programs and join them for a distribution course or an eating website and also if there'' s a schedule, I, that we all receive an e-mail concerning this, but if anyone has an interest in this week, so we have a couple of days left, you'' re able to go by website at the Nelson.
I can call information.- Thank you, Mayor, mine is Flaco be authorized a R for.
special fire research also, sorry, we approved an RFP for special fire research, that'' s gon na be associated to possibly reorganizing fire security countywide, at am bag, we had an info.
item that was draft 45 transport strategy se.
lasting community method, for our public safety conference we there'' s a conflict, that night it started a bit late, we didn ' t obtain the products, we obtained some materials kinda late also and so we made a decision to delay the meeting as well as we'' ll be. conference this Wednesday. so we'' ll have an upgrade, next time we satisfy on public safety and security committee as well as I had a conflict with the climate activity task force as well as with downtown monitoring, I wasn'' t able to make. those, yet I do believe we'' re gon na have an unique meeting pertaining to the environment activity.
plan in the next weeks. That'' s my report, I ' ll. pass it back on you Mayor, -Thank you, council participant Cumming, council member Terry Johnson. -Hey, the member works with. gave the update from City. I ' ll just briefly include that we had a rather costly state and government legislative update and discussed the governor'' s spending plan consisting of a significant quantity of money that, that rail transportation as well as rail facilities,.
no emission lorries as well as active projects and environment durability and also (indistinct) jobs have all those dollar amounts, however take a long time.And then we spoke a little bit around, bipartisan facilities, framework. Costs as well as the, the, just how much bucks that would certainly convert to and also just how much we would take.
in our local neighborhoods. And we likewise discussed.
the construct back much better bill mostly that there wasn'' t a, a lot in there around which the pieces that were there, like affordable housing that Congressman Pines for would be the, like contribute to the Metro upgrade. We consulted with Santa Cruz.
city colleges board yesterday I think yep,.
the other day as well as talk about the children'' s fund that this we ' re,( indistinct )a little over 200,000 and also that doesn'' t take into consideration the extra boost 12, 20%, so we'' ll, we ' ll anticipate to see financing there as well as I'' ll let or vice what can state more about that and then we likewise got an update from city schools where they'' re at, where with their. projects, we discussed the fence of primary institutions as a result of health and also safety concerns and also our collaboration with parks and rec department at to check out whether it'' s have

some.So those were the major.
factors we spoke about in … Allow me see below, we did.
not, we have actually not consulted with the community.
programs policy recently, I am now an agent.
for area action board and had my initial meeting.
with the organization, there were some highlights.
offered on the programs that carry out that they'' re executing. as well as I believe the action.
that are most appropriate to our discussions are their job around rental support and simply generally, the effects that, that seeing on both proprietors and renters and the absence of the state'' s feedback,.
provid rental assistance. And after that we additionally chatted regarding their youth being homeless program, young people.
homeless demonstration program, in addition to their shift age youth real estate voucher program, that'' s producing some truly remarkable outcomes, ultimately the young people action network, which I work as the.
city represe met just recently with all the jurisdictional.
reps throughout the area, it was a youth led meeting, which is constantly fantastic and had the possibility to kind.
of share their vision for this collaboration.
with, with administrative reps, we we'' re working, directly with the young people network guiding committee to establish a.
young people liaison that'' ll work straight with the.
city on city issues.And I wish to just offer us, save the day for the city of Santa Cruz young people action network turn up.
that'' ll in collaboration with, with the teen center gon na occur April 27th at the London.
Nelson and center. So whole lots occur, thanks. – Thank you, council.
member, Terry Johnson, vice Mayor Watkin. – Yeah, many thanks Mayor Gosh. I believe coming in the direction of.
the end, everyone'' s virtually covered a lot of the shared meetings we'' ve went to, however the only thing I would actually include is that indeed, in terms of simply constructing on what council for telephone call Johnson raised with our measure, an efficiently passed at this moment, there'' s so much capacity.
for a much more integrated strategy to just how to make suggestions to the complete council, to truly sustain, particular populaces early avoidance and also prone young people and extremely exciting opportunity to aid people in our neighborhood, so I'' m. truly expecting the following iteration of what that looks like, council (indistinct) Johnson brought up that the health policies committee has a meeting turning up soon, so we'' ll have something to report on there afterwards meeting and afterwards in relation to both by 2 Mayor, I'' ll let you speak to that, I was incapable to participate in that conference at this last time we had and I think Bonnie brought up, the farmer'' s market,. there is a real rate of interest in desiring to have an irreversible place as well as not be moved often times and also just continuing to sustain the farmer'' s market whatsoever you can and also last but not least, I would certainly state that we did have.
our alignment conference for the brand-new of care which is the,, the new iteration of the, of the half.It was the half as well as currently it ' s the housing for health collaboration and truly a great deal of chance to progress a lot of methods to think of. how we ' re Le leveraging our various sources, consisting of the human solution division,. numerous jobs underway outreach, along with union buildings. So even more to find there as actually into what that new procedure will resemble and also council upcomings raised that we have a public safety and security board meeting that was so we wear ' t have any kind of support at this conference on'that thats my addition.- Allow ' s see, I will certainly add validating that our see Santa our next meeting is following week, to make sure that is upcoming in addition to our health and all.
policy committee conference that satisfies every other month, to ensure that will get on Monday as well as for the in 2015 council member, Keary Johnson as well as myself and council participant Myers, we'' ve consulted with the AAP API neighborhood group, a number of members and also they are planning, they are planning an occasion in may and also preparing and.
we had the ability to sustain them with a Memorial this previous weekend break at Harvey west park, so let'' s see, we also had impromptu income meeting and also in that meeting, we acted on profits step at our last council meeting.We had recomme made the recommendation for a sales tax obligation rise and we complied with up on several of activity products around that, what next steps are June and after that the by 2 conference this month there was conversation pertaining to the region team that they previewed the report that they have mosting likely to their board today, the board of managers,, the last 6 months.
and also the following performance steps, sanctuary as well as.
mobilization as well as rehousing wave update and also there was conversation on the gap in between.
price as well as housing as well as connection to homelessness plus financing update activity plan as well as I, I believe there their word memo, all right. As well as there'' s also there was conversation'on the city ' s three year action plan and also some of the structural. investments and also those that in addition to choice.
on the evict halt that is turning up at the end of March and several of the homeowners that area that have actually not have actually obtained housing, the state funding assistance as well as have not received financing.
aid yet, so we discussed leveraging research study on that, so I'' d state that was that those updates, I'' d additionally much like introduce that there are 2,, public hearings coming.
up concerning area political election, March, April 19 and also so I simply wanted to truly ensure that our public knew March.
29th, at 4:30 PM using Zoom as well as or you can call in.And that information is on the web site. That'' s it for those currently we will relocate to the approval program thing. These are things eight 20 on our agenda for participants of the general public who are streaming this.
meeting, if you would certainly such as to talk about items eight via 24 currently is the time to contact, there must be directions on your.
display, please keep in mind to mute your streaming tool as well as raise your hand by dialing star as well as on your or picking elevate hand in the webinars on your all products will certainly be acted on in one motion, unless a product.
is drawn by a council member, further go over council participants that council member Cumming, thank you, Mayor, I need, I was.
gon na pull item number 12 as well as I 15, 16 and also 19, oh, down, sorry, pull 12, alright, Talk about 15, okay.16 and also 19, thank you,.
council participant Brown, (indistinct) Watkin, I simply.
intended to make a brief discuss thing six, fine? We have thing number.
12, fold and also talk about 1515 therefore I will go ahead then as well as begin with and also start with thing 15 and I will certainly begin with council member Cumming. Thanks, Mayor, I just intended to thank members of the public as well as dealing with unionizing at Starbucks specifically union participant name, Joe Thompson, that'' s leading effort young 18 year old protestor. Who'' s making considerable progress with, signing up with in the unionization effort of the Starbucks workers and also so I wished to give him a shout out to all the employees that are available that are working with unionizing and just wan na give thanks to Mayor you as well as council participant Brown for assistance bringing.
this onward as well as council participant Brown for your.
management as well as taking the lead on this, thank you. Council member Brown thing number 15, Mayor and council member,.
cumings for your talk about this item for who were around listening, I simply intended to say a number of points, so this I, this thing gets on our agenda today, It'' s. a resolution of support for workers at Starbucks.
become part of an expanding wave of union as well as initiatives.
at Starbucks across the nation therefore the union is Starbucks United associated with SCIU conditioning to represent employees at.
over a hundred locations across the us, so this.
is an expanding national activity for employees that have a voice on the work have day discussing what issues to them concerning job wages movements that require to be with a firm similar to this often tend to get made extremely far from workers, so this is a method for workers to actually have, have that voice and Starbucks has responded by wave of unionization by involving actually usual strategy motivating.
as well as who are identified as organizers and taking activities at the national labor rail, this effort and also I think '' reason of that, that really not unsurprising, yet really, simply unreasonable (laughs).
that time editorializing bonds for administration,, via this, this,.
this major major point we assumed it was vital, interact our support, so I just and also I intend to give thanks to Joe Thompson,.
– Thank you, let'' s see
, we. Great, thank you so much, I just wanted to thank as well as recognize.
you in addition to customer, what this thing has to do with.
sending our support to our legislators, allowing.
them understand that we sustain that they pass 86-90, which.
is option avoidance act and essentially what that'' s. doing is transitioning The golden state far from unnecessary non-health secured.
single use cigarette smoking product and terminating use non.
rechargeable vaping tools in addition to cigarette and also stogie filters. The activity for cigarette.
as well as tobacco wastes is slow-moving and also it'' s always typically.
really responsive The golden state relocate this instructions, I think it really relocate the needle considerably within the country as well as after that past, so it begins here and this appreciation as well as assistance hopefully will assist obtain this over the movie, thank you for.
composing that Council participant Cumming that also talk about product number 16, yeah, likewise, I just wan na thank you Mayor and council participant walk for your support on this and I actually want give thanks to two area participants, Taylor lane and also Judkins, they'' ve been doing a whole lot of protestor deal with attempting to ban the bud prohibiting cigarette, but and also filtered cigarette products.Because what we ' ve

seen is that sometimes when individuals are at the beach, if they ' re smoking these cigarette'butts, which are constructed from plastic up ground and in the sea and also are a big contamination resource to our environment and likewise sets you back a great deal of money when it concerns attempting to cleanse up cigarette butts, whether they'' re in the sea or whether they'' re pathways in the area and also.
so they'' ve been advancing a huge effort to.
try to get territories throughout the nation to ban solitary usage filteringed system tobacco items and also I eagerly anticipate continuing dealing with them as we progress to see just how Santa Cruz can be a leader.
in this initiative as well. Thank you a lot council member, then we had a comment on number 19, yeah. I simply wan na express my admiration to staff as well as the area.
bringing this forward.This item is developed Juneteenth as a citywide vacation as well as back in 2020, when after the murder of George, I know that this has actually shown up as a topic of discussion as well as although it'' s really tough to type of make it, so then in time, simply trying to recognize just how we can you recognize, continue to have operations function in the city and additionally supply individuals the city has actually functioned, bring this onward. And I recognize we'' ve obtained job by council participants at previous meetings to move in this direction therefore I understand it'' s simply really interesting to see.
that Juneteenth will be a, a city vacation for city employees this year as well as I hope that organizations participate as well as other participate in and.
making this a vacation for their job paid vacation, thanks, council member, all right, Currently, step on to public comment as well as if there are any kind of members of the general public that would love to talk to any type of product on our approval schedule with the exception of.
item number 12, which has actually been told currently is the moment please increase your hand by calling R.
nine, we'' re picking elevate hands from the webinar of your, the timer will then be established, alright, so heading out to guests by phone number finishing as well as absolutely no 9 one, go on and press our and also mute yourself, yes, simon, hello, welcome.

– Thank you, I just wan na comment briefly on item 20, which connects to evergreen burial ground, I understand evergreen burial ground was started in the 1850s.
as well as was really actively made use of as the very first public burial ground in Santa Cruz for decades after that, but then fell right into overlook as well as desertion and is now possessed by the.
museof art as well as history. while this is simply a little advancement license I'' m delighted to claim this truly stands for the next stage in our decade long now initiative by volunteers throughout the neighborhood to enhance.
evergreen cemetery and not just make it.
a, a secure as well as beautiful place for individuals to check out, however a lot more so make it a place individuals learn regarding Santa Cruz background and also a full diversity of Santa Cruz history.
from our Chinese immigrant community, civil battle.
Experts, London Nelson family started the.
companies in Santa Cruz et cetera as well as really what this is, is the state,.
we obtained a state give from the California museums give program.Doesn ' t normally provide grants to burial grounds, however ' reason of its usage by thousands trainees that appear to find out local background are made use of on DDO, it ' s actually seen as the cultural and also so we got this grant to boost ease of access, which will simply make it better for everyone,, checking out evergreen. cemetery, not only for the older visitors that have trouble navigating our old dust course, however all of us out there therefore I ' m truly thrilled this, the infrastructure project that ' s gon na enhance the, a burial ground for years to come and also but I additionally wan na claim, I really wan na say thanks to parks division since the only means to make this occur was to accept Harvey west park and to put some available. parking Harvey, west park and burial ground, so.
we actually worked that out with the city and challenging to figure this out and obtain permits for it.But Eric Marlet was really handy.

the city a Les was really useful. And also so we ' re simply enjoyed be at this point and really prepared to I ' m agenda.

– Allow'' s see, a pair points to note, we we did have a City board conference last month, as well as there will be some extra products moving onward concerning some of the resources investments that are configured over the following years, some of those being including additional electric buses fleet, as well as looking at actual hydrogen gas cell buses as a possibility as well, there is a demand for diversity in the, as different, carbon reduced types of automobiles come online, so the capital resources board, which I sit on did authorize a 10 year capital, budget financial investment reason me, resources budget plan just in last week and also that will be coming to the board on Friday this month, the City board meeting is Friday at 9:00 AM, so that we things moving in advance on that and I think also there'' ll be some statement occasionally doing relating to the search for the brand-new Chief executive officer for Metro as well, the various other product that I the various other conference that I attend this month was the basic Cruz area groundwater firm and that body has sent the groundwater sustainability plan for the areas prepared seawater, those, those.
We'' ll have an update, next time we satisfy on public safety and security board and also I had a problem with the climate activity job pressure and also with midtown administration, I wasn'' t able to make. That'' s my report, I ' ll. Thank you, Mayor, I just wanted to thank participants of the public as well as functioning on unionizing at Starbucks in particular union participant name, Joe Thompson, that'' s leading initiative young 18 year old lobbyist. As well as so we ' re simply thrilled to be at this point and actually prepared to I ' m program.Our following guest is Joseph Thompson as well as then mute on your own,
there you go, thanks a lot, to start with, I'' d much like to to begin with once more, by thanking helpful Brownish as well as Justin Cumings for presenting this wonderful resolution in assistance of the Starbucks workers arranging not just at the sea water road, however also saw objective in previously, we have undergone a great deal of technique
ever given that we released our campaign returning January 21st, this year, 2022 and given that after that we'' ve United together as well as actually continuing our job battle, ever since we'' ve had concerning 8 more throughout all of California that I'' ve been assisting arrange those shops, the recent storage space data actually this last
Friday in mill valley where the lead coordinator at that store is just 17 years of ages and also simply showing that this motion is being led by youths who which'' s, that ' s the largest point
that resolution is battling for Newing to battle for is having youngsters and also voices in power that can speak reality to power, so again, thanks for all the council members who make a decision to go solution.It programs that

you guarantee workers that are, who are arranging versus a multi billion dollar firm that has actually picked to place profit for companion as well as companions that these places of employees are the ones who require one of the most sustain right currently, '' cause we ' re in a battle not only safe arranging rights for us, yet to continue the worker movement and also truly branch out labor, we'' ve been getting to out to other neighborhood cafe, other national adjustments as well, now and really beginning to to unionize doors and also we'' re not gon na back down. We ' re not gon na stop obtaining as well as it'' s, it ' s so great to have the support of, of union members and also union leaders who want change on the planet, so thanks all once more and I wish you do pass this resolution to reveal that Dan Cruz stands, are you solid and go get yourself a union solid mug of say thanks to you.Thank you,

Joseph Thompson, our next guest hiring on approval agenda products, product 12, I am enjoying you. Yeah, aye. As to thing number 14, the funded left us proposition of brainwashing, after that marital relationship between radical social justice groups with environment lobbyists, no, no and also empty, however, this is not simply a harmless gold, be like extravaganza instance of (indistinct) A to Z leftist negative word item like environment justice, however it is additionally quite a startling egotistical public financial demand meant to change right into a mass prospective misappropriation of public monies, mounting an unelected bureaucrat drawing city income to head a local union, leftist political social justice Partnership kinds past the reach of individuals focused on the complete spectrum of leftist, ideological conditioning, power, radical social justice warrior program with the hope of draw in pressure grants and power to a rather unidentified, but plainly left this objective as opposed to the particular goal of boosted local sustainability, this proposed range of so-called compensated justice groups and local climate professionals calls partly outside the application'' s work, after that diagram, I stopped working to see exactly how bigotry, justice, equity, addition and also variety training makes for one Booger'' s worth of sustainability impact
, however I never got infected by the college message modernist, Neo Marist conditioning, clearly some did, It'' s seriously crucial to quit the shunt of public tax cash that fund left wing radicals, I request this unacceptable slide of hand overarching complete radical left this schedule request for funds by an enormously paid too much SJW city bureaucrat.He refused now as well as set back for a much more restricted range reword with a sole concentrate on sustainability.
I take sustainability issues seriously, yet I wear ' t pirate it to suggest anything apart from a focus on the deficiency or damages of Earth'' s natural sources, which sure just can not proceed that the environment modification dollars spent will mainly additionally be thrown away to understand certain disable environment result is an additional aspect that additionally earns less preferable. I oppose the controversial items like thing 15 as well as 19, yet unless bullet, I wear'' t have time to.Thank you exist any various other that would certainly such as on products with the exception of item 12 currently is the moment to increase your hand by pressing celebrity 9 on phone or choose elevate hand in the, I will certainly after that bring it back and ask for a vote on the continuing to be products of the permission schedule for relocating on the hold product number as well as I see council participant Myers, staff member Brownish soft council participant Myers, sorry, I'' ll make a movement on the continuing to be Motion by council participant Myers, 2nd recognize council participant Brown. I'' d like to ask the staff, take a duty call ballot. – [Staff] Mayor council participant discourse Johnson, Cumming. – Aye. – [Clerk] Brown. – Aye. – Aye. I'' m gon na I
' m gon na. ballot aye, yet I wan na– Sorry, I number, I
just wear ' t. really feel like there ' s sufficient.

I guess it '

s a no vote,. – Aye. Mayor Brunner.
– Aye.- [Staff] Let ' s see, movement. passes with six yeses, one on all things. One no on thing council participant gold app. We will currently come back to product number 12 and also council member. Cumming, you drew this thing, yeah, there was just one, thanks Mayor, there was simply one small change that I assumed or one minor information that was left out of the friendly, the pleasant modification and the minutes regarding item number. 17.1, homeless action programming, quarterly upgrade, homeless reaction, activity strategy, homeless staffing as well as homeless reaction funding, in the friendly amendment that. was made by the Mayor was deal with the county court 24 7 non-law enforcement.
alternate emergency crisis action program at, or government on risk-free funding possibilities which accepted.And but somebody had connected to me due to the fact that we had stated having words focus on assistance meant to be in there at hour eight min 29 in the video clip from the last conference I brought up, whether we can consist of focus on Mayor said yes, in a friendly change which was approved by them and therefore, but then. considering the mins of the, sorry, then checking out the mins of the the min the last council meeting, the prioritized.
component was overlooked. So the only thing I was raising was simply having, so it was mirrored in the minute that it claimed focusing on, state that appropriate was made as well as I clerk Shrub up, yeah, yeah, thank you, council participant, you directed it out, I I'' m presuming you, maybe place'' t got the e-mail that I sent out the other day to allow you people recognize that was made, we did verify in the video clip and also focus on, reflect, thanks significantly, okay, thanks, audio speaker, that suggests we will pertain to a vote on item 12 from the March 8th conference and I have a phone call Don, put on'' t assume we have a, I don ' t believe we have a movement Needs to bent on public remark And we need to tipping in advance of myself, so for thing 12, we'' ll bring it out to public remark and also if you want to comment.
Council member Myers seconded, – Aye. Johnson, participant Johnson. – Aye.
one missing, thanks. That ends our agenda items. Proceeding right into the program, we.
will currently start public hearing and also next step is program, number 25, 25 is a public hearing for 2020 2023. United States department of housing.
a city growth called head action strategy.
for members of the public were streaming this meeting,.
if this is a thing you desire to talk about currently is the time to hire utilizing the directions on your display, the order for this item will certainly be a present of the item by team adhered to by inquiries from council, we will.
then take public comment and after that return to the.
council for liberation and activity, I would like to currently existing, I think it'' s lake. our manage, say thanks to you.Go in advance and also my display, this is the CDBG and home action strategy and.
budget plan public hearing. I'' m Tiffany lake real estate as well as monitoring expert and economic growth likewise right here today as our real estate.
and growth manager today to obtain funding suggestion from this will enable us to maintain me moving on as well as hit our staying devote our annual activity, this is the annual activity timeline, we'' ve currently experienced a great deal of steps in that procedure, most recently we brought programs committee and also the first council approval enable us to remain on this line as well as strike our continuing to be goals and bring it back, second public hearing where the HUD budget is settled, then a devote the HUD in may,.
so the referrals we'' re today are all based upon estimates. Our CDBG as well as residence funds change a great deal throughout the years, however, for.
this upcoming program year we'' re estimating will certainly have 605,000 our area advancement programs and we'' re estimating 425,000 CDBG, we ' re likewise estimating program income, our payments on lendings made with CVG funds of 55,000 and prior your funds readily available.
absolutely free programming at 60,000, providing us an overall offered of 7 of that management.
is established by quest formula 32,000, we likewise have rehab rehab administration for lending maintenance grants made with CPG funds at.
5,000, to make sure that offers us 583,000 readily available for.
programs as well as projects.This year, we got 4 applications demand for tactical financing programs. Currently these are all subject. to a 15 %activities cap, however Nova View is not subject to this cap ' trigger it ' s neighborhood. based advancement organization, our C B. O, so the complete requests go to 190 F is advising. to fund all of the programs.
In 2015 ' s funding degrees. from the group facility to historical funding. degree decreasing at 35,000.
We suggest to not. boost financing levels for any of the programs up until we understand our real word quantities from HUD to make certain that we don ' t surpass that. 15 %civil services cap, that ' s an overall of'185,000 for programs, have some updates for.
some CDG funded programs for the first two quarters.
of the present program year.So that '

s from July, 2021 via December, 2021, so the first one is for 2nd harvest food financial institution, they have actually offered over 1.4 million pounds of food to Santa Cruz, really some even more updates from the familiar center, they have actually supplied a great deal of beneficial solutions to.
the community, including 50 hrs of advocacy job over 700 customers, along with assisting to.
provide 3 40 houses to beach flex community.
center, 36 use we'' re able to take part in.
the summer season entertainment tasks in the lunch program. 50 young people had one-on-one.
homework tutoring for afternoons each week and 18.
moms and dads were offer with medical aid to assist with remote knowing, California,.
rural legal aid has aided 53 Santa Cruz citizens are 41 homes in the very first two quarters of year and of those 24.
families have actually obtained.

( indistinct) likewise obtained CDBG ask for financing for project, the Depot park remodelling will certainly be for.
bathroom restorations and also renovations to.
classroom park, the Depot park structure, we also got a request for the Santa Cruz ACE.
project of its budget-friendly housing for those living, with human resources HIV or help in Santa Cruz and also.
we additionally had a request from homeless infrastructure that will assist sustain emergency encampment needs with the purchase.
hygiene systems, hookups and various other website preparation, so our overall requests below are little over 500, 5,000, but we only have hundred 98,000 continuing to be of CD financing,.
the staff is recommending to money the Santa Cruz project demand at their asked for 90,000,.
the Depot park remodelling at 62,000 which the bulk of the financing go homeless framework are all of the staying, so 242,000, if we do get even more than we have estimated, we advise that all of the continuing to be funding must all go to homeless inform, that'' s an overall of 398,000 job on summary, It'' s 185,000 of programmable CDG funds, community programs and 398,000, in a similar way for house, again, we'' re collaborating with estimates in our price quote of the.
upcoming give, 425,000 approximating program earnings of 125,000.

And also again, management is established by HUD formula, 55,000, we have a picture allot for community real estate.
development organizations of percent of the give must go to among these organizations as well as.
we have a brand-new organization accredited this year for area real estate that will be eligible to use the funds. we have previous years financing of 1.5 million as well as an overall house spending plan of one factor this year, we received two.
applications from funding. Both are 100% inexpensive task. The first all-natural job.
is a 20 unit solitary area occupancy or SRO task, it just mosted likely to planning.
commission and still requires to visit council for.
plan growth license, be obtaining its coastal license and also design license in the spring, the asked for 1.5 million, a little over 20% complete project, a spending plan of 6.9 million, the other,, application was for.
the City Pacific terminal, north task as well as 95 system family members project, the bulk of two in room a little over 160 rooms in total amount, the project has actually already gotten its preparation license and got its state.
95 systems will certainly be established aside and also assigned for homeless.
agents that suggested that we required to.
New project ' s ability to assist.
three outside reviewers that all placed task of the natural, so since there ' s not adequate funding to fund both tasks, ask personnels recommending to. fund the leading ranked task from north at 1.8 million.It is a HUD advised ideal method to fund less at higher.

degrees, to make sure that tasks and also are not marketed that will leave 182,000 available, in addition, city staff is also servicing the house. a, which will provide 1.2 numerous funds,. these UN house populaces. We are seeking input to. aid us to prioritize the very best use of funds, please really feel free to onward the studies, learn more of the community that can be. [email protected] slash programs, so once more,. based upon the preliminary
budget suggested by council today, we ' ll
have the ability to prepare 22. action strategy, we ' ll bring that again for a 2nd. public hearing where the HUD
spending plan will certainly final and afterwards we will certainly submit the annual activity plan on May 15th pending will certainly appear as early as July 1st programs later on. in the loss project.Now we have time for any inquiries, thanks, council members have any concerns council participant come, I did have a concern particular pertaining to the financing homelessness, knowing that we ' re placing 14 million towards that currently which oftentimes we fail on being able to assist sustain budget friendly real estate project, which is in length of being homeless, I ' m just questioning if you can direct out. kind of especially what ' s meant to go to ' reason you recognize, we have a whole lot of funds of putting in the direction of this thing as well as wan na make certain that we ' re additionally placing funding towards various other needs like afford real estate related homeless, thanks for that. The survey itself,. initially two inquiries list every one of the offered uses the funds. So it is a bit limited due to the fact that it ' s residence funds, so similar,. similar to the funds that we have each year this funding has to go for either economical real estate. That ' s specifically targeted for homeless. It can go with lessee.
based rental assistance is paid directly to property owners and also there ' s some unique housing therapy, real estate targeted case monitoring. type solutions that are permitted, however they all need to
have a( indistinct )with. housing and afterwards there'' s a great amount of constraints on exactly which kinds of solutions are allowed, so we we ' d love input for everybody, yet it ' s those 4 main usage, could you simply, could you provide those off once more?, yeah, so it is board of real estate advancement targeted specifically. for the homeless occupant based rental assistance, repayments are made straight to proprietors specifically for those who homeless are. in danger of homelessness special real estate counseling
. as well as being homeless and to real estate with unique certification.And the various other is situation supervisor, thank you. Let ' s see, I had an inquiry. for the lawyer present,
thanks. My concern, among the requests in the presentation is an item that originated from the real estate authority as well as

I. am a real estate authority commissioner, so I assume I would certainly need to use myself from that if Yes, my suggestion would certainly be that the activity the council tackles that different which as participant of the housing board that you Thank you, so the thing house financing, all-natural bridges. SRO, please validate that ' s the real estate authority advancement bridges, An application from the real estate authority and partnership nonprofit.Thank you, we ' ll take. any kind of action independently.
Are there any questions. from council members before I bring it out to public? Okay, I will now head out to. public discuss this item as well as are wanting a participant of the public as well as intending to talk about.
The 2 to 3 us department of real estate as well as urban growth activity. As well as when it ' s your time to talk, you ' ll hear an announcement. Okay, guest and I ' m not.
I will certainly bring it back to. guidance for as well as movement. The council member Myers. as well as council participant cummings and also they are'all cubicle items.Second, fine, so we have a. movement Myers participant Cummings and also may we have a roll phone call ballot?- [
Clerk] Thank you, Mayor.
Member Johnson.- Aye.- [Clerk]

Brown.- Aye.
With any luck that ' s thank you. Okay, so that passes consentaneous with council member Gold absent. If this is an item you would such as comment on now is
.
my name ' s Sarah Noisy, Supervisor Butler stated,.

I am a senior organizer with the innovative preparation. department below at the Santa Cruz.
Initially off, I simply. wan na say thank you to all of the community members that wrote in, I am simply constantly so thankful.
to benefit an area where the general public is so. engaged as well as so thoughtful in our discourse, we got a lot of
really thoughtful meticulously worded comments.And I truly appreciate that, so there are a couple of points that I do think, are a little complicated and also I understand why they '

re confusing, so with any luck I can, those below pretty pretty conveniently, so allow, simply share this PowerPoint, fine. So we heard problems listened to these adaptable thickness devices are gon na enhance density. We heard that nothing else. cities in the nation do this thing, we listened to that this proposal is gon na boost the height of buildings that built or that this proposition ought to have full EIR of it very own, we also heard worries about water and also not having enough for any new advancement and also then we also simply heard a great deal of stress and anxiety concerning the manner in which legislations as a result of transform in sexual as well as kind of just this unease regarding understanding what ' s boiling down the. line, so I simply wan na be actually clear that the SROs which exist currently and also have actually existed for our, the existing code was adopted in like 95. So at'the very least those 25 years we ' ve had specifically SROs as we. have them now today. and also that remains the sort of real estate that we would certainly permit. and also there is no density stand developed for SROs throughout the zoning code as well as. specifically in the general plan, they are spared. to any basic thickness categories concerning no various other city ' s are lots of locations in the us that utilize a completely space code where. uses are very gently managed and also density is ruled out, but they regulate is. the form of a structure outside, how it. associates to the street.And after that certainly, open room and also car park requirements support residential growth as well as those kind of press of. domestic growth and those sort of push the amount of building room that can be offered, to make sure that is. very, that is comparable.

I'' m gon na I
' m gon na. That ' s especially targeted for homeless. Allow ' s see, I had an inquiry. SRO, please confirm that ' s the housing authority development bridges, An application from the housing authority as well as partnership nonprofit.Thank you, we ' ll take. And when it ' s your time to talk, you ' ll listen to a statement.This step towards flexible thickness systems is kind of a midway
step, a more kind based code, doing a fully kind based change is a very big task as well as something for another time,, as much as altering height, this proposal is refraining anything
to transform that building envelope, we'' re
not talking regarding raising Levels in all, we'' re not discussing increasing Levels either for conventional adjusting jobs or for density reward project, there is no adjustment in Levels adjustment in no modification in the car park requirement, no adjustment in the quantity of office that is required for any one of these devices compared to what is enabled today for a.
small possession unit.The general strategy did consider SROs once again, as establish our. dental professional most extreme kind
of real estate that our plan permit when the E R was safeguarded the basic strategy. So it is our idea that this quantity of was considered, this quantity of variety of units was considered,. but we ' re chatting around is that existing. capacity and also evasion the method it can made use of.
Whereas tiny ownership. 20, so that it matches up with where SROs are needed to have a complete set of (indistinct )features, we are recommending to add, not eliminated, we are including suggesting to include a demand for commercials to be consisted of in three area districts in the. There we are, what we are recommending is to order our existing plan that predates the basic plan, we just ands that, but so whatever else is not transforming, I won'' t slide, however primarily nothing concerning height testing about.
quite rapidly, so I just wan na sort of offer an instance if we check out type of a 14,000 to 15,000 square foot website, so concerning a 3rd of an acre, let ' s chat regarding what we. Can build there? What could be developed there today? So if we have that website in a zone district that permits up a 30 volume units per acre, which is much of which is. the criterion that puts on great deals of our PC zone, you might obtain concerning car park. an open area'and also tale limit.You might obtain to about. square feet developing room because building envelope. There ' s some room for. blood circulation and trash rooms secure a thousand feet. and then you figure, you can access that density. You ' re a third of the acre. You can strike 10 houses and split by about around nine square feet.

To ensure that would be the.
typical dimension of the homes that can be developed on that. site'would certainly be 900 square foot. That would consist of 2 houses scheduled for reduced revenue household.
So the adjustment that would come in these flexible density devices', this is exactly how we ' re envisioning.It is that the versatile. density systems would certainly be added top of those 10. Your density limitation is 10. That relates to whatever that is over 650 square feet of dimension. You can obtain 10 units. that are that larger dimension. We ' re managing the very same. 10,000 square foot building with a thousand feet for flow, 9,000 square feet that were.

currently offering up amongst systems.
You might get 10 homes at 700 square feet, plus five more units devices home in the flexible thickness device group at smaller sized studio size square feet.
This would be a total of 15 residences with three reduced earnings. home and these projects would certainly look similar outside. You would certainly see more mailboxes, fine.
You would see even more mail boxes if they have, to the extent they have. ground flooring access, you might see even more entrances. The form of the. building is not altering, a 3 tale framework still. requires vehicle parking project similar to this on the right contrast.
that with an SRO task, which is already permitted today in all of these very same area areas. So as opposed to those 10. houses as well as reduced revenue residences with an SRO task, so SROs. need a little less vehicle parking as well as require much less open space.So that structure kind could.
be a bit larger that structure envelope we ' re.
approximating you might fit. If your house, sRO homes.
are around 300 square feet, you might fit 35 of. them on the exact same parcel. And of those seven would be booked for really reduced income housing. That ' s kinda the. distinction that you ' ll see that in between standardized. development as well as SRO development,

significantly a lot more housing,.
These are the division on particular, which is an SRO growth. And currently I understand individuals are stating, but you ' re not showing the thickness. Allow ' s look at what
you really do if you'really wanted to everything whatever, so what ' s shown revealed.
down to two 20 square'feet, to ensure that on the same site would certainly let you obtain the 40 residences of which eight for low earnings helps, so you can see that this is somewhere in between the existing OU ordinance that we have and the existing SRO ordinance that we have and in every situation that SRO regulation is gon na offer housing for even more houses, so I do wan na address likewise this inquiry about S 35 discussed in several several of the e-mails
that we obtained and I think this is an actually vital factor people who sanctuary ' t heard of SD 35, just to sum up that S is a state costs that a couple of years ago that essentially exempt certain types of, from a complete set of our public, our basic public process, excuse me, they obtain. exempt from look for introduction and after that it simplifies the public procedure that we ' re familiar with experiencing on those, the most current instance of that, of every person below might understand folks paying attention might not, is the people that came in at 8 3, 1 water road, presently the city,, any kind of proposition that is available in and consists of greater than 50, 50% or more of the systems as committed cost effective housing, they ' re qualified to this streamlined testimonial that our typical evaluation procedure we are servicing purpose. domestic style requirements, those are coming forward before your council in the following 2 months.Those will assist reclaim several of that layout control, yet basically. when we ' re evaluating for SB35, we ' re truly limited in what we can for, we just evaluate for points that are unbiased requirements that can be determined as well as validated as well as are available beforehand', so 35 uses. to various territories in various means, based on their development towards fulfilling their. regional housing demands allocation as well as our market price appropriation for the following cycle, which starts at the beginning of 2024, is that we need to generate by 20 by 2031, a minimof 1600, over 1600 new market price home and they evaluate us midway the housing cycle with that duration, so we have to have fifty percent of much housing entitled entire building permits by the end of 2027, that 803 real estate.
devices by the end of 2027 which is a lot more than we have actually integrated in the last 7 years, so we, in order to satisfy this goal, you. need to almost double our manufacturing, so just to be clear, this is state loss, if we have the ability to fulfill this, if we ' re able to meet this four hr market price manufacturing,. then S3 five continues that does today and also has actually applied for the last 5, 6, 7 years and also. we ' ve had one application.So it just uses projects that offer 50 %or even more budget friendly. housing, if we missed out on that, we went down a more rigid category where whatever that we accept right here in Santa Cruz would certainly be done. is almost whatever. I think I shouldn almost everything that we do, multifamily housing would certainly end up being qualified for 35 ' reason. drop down here where any kind of job that gives 10% affordable housing certifies that. as well as our inclusionary portion is 20%, that would certainly be virtually every little thing,
so there are a few exclusions to state regulation, however so we ' re worried regarding that
, we ' re interested.

in preserving whatever local control the state permits us to have.
As well as among the methods that we do that is by allowing and discovering ways where we can get system developed, to make sure that ' s type of the factor for bringing
this onward as well as trying to find ways that we can sustain. production of these smaller devices, so I wish that dealt with a minimum of a few of the inquiries you have, this is our recommendation, it published in your, I won ' t read it the second and after that also resolution writer send the as well as with that said questions, Council member Cummings, say thanks to. you a lot for that information, a few of that practical, thank You and also thanks for attempting to resolve those questions that have actually been being available in because we ' ve been getting a great deal of emails, I do wan na see if we can attend to the affordability due to the fact that,, doesn ' t appear like there ' s anything that ' s making these restricted budget friendly devices and also there ' s debate over the cost by design type of notion, I ' m one of the individuals who wear ' t truly agree with that, ' reason. you recognize we have studios that are going 2,800 a month, and also they ' re continuously. rising price in time, diminishing the dimension of the unit. doesn ' t obtain price, so I ' m simply asking yourself if the suggestions that we ' re reducing the size,. yet we ' re not price in terms of making it be limited, then what much more could we. do to make these systems in fact economical as well as not. just economical principle?- That ' s a really good question.So, the only means to. Assurance affordability is with the right and we ' re speaking regarding we ' re doing a market where real estate'is, so there ' s not abundant real estate? It ' s not like you have of. selections, whatever'your budget plan is.
It ' s not like you have. That ' s simply the reality of our market, so within that kind of constraint. ' Reason they wear ' t have a car and also now.
SROs do have a various I need that have to be you really reduced revenue rather than reduced earnings, so I assume there are points that we'could speak concerning that, however I wear ' t, I put on ' t understand that there ' s a concession that we with, there are giving ins we can provide that will decrease expense? And with lower costs comes the. opportunity that reduced rent adhere to, yet it ' s no assurance the market is always gon na set that as well as our'market has a great deal of influences. on it and is honestly restriction, there ' s not a fund, so difficult one, you have something you wan na include, currently, you, you covered it, with the inclusionary. remarks, the inclusionary applies to this for 20 %at reduced revenue, which is 80% of the location median revenue and also as Sarah stated for SROs, we do have a various threshold it ' s, it ' s 50 % of the location median income.Now that does give. that provides an automatic qualifi, or I believe it ' s a 35 %state density bonus SROs, sROs qualified for 50, thank you as well as our other. typical inclusionary qualify.- Great, thanks for that. explanation, thank you. thanks, council member.
Brown, Mayor and also you there'for the discussion. Aid clear up extremely complex. idea of I presume I desired to ask as a comply with up, what we ' re hearing is that the initial uses, however my understanding is that. inclusionary uses only to the base of any type of project. So every one of these F views. with infinite density. Good am I so I think, I reconsider, we'' re blending density bonus offer. with our base zoning, so FDS are
being are component. of our zoning, right? So they would certainly enter into. that base and inclusionary is absolutely needed on those, okay.
So thank you for that, I, that and I think that ' s component of my concern, I didn ' t a situation with density incentive, like a thickness perk. task scenario with Fs, the situations offered us, which
were extremely useful and I assume that is where I ' ve listened to most of, because when you speak about an oral bonus offer job where you have essentially a base, then that unlimited density a density reward piece of it then possibly, I mean, there ' s absolutely nothing that would certainly quit a designer look for a thickness perk and after that all of those, of height as well as trouble guidelines that you state are, remain in the we have the capability to.
manage that disappear.They ' re required to. supply those discussions. So again, I ' m attempting to identify exactly how we shake that, I suggest', it ' s very hard to recognize.
So I think it ' s, it ' s, I think I ' m simply trying to recognize my under, I presume my understanding. ' Cause I think this is for a. whole lot of individuals get utilized, what we ' re talking about altering is the base of zoning, so basically with an FDU, you can get a perk of thickness without any waste,
we would keepMaintain I showed you, where you go from 10 systems to 15 devices, when you add ADU, you ' re still.
' Reason I simply wan na clear that thickness that doesn ' t a density restriction, not right, there ' s restrictions, we do SROs, so let ' s look at an SRO job actual quick and also simply see exactly how they did that. Moving from right here, this is a proposal that all of our zoning demands, this is a demand for.
So they ' re gon na be and also they can be smaller, right?

' Reason they wear ' t have an automobile as well as now. SROs do have a different I need that have to be you very reduced revenue instead than reduced earnings, so I assume there are things that we'could chat regarding that, yet I put on ' t, I don ' t recognize that there ' s a concession that we with, there are giving ins we can provide that will decrease cost? So I assume it ' s, it ' s, I think I ' m just trying to understand my under, I think my understanding. ' Cause I think this is for a. whole lot of folks get made use of, what we ' re speaking concerning transforming is the base of zoning, so essentially with an FDU, you could get a reward of density without any waste,
we would would certainlyMaintain ' Cause I just wan na clear that density that doesn ' t a thickness restriction, not right, there ' s restraints, we do SROs, so let ' s look at an SRO job genuine quick and also just see how they did that.They could be 50 feet on
average, so this has to fulfill all of the standards
that are in the zoning code as well as in the location strategy as well as we assess this to make certain that it feeds every one of our requirements, that'' s the base and afterwards they obtain the thickness benefit and you go this developing strategy, this perk proposition, so because this is an SRO proposition, they are supplying 20% of their devices at extremely reduced income, which state density bonus claims them entitled them 50%, so this is 50% perk, so it went from hundred, five systems to 233 devices therefore at this point when just when the thickness rewards gotten begin to have to forgo website criteria like elevation and also flooring area ratio.But we do have that. So yeah, I imply that ' s state legislation, right? So there ' s nothing that we ' re doing right here that would certainly circumvent state law or that would certainly avoid state therefore the choice that you ' re is regarding device size, actually. I indicate, if you go, if we return approximately our circumstance that we looked at you can have 10 big homes, you put a density bonus offer on that for 35 %, you get 13, big houses, pick 2 that are reserved for low earnings health,
or you can do right here it ' s or you can do 15 homes', you do a 35 %density benefit my calculator out, yeah, 20, yes. That provides you five more incentive systems. You obtain up to 20 devices and they still have to meet simply like very same average dimension and also on a circulation, right, so like they wouldn'' t all come to be workshops, right, you wouldn ' t with the thickness bonus offer, we wouldn'' t simply suddenly every one of them be 400 per foot systems, they still need to match that base base, so yes, I suggest, that'' s what you ' re considering', that ' s the, that ' s the fact of the bonus, so a 20, a 20 device job however, is not gon na be'right, the 20 system project
that might, Might go to four,

? It ' s not gon na go to 5 or six or two, however got it.Council member Brown, did you have any type of other concerns? Not. Any kind of various other council member concerns Guess I just from, I comprehend the something we ' re doing now, it ' s remained in the docket for some time, certainly fulfill real estate, you know, however this is not called for today, right, there, I imply, there'' s absolutely nothing that ' s compeling us to adopt this statute right now, yes That ' s Yet it is, I indicate, your discussion was, was really practical today and also really what I understand, put individuals here, individuals hesitate of having large developments.We ' ve been via this for over two years currently out, they'' re terrified as well as they have this anxiety and also I recognize it. I imply you reside in a.
area for a long period of time and you type of think it'' s. all gon na look the very same throughout the years and after that new legislations. Quality that are offered or.
purchased as well as people have a tendency to. You don'' t wan na make sources. out of those investments. As well as so you you end up with an unexpected five, six, 7 building.
so a lot of that expectation. Component of it, component of state.
regulation just how we become part of it is like SB35, which had.
Your, your total layout of a structure is constantly going to be assisted by those, those standard floor location proportion, all those points that we know that are on the books now exactly how does this, where, just how does the style,.
how do the objective design conventional kind of concerned play right here? I imply, I believe.
most of us assume objective style criteria is a.
location for the community expression of what individuals want to see as a little bit extra right as well as this that have any bearing on what we finish up seeing in our neighborhoods,.
or exactly how do they– How does it associate with that kinda story? I'' m kind of looking at that timeline of all the things that.
the planning division is and also so currently below'' s this other, then you wear ' t need to go into a lot of information, but perhaps simply a few remarks to aid under stand, if this got on the publication we pass our objective criteria continues to relocate our more comprehensive preparation set of tools in, I think into.
a location where there'' s possibly extra predictability,.
even more understanding around what things will appear like in the future offers ideally more assistance in concerns to the sort of standards that we desire in the appearance that we want, however we'' re still not rather there yet, right, so is that not real or true? I'' m very, I ' m, I ' m discussing this extremely opaquely, but I'' m hoping it ' s kind of, I ' m just trying to assist, assist the community understand that there ' re not gon na be 11 stories, call buildings beside them in the following, attempting to, attempting to sort of put this in context of how you are kind of.
moving further defining what aesthetic in any kind of kinda zone in the city, how long that will take, there will be tasks that make it through in between once in a while, sorry, Is that sorry? Yeah, that'' s I imply that ' s fine, so so the objective requirements is RA is like fast (indistinct) mm-hmm, excuse me', we ' re planning to be at the planning commission on April, whatever second conference in April 23rd, fifth, something like that, the Thursday of.
that 3rd week of April, so initial 21st, okay, thanks.

( laughs) April 21st mark your calendar. so those, what those requirements will do is so I'' ve talked a great deal concerning exactly how we have the building envelope as well as that, this ordinance is changing the structure envelope, those.
unbiased requirements can press on that building in ways that our zoning statute presently doesn'' t right. So we can ' t reduce the total like mask that can enter the building, we can'' t lower that the one that people are gon na get thrilled about or is the 2.75 location ratio that'' s pairs locations on and on water road we can'' t lower that total floor location.
proportion, yet we determine just how it'' s how it ' s positioned on the site and also just how that video footage is used, so among the things you'' re. gon na see our change zone between smaller structures and also smaller, much shorter structures that are next door, you'' re gon na see requirements for expression on facades as well as demands for materials and also develop to ensure that,, we get buildings that while they may be larger, they'' re gon na be larger, I indicate, that ' s just the true. issues, these buildings are gon na be bigger than what ' s there now.Cause most

of the city is really underbuilt contrasted to what it'' s permitted to develop, yet they'' re gon na be more appealing structures than what we'' re able to regulate to now now, so we'' re gon na have as well as the density bonus ed, a few of those standards, they can, you recognize, you, if there'' s. a physical preclusion from the amount of density incentive on the website, then the criteria have to as well as it'' s tough to make that disagreement for features of the products as well as expression as well as reform as well as quality of open area, quantity of open room, you could make that debate, you could make that disagreement and also height.
The item that we have a little bit of a control over is exactly how subject to SD 35 are we? Is that, that law that truly,. I understand that inquiry is gon na
come up, but yet about concerning density.
getting rid of that alternative for them, we are'gon na. be guiding them regarding exactly how make that structure. appear like it belong below, that ' s valuable, that'' s helpful.Okay, thank you, thanks, Mayor Myers. I suggest, council participant Myers, I just intended to add another point, Mayor, yes. Principal organizer for innovative planning. I just desired to add onto Sarah'' s aims too and simply reiterate that the, the tiny devices before you currently with the FTUs don'' t change any structure type today that would certainly be built under.
our present goal requirements, so as well as any type of, any feel and look of any domestic.
constructing that was sent right currently wouldn'' t change under, under this FTU ordinance, It ' s simply about adding density on the inside of that structure, so no place would certainly there be something that would certainly look or feel or be taller?, nothing would be different than today, It would certainly simply be what'' s on the inside and also possibly.
Thank you, that'' s also thank you, Mayor. Thank you so a lot at this time, I do see raise, I likewise had a for additional time that was accepted, so I will begin with your hand is raised to go in advance, Mayor, this is, this is Martin, I have just one question prior to public comment, if Okay, go ahead, I simply, I believe it was responded to, however I simply desired to make certain that in regards policy should, if that'' s being suggested there ' s, recognizing from
staffTeam
' Reason we wear
' t wan na be. Just how can you simply state that? Is that exactly how you see it
?
about that a little much more. So 5, as I pointed out,.
relates to territories based upon just how well they'' re. conference that local housing requirement allotment as well as there.
are two different rates. Some territories in.
the state like Santa Cruz are meeting the majority of their.
groups in of the RHNA and so in those jurisdictions,.
SB35 just applies projects that supply more than.
50% or even more as cost effective, dedicated budget friendly systems for low revenue or lower families, there'' s. another tier for people that are actually not.
getting any housing built. It'' s 10 %, so in those. territories today, anything that comes in.
that consists of the 10%,, price element is entitled to that simplify you and circ the slip between those two rates is based upon above moderate real estate production, so if you stop working to satisfy even your over moderate real estate manufacturing, you from that 50% tier down to that percent.
tier as well as in Santa Cruz, '' reason for our 20%. inclusionary that would certainly certify every task in, right practically every project that comes.
in for that improve sight and also this one ordinance.
is not gon na avoid that from happening.And we believe this is one. tool that we can have in our tool kit that. might modestly enhance real estate production as well as obtain us closer to satisfying that objective. SB9, will help with that.
If we get 9 applications, I ' d recognize that we ' ve met numerous yet, however potentially assist us with. that anything that we can do to like keep real estate. manufacturing up is gon na aid us restrict the as well as the number of. projects that qualify for.Thank you.- Yeah, I value that explanation or simply kind of more. And I assume that ' s consistent. When we did the real estate trip and paying attention tour wanting sort of even more as well as similar as well as less larger growth, with a whole lot of what we listened to. I Thank you, you are. a participant of the public thinking about commenting.
on the second analysis as well as last fostering of. regulation number 1022-2, little housing devices,.
– Hi, welcome.- Hi, thank you, there Philippine talking on behalf of Santa Cruz tomorrow. I wan na give thanks to personnel for.
Significantly, we ' ve allowed more than double the reduced income units in our goal. We ' ve additionally permitted. There are still two even more.
years left on this RHNA cycle as well as we are simply beginning.
to see some of proposals use these new state real estate regulations.
The growth in our housing production will certainly be greatly affected.
by the laws currently enacted and more are being passed and also suggested. Santa Cruz is one small city amongst lots of cities as well as counties that brand-new state regulations were developed to affect as well as we are doing far better than the majority of. of them in meeting RHNA of the state thickness reward regulation has currently boosted from. a possible 35% thickness bonus to a 50 %density reward as well as is set to climb yet once again
as well as those benefit devices come to be market price, some. of these legislations currently consist of circumvention of. regional car park policies for certain residential developments, some do so based upon closeness to public transportation with this pattern, it is not inconceivable that other neighborhood regulations such as open space requirements could additionally Beed by closeness to public parts and mention this to highlight just. that we do not understand how these new regulations will. impact our advancement as well as ability to enforce our website criteria in the coming years, the only actual duty that we have is that the.
This would enhance the base thickness of prospective utilized to then. This might have been an actually interest. This can have been an actually interesting device for resolving our economical housing needs, if Santa Cruz.
I ' m calling in, in. I ' ve spoken before I assume to maintain in mind, one of the really helpful devices that this ordinance will enable
us have is more a lot more for people, whether they ' re renters tenants or looking to buy one of these smaller smaller sizedCondominiums we already have our SRO code that allows enables a lot more than, than these apartments homes, or,'or condos apartments would certainly, but however is just simply giving offering more choice option and and also a lot more to to have more homes residences people individuals our community, I also likewise to speak about the affordability price facet this I ' ve been low incomeEarnings. I think that the way that it is, it ' s gon na supply more options for us and we can look at various other means.
actually detrimental in regards to getting individuals. who require inexpensive houses in to produce these.
constraints as well as obstacles on these sorts of units.
that make them harder o pencil out for market price designers that are developing them when.'we already have various other alternatives for economical real estate.
Designers come in as well as build. a lot more economical devices anyway.
This is not a panacea of affordability, however it is regarding developing much more alternatives for market price real estate and creating even more inexpensive market rate.Thank you.- Thanks, our next telephone call is Kyle Kelly.- Yeah, thank you. Mayor council and also team, it was a great presentation, I talked throughout the very first analysis, yet given that this came back once more, I wanted to come and also speak and also speak with every one of you, these,. these dimensions, specifically having this, this increase in sizes, this gives a great deal of alternatives for individuals that actually don ' t have much else, many individuals can ' t afford the existing. separate residences, which I will certainly include, have no price handle. We can do shakedowns on apartment or condos all we want, but it looks. truly negative if drinking the housing that working course individuals will certainly live in, so I ' m, I ' m in a family of 5 as a household of 4 we ' ve stayed in device that were as huge as, as these ones prior to and also they were the only options that were offered, we did.
not have generational wide range assist us enter. some various other options.We didn ' t have other connections that would certainly maintain us be able to maintain in one, one location we ' ve gone through evictions through in San Jose, we ' ve needed to relocate from home. to home, I have actually never lived in any kind of. place much longer 3 years until I obtained an area in. Santa Cruz which ' s just via the lot of money of having the task that I have, I desire to develop some more alternatives for people where they can

, they can obtain a location, they can develop equity. It doesn ' t have to be the same manner in which land values, ' reason I wear ' t recognize if anybody below has really. considered just how condos function, they don ' t rise in worth. as much and also they actually should, like, we require to separate. is this about housing as investment for real estate as, as an area for individuals to live and also the reality is if you create much more flats, producing a lot more, much more places for individuals to live as well as concentrating on creating real estate affordability or, 'obtaining the'unit,. the housing unit itself bringing down the cost of housing, not simply in acquiring a separated home.And that ' s what I actually desire people examine to look at. ' Cause in this case for exactly how. much we ' re at now, homelessness, overcrowdedness, commutes,. I know a lot of you are interested in the. rail, yet it appears like it looks actually bad. You state individuals should. have the ability to commute in, however we ' re not gon na create. much more options for them to live right here, we need to. develop a lot more choices for individuals to live here, if we ' re gon na. 'claim immigrants are welcome, you require to'broaden alternatives for. them ahead and live right here.
These are providing more options.Maybe it ' s not excellent what precisely you desire, but they ' ll provide alternatives for a lot a lot more family members, good friends for ourselves, for everyone else that we understand, so
thank you, thank you for supporting sustaining. I really wish that.
remain to see innovative work, thanks for your public remark.
The next caller for public. comment is Jonna Payton.

– Hi, I ' m Jonna Payton, a long period of time Westside center. local, I highly support the FDU proposition since basically, I desire a place to live,. currently, I study at a college I ' ve discovered in a city with. this very own housing crisis, which ' causes me to pay way.
even more than I must for housing.And I'desire the opportunity. to find back to Santa Cruz after I finish, this. proposal will make it less complicated to build smaller sized as well as cost effective housing that I might live in, so I'wouldn ' t demand to have a great deal of roomies as I do currently. And also 'I wouldn ' t have to. spend as much on rental fee

. It wouldn ' t imply a lot more for real estate, especially for young people like me without suggesting bigger. structures I reach use. would certainly likewise imply that when. individuals relocate to Santa Cruz or leave to their moms and dads residence, they won ' t have to displace a household who may be lost'by high rents live somewhere with longer commutes, reduced quality of life in Santa Cruz.Someone that could also at. threat of becoming being homeless placed our existing policy of limiting housing ' triggers ravaging situation as well as we should address it with. plans suches as on the whole, a choose'this proposal. would provide the city would certainly provide this would. offer individuals of the city extra chance at residing in a. even more equitable Santa Cruz, supply more chances. As well as because of that I highly encourage us, thank you, thank you for your public comment, our next phone call. is Elizabeth Conlin.

There ' s nothing that we ' re doing here that would prevent state law or that would certainly avoid state as well as so the selection that you ' re is about device dimension, actually. Thank you so a lot at this time, I do see raise, I likewise had a for additional time that was approved, so I will certainly begin with your hand is raised to go ahead, Mayor, this is, this is Martin, I have just one question prior to public remark, if Okay, go ahead, I just, I assume it was reacted to, yet I just wanted to make certain that in relates to plan should, if that'' s being proposed there ' s, recognizing from
staff. ' Cause we put on
' t wan na be. If we get 9 applications, I ' d know that we ' ve satisfied lots of yet, but possibly assist us with. It doesn ' t have to be the exact same way that land appreciates, ' reason I don ' t know if anybody below has in fact.Hi, great mid-day, I would love to say thanks to staff preparation, compensation
council for determining an issue low usage solitary occupancy device and provide those that
actually fit for neighborhood. I believed that was so essential that I'' m relaxing from job now and also (indistinct )as a tenant

and also as a. young gift professional.I assume( indistinct) would certainly, it truly offers me hope that.
starter once more and actually like the concept of a building, a different dimension homes in it, some studios, a person rooms, some two.
rooms that fit individuals and also family members in different circumstances. in life I think increased ownership, significant for stability as was mentioned absolutely nothing would certainly enhance ability renters than in fact having the possibilities to phone their very own home.
banner, It would certainly give even more options with center class as well as broaden center course being secured outta capital to own their own home in Santa Cruz, It would certainly give financial investment in our community and actually reinforce.
the connections to neighborhoods below by being able to possess a location Santa Cruz, I additionally really like advancement from the personnel doing.
something that'' s looking kind based zoning since it gives more all suitable in with. requirements and also regulations.And I actually like even more acceleration and also research studies into form based zoning because as we see for worries about developing communities commonly based upon the dimension of, however if we ' re able to house more people within the same size structure, I think that would certainly. overall a significant advantage for, so I like seeing
the five council participants supported this step in the initial reading and also I hope. that you move on with activity today,. thanks for your
time. Thanks, our following telephone call is( indistinct)
. Thanks, great mid-day,. Mayor as well as council members, Elizabeth( indistinct), in support of the Monterey. Bay Economic Collaboration, our housing campaign.
consists of a wide union of area participants,
neighborhood. employers and also organizations to support for as well as catalyze.
an increase in housing of all types and also income.
( indistinct) Partnered with visualized housing to release our white paper,.
staff ' s referral to authorize the flexible density density device regulation in order. to contribute towards a manufacturing of a varied mix of real estate kinds within the city of Santa Cruz, we especially log the FQ. ordinance as it eliminates for even more missing middle type homes in Santa Cruz that will be.
available for lease or purchase.Having a lot more housing alternatives. will certainly enable students, solitary people
, family members,. couples and elders, chance to reside in our neighborhood. as well as thank you for your. committed leadership and taking realistic steps to urge much needed real estate. development in any way kinds. Our following is telephone number finishing in five. Go on and also mute yourself, press 6 or unmute, there you go, welcome The episode, construct more devices with the thick benefit at 50% that the, that more devices below even more, it goes greater,. started with an including the more collar of bills it ' s. since the (indistinct )it gon na go to example rock as structure, not what and also are boat.When are we on a roadway. or traffic alteration? Thanks. Ballot, thanks, our next ending four', go on and unmute on your own.- Hi, can you hear me?- Yes, welcome. Yes, welcome, thanks,.

so my name is Canda.
I ' ve benefited 7 years in this area as well as Midtown resident., this whole subject is. of this, of the truth that we ' re living in today, which is with the thickness bonus offer was brought it by the previous telephone call, that was the heart of the conversation with.
the planning payment and why there was just. a four to 3 votes. It also deserves keeping in mind. that the inclusionary is only on the base, not with the thickness reward is thinning down the effect of cost effective health of things, but that ' s why you ' re now seeing only 5%, instead of the 20% you can also because. of the thick parts, you can remove the. protection of obstacles, car parking needs and height, and also open space, you can likewise forgo the advancement requirements, It ' s. additionally not easy to understand why you ' re authorizing this or trying to authorize this currently before the objective criteria and also my understanding is that they wan na raise the elevation a lot more on the base, there ' s no mention about type variable plans as well as where those were where they likewise affected by the thickness reward, that really is. exceeded'the discussion.And there ' s been no examples offering by innovative preparation to show that if you take a look at 9 0 8 sea street,.
they originally recommended 396 devices of sous at 4 60 to 6 48, if you check out it with 220, they can count the vehicle parking, they account stumbling away commercial, yet including. the result, the benefit of their auto parking generate 559 units. You assume that by including even more thickness to a present setting or, form variable that you have no additional effect, which would be ludicrous and as a matter of fact, because certain job, I think last time I inspected, they included one more 9% at 433, so you could discuss some of hundred systems in much less. than three and also a fifty percent acres, these are significant. adjustments and without a large out, without a. additional analysis, without a true general strategy. amendment procedure, which
has not been carried out in the, you truly put on ' t have a sense of real.

effect on the community.And also recognize that. the order strategy,
which was just at 55 years per acre versus 150 systems, plus you had thousands of people objecting to it, individuals do care, there was, I believe concerning 2,400. that signed that petition 3 or 4 years ago,. there was 300 people that organization people. that authorized an application, specifically organization people that were on ocean road,. water and SoCal, understanding the effects it would certainly.
have on their services. I believe that you simply.
– Hi there, hi there, can you hear me? Okay, many thanks, my name is( indistinct )as well as you most likely understand that I was a participant of the city council as well as during that time, I was part of conversations. And also over the years, UCSD.
has continually intended to on the variety of. trainees on the school, yet attempt to create the needed housing. Some various other time, constantly. later, constantly behind that has actually not altered in any way.
last years, possibly permanently. As well as currently with the avalanche of state laws and the push to develop.
dorms all over Santa Cruz, you ' re asked to support
. these modifications that have actually remained in all traditional feeling of. all sense of place to construct these little square foot boxes all over our midtown, so you really. require to ask yourself, why would you do this? ' Cause pupils
have these units that afford budget friendly rates, certainly they do I ' m. with them on that subject.But what has taken place to. the concept that the college must construct 'the real estate utilizing its land, its land use policy said you are recommending that we transform our land usage planning.

Okay and our city ' s. right to do its own land, use preparation and also lose our. local color permanently. Yes, all these trainees require budget friendly and comfy real estate. to inform the college, do their work, produce.
the at home, please not adopt this procedure,
we don ' t want telephone call 10, 8 to 10 tales, realities of these boxes around our.
midtown, the literature that was mailed to the U is no designers websites to generate duplicates of the midtown Cedar village location, no designers in websites to create the duplicate of. the St George hotel.But, however the images do that, that ' s the situation as well as you reveal pictures. of little advancement that they ' re planning in the pipe, 10 story structure therefore do not adopt this action, we wear ' t want 10 story phone calls, realities to these boxes throughout our midtown utilized to simply their work, thanks for'your comment, our following caller ' s contact number ending in eight, 9, 9. Go on As well as hi there, can you hear me? Yes, great, thanks.- Hi, this is Ben,. student housing coalition phoning call to enter your last minute below. I'really want to state. our company ' s complete support for the statute and the modifications it brings and also really.

returning to the telephone calls going about changing our character at the college, I believe I kinda that narrative discuss how ideal and also so when we discuss building housing, when we claim the university must be.
developing all the residences, city must be building all your houses are( indistinct) and. both have an obligation for those issuance, so I think the idea that we ' ll lose our area personality by permitting people have a place to live and approaching this issue with situation from a dilemma tax from.
all sides can actually make, so I assume it ' s. truly crucial that we'push and also we proceed. and also enable these even more, a lot more sort of living for people who are attempting to downsize, you ' re trying to down or family members wan na reside in a smaller sized setting, even more eco.
I ' ll allow that four,. I ' m simply calling in to. I work as an educator in the county as well as I assume this type.
Hello, can you hear me?- Hi, I can hear you. Thank you, thanks for taking my call.
I just desire to see these. votes on this statute zero, the public communication. for this thing today was four to

one once more, please pay attention to the voters of your city, specifically on a statute. that would certainly have such substantial as well as challenging to envision. results on everyone. I concur with the people. that ' ve been talking regarding the desperate requirement for. far more affordable housing.
There ' s no doubt about that, yet there are major. They truly checked out that as an obstacle as well as
it ' s a challenge obstacle financingFunding and as well as particularly the wayMeans You ' re in a situation where you can only offer.
a various kinda cap where they would certainly select SROs, which are limited to service.
– That answer my concern, I think.Yeah, it simply increases some problem because I think that what we were listening to
from people is this idea concept. Like that ' s additionally an issue. Only that, so there ' s no,.
like you can ' t like hedge your and develop some bigger systems, some smaller devices and. like they ' re all just that. So it simply hasn ' t actually.
That can make it. Got it, well, thank you. If we ' re gon na relocate.
And also until we have a much better understanding of the effects of the. brand-new housing regulations pertaining to thickness reward, our goal are various other and typical real estate manufacturing actions that will certainly affect community.
Okay, we have movement by council member upcomings there a 2nd, yes, I I ' ll second that I put on ' t wan na lose the floor that Okay, Let '
s just take, read this motion, have an initial by seconded by Brown, all right.
( laughs )I will take a look and sort of Bonnie, could youshare it again? ' Cause there are different.
And also I just keep in mind that. Currently allowed right currently under the basic plan?
So where Sarah was discussing the 2.75 R we could have structure heights that put on ' t suit a 2.75 R, where area ratio, the. housing accountability act does not enable us to use. those height standards when we put on ' t have … when you can ' t attain the. complete density allowed by As well as so once more, as we.

mentioned numerous times, this FDU proposal wouldn ' t modification. the massing or the range as well as we come back with the unbiased requirement, It will certainly have ramifications.
for things like products or roofing system kinds, the height are enhancing as one of the customers discussed, but not
, not according to what they can do currently because again, also if. the zoning regulation says it ' s restricted to. 30 or 40 feet in elevation, if the full thickness can ' t be accomplished because limitation, we need to allow higher under the housing accountability act the changed hallway strategy, I ' m uncertain precisely what ' s being. described best there.I assume That
would be the zone area, the zone areas, yeah, to make sure that is that is combined with the objective criteria, we information owning areas for a lot of the places and keeping that it will again, have the exact same things that I was speaking. concerning with the objective standard and better understanding of the effects of brand-new real estate. regulation pertaining to density bonus offer, other. real estate, production, shield housing manufacturing procedures.
With regard to regulation, if we ' re waiting on. And also in some cases we do wan na hold off on, we ' re doing, for instance,. We ' re expecting that
in the next following or two2 so for this particular issue, I wouldn ' t recommend suggest ' re waiting for what ' s gon na happen with the housing real estate regulationDue to the fact that

' Cause trainees
have these units devices afford affordable cost effectiveRates of course they do I ' m. with them on that subject.But what has has actually occurred. I ' m simply calling in to. Like that ' s additionally an issue. 30 or 40 feet in height, if the full thickness can ' t be accomplished in that limitation, we have to allow greater under the housing responsibility act the changed passage plan, I ' m not sure specifically what ' s being. We ' re expecting that
in the next month or two, so for this particular issue, I wouldn ' t recommend you ' re waiting for what ' s gon na happen take place the housing real estate regulation.Therefore I'' d like to know where that, that, what this personnel settings on that, what, what happened
at that conference, where there was an attempt to begin to relocate a proposal like that
forward from the planning committee straight to us, so which was happening a long time ago, we'' re chatting about urgency and also we can'' t wait even more Mon more months months, but they place ' t had a possibility to have the conversation that I recognize at the very least some commissioners wish to have, so I'' m just asking yourself where that'' s at and also why

, sure.Happy to talk to that,
so the planning commission did have a, a conversation on inclusionary. and that recommendation has
been sent to the Mayor, the thing has not been offered the council yet, but will certainly go to some factor I place'' t had a, a control with the Mayor relative to when that,, will actually happen. Great, okay, so I wan na.
make, so it is in the mix, however it simply it'' s not been prioritized. So I also wan na be clear that the, the inclusionary referrals for the that came from the planning compensation bonus were, were associated with density reward and also not specifically related to FDS, there was a conversation concerning FDU on a similar timeline, however those, those and also the preparation compensation, acknowledged some of the concerns related to that,.
because some of those suggestions would in fact not urge the manufacturing of really reduced,, income systems, so.
that, that is gon na take a great deal of analysis, that'' s, that is gon na be on a, a longer timeline, then an easy change we intended to just match FD to SRO with going to 20%, really reduced, rather of 20 %low, you record all that, that was a whole lot (laughs) I do and, I have, I and also I value that.I disagreed somewhat with the level of select figuring it out, but I'' ll just do that.( laughs )An offline conversation, I do.
have some extra remarks I wan na make and also I'' m gon na go back and I'' m gon na chat concerning the
.( sound drops) that I care regarding '' reason I ' m
propositions. forward and also that individuals I see that are having a hard time.
and also I want us to assume about that for a minute, we.
listen to from participants of the general public, we require options, we need.
selections, we understand that no one has really any kind of choices right now.We do have– We have an undersupply of.
housing, I identify that and I'' m not opposed thickness,.
Allow'' s speak about someone who one may kind of.
envision, discuss this wonderful, budget-friendly by style Movement. Allow'' s discuss a Santa Cruz City Park, who earns, I'' m just gon na round it 18 park and direct employee and also I'' m in a grounding, yet I'' m gon na stay that park and also straight worker and also I'' m type of is a composite of experiences that I. understand happening our stone citywide that employee shed their housing to a rental fee, that worker is residing in their vehicle on close friends at $18 per hour, currently I'' m gon na deposit the reality that employee.
and once again, a compound might be functioning 20 hrs.
a week as a long-term worker, 20 hrs a week as an attempt where they are after that laid off end of thousand hours, someplace around a, the 9 99 on, that worker will be lucky to, with that said one task every hr available to them earn regarding 30, I'' m gon na. ground down because that temperature position has a lower wage affix to it, concerning $36,000, $3,000 a month.In order for that paying budget-friendly rent, that would be about $925 for an employee for that worker not be lease Santa Cruz, that lookout released a post that workshop costs are up 112 over this past. That is not because we didn ' t build enough real estate in the past, that ' s not since we didn ' t construct enough housing over the previous nonetheless years, that ' s since there is an influx individuals with the capability to pay even more rental fee and proprietors that will bill it, so the existing ordinary cost of is 24 95, which is rather darn close. The studio rate, brand-new. growth come online that I ' ve gotten on this as well as simply that, how is something like this advantage that exactly how is something like this benefit workers at the solution market employees that are, we understand this is a significant part of our labor force, just how are they gon na profit from a change, provides more housing options to individuals with relatively? Yeah and all of us battle, I recognize that, however who aren ' t because we discuss option every one of that, I feel like there ' s this detach from the truth that reduced wage family members. face, so we ' ve assumed others have regarding the significant potentially dramatic landscape, our constructed atmosphere, I ' m not gon na repeat,, all of those, yet I will certainly state I think that it should size better dialogue and also should equal evaluation as well as should consist of factor to consider of exactly how produce within this possibility that we have below, and also this reward for. developers that would develop a lot more inexpensive units, so I ' m gon na, I ' m gon na leave it. there, no, I ' m not gon na leave it there, sorry, It ' s frustrating to have as well as I simply really feel. like nobody ' s truly discussing,'there is one fact which is our fact the need for housing, however there ' s an additional truth'of like, who obtains to live below reaches, to the workers that in our, in the bathrooms and our per reach live right here, that'' s a conversation.We can ' t

fix it with our real estate policy, but we can absolutely take it right into account as has.
been repetitively kept in mind today, not called for to give our regional legislations to fit even more density density this method at the time, by all the influenza concerning the state actioning in, since we have not helped with adequate real estate manufacturings, we have our RHNA, this has actually been specified continuously again as well as we'' ll talk about that more or later today, I'' m thrilled to have that discussion regarding the real estate element, we have actually satisfied those all, but the extremely reduced and 3 very reduced, we understand really low income market developed unless they are called for or funded given every one of that, I think that if we offer kinds of added designers at a minimtalking concerning kinds of units that we understand going, we can'' t produce. sufficient the market isn'' t.So if we'' re gon na provide. to designers additional density chances as, as director Butler stated, we can'' t alter the size of the structure massing, yet the proposal will certainly transform.
the roi chances available.
to developers advancement. So if that holds true, then we definitely must discussing an.
raised exclusionary precautionary for these sort of jobs. That is why I assume that having financing time on the proposal and bringing it back with interest to price,, is very important currently, thank you, council participant Brown council participant, voluntary Johnson and also after that council member Myers. Thank you, thanks for the job of the planning payment.
and also team and everyone that called created letters I'' m simply gon na grab.
the string that council member Brown simply left,.
I fall short to recognize just how structure less assists those real estate the most, I fall short to comprehend exactly how building much less doesn'' t rise competition for the existing units that we have below, I am actually privileged to have stable housing had stable housing for a variety of years.That wasn ' t constantly the scenario that I discovered myself as well as my household in, there was a letter that was.
sent out in by a Mr, charlie VA that speaks about his.
mommy as well as mother-in-law who came below recently as well as just how it'' s tough for immigrants to discover housing. I suggest, that was me.
and that was my household. the trainees that contacted they'' re on springtime break, thanks, send from calling from the beach, that'' s a truth, It is all of our obligations and that was me also, I finished from,, this is regarding structure.
housing for everyone. This has to do with building housing for children or maturing parents and for that city worker, it'' s about building real estate for him or her, It ' s concerning building housing for our middle class what if the 30,000 travelers that enter our city to function belonged to live, how would certainly that impact climate? Where is the intersectionality.
of decisions that we make around housing and land use? If we'' re devoted to climate,.
that'' s just just one area. I recognize most of us on this. council are committed to attending to the obstacles around our unhoused homeless population, where'' s the dedication to that if we'' re not thinking proactively and also advancing cutting-edge services if we, if we check out the schedule product later tonight around the housing component update, we'' ll see that council participant Brown is right that have actually not yet satisfied very low revenue systems, but we are mosting likely to jobs that remain in the line up which we have new re objectives that are in the thousands for a variety of real estate that our area needs, so if we wan na expand in such a way that is suitable for our neighborhood, we wan na expand sustainably.Let ' s be proactive and not'obtain our hands put by the state. Allow ' s not have high all. over community and I think the manner in which we do that is we obtain in front of it. there are a whole lot of questions as well as problems that were.
advanced in comment and in the letters and also I believe that team did an actually great job of offering extensive info and also I truly believe that, that we if once again, if we wear'' t wan na see monstrosities and we wan na determine just how we.
grow, we wan na dictate instructions that we enter, then we need to think outside the box.
and also this is an effort at doing that at the end of the day, it'' s about being an inclusive. and also diverse neighborhood. I think that'' s a value that all of us share right here on this council and also I assume worth that we share as a community, I'' m talking to community participants, that ' s something I hear over as well as over again, our strategies and also energies thus far have actually not been working.So why are we

suggesting to remain to, hasn'' t been working,. doesn ' t make any kind of feeling to me, It ' s about giving housing, It ' s concerning supplying housing and development in the way that we want determining growth, the manner in which we
want, so I ' ll. finish my comments there. I will not be supporting the motion, thank you, thanks, council member Myers, and after that like council Myers, yeah,'I just I also simply wan na state on, I won ' t support this motion and also I simply, I, yeah, I think I additionally just actually wan na explain because I'' ve gotten on the city board,. there ' s simply been efforts, right, to simply stop real estate and also tasks that our market rate. but possibly there ' s an advantage, as an example, the entire station situation, you understand, currently we'' re going to have numerous units, really reduced earnings housing built, we will certainly have the very same 5 devices of extremely reduced income real estate in our midtown library task, we'' re seeing with, with the devices readily available, we'' re beginning to see that we can care for the individuals who are taking a trip down freeway one to find into Santa as well as this idea we simply postpone so that we can somehow up with another solution when really designers are concerning San Cruz.
today, budget-friendly housing designers, I.
can call 5 economical real estate jobs that are going on now, they'' re in the permitting procedure, obtained the permanent. helpful housing project and also housing issues, we'' ve got the two, an addiction, we have the one that ' s gon na enter at the red we have Jesse street marsh, these designers are here, they want to purchase Santa Cruz and also they'' re building. low and also really low revenue real estate,'I wear ' t recognize. why we just keep desiring to throw more barriers at it.Let ' s just postpone play play,.
We'' ve heard from people. I was especially struck by the instructor that called today, made an area to live as well as it'' s a starter for them. Hopefully they get.
maintained by having a residence, maybe they can put together the financing to actually buy it, this.
offers us the flexibility, great tool, allow'' s examination. It constantly transform in regulation, It ' s not going the method we will certainly on and also there will be future city board that will modify this gradually, this is a tool in our land usage toolkit and also it'' s there to attempt to obtain us for housing, not in six months, not in 6 years, we in fact begin making points occur and we'' ve seen.
that trajectory already, currently began as well as I'' m sorry, but The golden state is. people like California. They transfer to The golden state. (laughs) And afterwards they inform us, “” Oh, you.
shouldn'' t be constructing this.” I indicate', it ' s ironic to me.
that a great deal of this comes after people get worked out in California, then they'' re like,
well, like. you got ta slow-moving this down, so'allow ' s just attempt to. look after the individuals that are struggling here.Let '

s just attempt, do some.
that assists households, individuals, people.
as well as others and also seniors, that are just attempting to make.
Brown with your hands up for the benefit of time, do you have any type of additional comments you ' d like to make? I do, okay, Go in advance, council number coming and also then council number Brown, I just wan na claim that the purpose of this is not regarding the manufacturing of real estate in our neighborhood, It'' s regarding ensuring that if we'' re gon na move in. The only point that ' s protecting me as well as the setting that I ' m in right now is the truth that I was fortunate to find a property manager, maintaining their rates.
The problem right here is trying to. find out just how we can raise the amount of inclusionary,. each limited affordable real estate that
. can come right into new units. Since as our planning commissioner, as our preparing supervisor stated,. as our planning division has claimed, that the just.
means that you can maintain economical housing in the.
That ' s all I have to.
claim, council participant Brown.- Yeah, thank you, Mayor. I just wan na claim, I fail how. relocating onward with
a proposition that would basically promote, promote more market price real estate.

with no cost, any type of additional price is mosting likely to benefit the functioning families as well as the people that you all are driving below, I just offer you a scenario of somebody that might never ever in a million years possibly rent out if they (laughs) had a flatmate, one of these units.
that we'' re speaking about, I'' m I ' m hearing oppositions in what my associates were saying, one, we are not doing a great job.What we, what we ' ve done, hasn'' t functioned. And at the exact same time, the very same council participant stating we ' ve satisfied our objectives, see, later on today we we'' ve met our goals so that I listen to contradictions around the timeliness of the bus back now, when it pertains to building market price real estate, you recognize, extra.
price requirements. When we speak concerning.
a little (indistinct) the percentage of inclusionary device, we have to research it for life and also so I would just urge folks to assume concerning that when you decide what.
anxious as well as what needs even more very carefully as well as I would additionally motivate us concerning the fact, not just theory of real estate, supply matching for meeting the demand of the and I'' m all for not waiting as well as I'' m prepared to in fact make Thank council participant Brown, I believe this has actually been a great discussion as well as I value.
every person'' s input on emails.I think there were around 7.
e-mails with various worries, thank you to intending staff.
( indistinct) as well as Butler for clarifying several of.
the questions that I had from those concerns around thickness, and just how this policy drives development. Those problems were clearly responded to as well as that it'' s not changing.
versatile thickness units, the dimension and you understand the height trouble, the inclusionary requirement. Those worries have actually been responded to. We have to ahead conference.
the needs of our community in the ideal method and also you know, this is something that we can progress is assistance that with.
This is simply one item of that, will certainly get us so numerous individuals.
With that, I ' d like to take.
– No.- Aye.

– Aye. – No. (indistinct) – No. – No. That movement does not pass two in support. You have one application as well as.
one, 4, 4 again and also 4 versus in support. Council participant Folder, okay. allow'' s see, council participant Brown and afterwards council participant Myers Mayor, so I I do have a movement that I prepared. I sent it to Bonnie Bush and also I'' m hoping you can that up identifying the necessity desire to not have a decision about this. I so here'' s my motion, I ' ll, I ' ll reviewed it while reviewed long straight staff council at the earliest feasible meeting with one an amendment regulation 2020, title 24 of the code regulating small real estate units, including replacing.
little possession devices with devices as well as making.
small clearing up changes adhering to rise the demand 2020 5% restricted inexpensive system as well as I, this was prior to I realized that really low is required, to make sure that last and then two, a changed resolution.
accrediting injection manager send statute number 2022 and changes to the midtown.
plan as neighborhood seaside as well as change, California,.
coastal compensation for final qualification.
enhanced portions for F and cost-free any kind of requisite regulation to mirror for the recently established, second, we have a motion on the flooring council member, Brown seconded, are you seeing that item area product one that No tail end, no, I'' d like to leave it.Okay.

For Butler, I Gon na ask if, might comment, sure, thanks, Mayor I was simply attempting to make sure that I recognize this as well as I assume that and also I think that I got it currently,, you'' re recommending that we return to you, so we would go to the preparation payment with a revised ordinance that consists of the exact same arrangements of the FDU as well as except we would certainly likewise loop in inclusionary adjustments and also you desire those to go from the 20% that they currently are to 25% which and after that at this, when we bring those back, that'' s when we would certainly bring the amended resolution. The amended resolution directing, okay. I comprehend what you'' re recommending, (laughs) as well as I, wasn'' t quite sure that I obtained it the initial time.
around, so thanks. I have a question for you Butler, certain. Have, has your staff explored this 25% raised, so we have not what I would certainly claim relative to that is I kinda restate what I suggested before, which is the SROs have the 20% at very reduced revenue,, a a 50% location, average earnings degree the little ownership system as well as the small possession units.
suit all various other developers.That ' s 20% at'reduced earnings with 80, which is 80% very prompt, I assume, given that the uniformity or the distance of FDS and also SROs, I indicate, I would certainly wan na deal with our economic growth team who understands the funding of that,, much more very carefully as well as better as they develop some economical real estate projects in our area, however I believe that change if we, if we changed FDS from low to really low and kept it at a, and also sorry as well as moved it to 50% AMI rather of 80% AMI '' reason that analysis', we ' ve currently got the SROs that have been created that, that are being established back,.
I believe is a simpler change as well as most likely a much faster change. And if if we, if I would advise that if we were rising to 25%, that we do a market analysis and bring in a 3rd party, a professional.
like Kaiser Marston, who'' s done these. proforma evaluation before.And we deal with our financial development department, that would certainly be my suggestion is, is. Making sure that there is that tasks are still viable? We wan na obtain the maximamount. of cost effective housing units that we can and also we
want to make sure that those housing jobs are constructed, since we don ' t wan na. established that bar so high that absolutely nothing gets built that. doesn ' t aid us meet our RHNA, our local real estate. requirements allowance targets, nor does it offer.
housing for the neighborhood or in order, does it.
there'' s as well much threat, to make sure that'' s what they would take a look at as well as make that resolution as well as.
make those referrals.

( sound decreases) that I care regarding '' reason I ' m
proposalsPropositions That is not because we didn ' t construct enough housing in the past, that ' s not because we didn ' t construct enough housing over the previous nevertheless numerous years, that ' s since there is an influx individuals with the capacity to pay even more rent as well as landlords who will certainly bill it, so the existing ordinary cost of is 24 95, which is pretty darn close. Yeah as well as we all battle, I recognize that, however who aren ' t in that we speak regarding option all of that, I really feel like there ' s this separate from the reality that low wage family. The only point that ' s securing me as well as the placement that I ' m in right now is the fact that I was privileged to discover a landlord, keeping their rates. I so here'' s my movement, I ' ll, I ' ll read it while reviewed long straight staff council at the earliest feasible conference with one a modification regulation 2020, title 24 of the code controling small housing devices, including replacing.Yeah, I assume that
complexity, that component for numerous people to recognize is not simply the system count, yet really whether or not somebody can obtain the funding, whether or not long term holding the property gradually, taking care of with that said construction lending period as well as after that right into ideally filling up the systems made complex, so I believe you maintain increasing bench and people are gon na go develop, construct real estate, other places, not below, tan Cruz, so
thanks, Mayor Council, member Brown, I simply
a, a fast historic evaluation below, very recent his for those who are not on the council and,, a few of us were as well as will remember this previous city board identified that the ideal means to obtain housing developed was to reply to programmers needs and also reduce, I exclusionary focused that needed task, I did not that community neighborhood members with
the city, we received a Kaiser showing
that that was the sweet spot for penciling out your job and five participants of the council that,, we were told with a research study by Kaiser Mar that that was the
just method we were gon na obtain housing was to community members, filed a claim against the city, they had no various other option to try to guarantee the will of the individuals by a ballot of the people measure O was upheld at 15% inclusionary would standard, then we had a minute where we had a city council that
believed application would certainly to come in elevated park and so we raised it, we were
told, so and then Kaiser Marten discovered a means to
reveal us that it could be done, right, absolutely nothing had changed in the real life, like in the worldly world, nothing had actually transformed, yet we then obtained a study telling us
what we desired to hear.

'' Cause we had to do that '. ' Reason we were that we needed to do that, so then boosted 20
%, some of you claimed, oh no, we can ' t do that due to the fact that nobody ' s gon na build, and we have actually had a lot more applications than ever before, even after boosting our– so (indistinct) study might be done, we could also simply try it, what happens if nobody intends to construct FQs at 25%, then we can take another look at it.It ' s kinda what I claimed the initial time around. It finished up a lot longer than we did, we are currently, so I just believe that,, once again, this is where we get into that inquiry about, oh, if we wan na make that take a long, it doesn'' t have to, it truly doesn ' t have to( indistinct). will right here we ' re Participant Myers, I believe I I just need to, I have to challenge a little bit concerning that background that. we just reason we'' re getting extremely reduced income as well as reduced earnings systems entirely with best by the state of, on those devices, I'' m speaking concerning market devices And also the city is, is smartly utilizing our very own homes as well as dealing with our companions to actually bring those things to consent, there was additionally use a brand-new legislation that we were able.
to put particular projects immediately, that they.
The state leveraging this extremely low as well as reduced revenue housing, it'' s not our inclusionary. The inclusionary price ratio right now is not producing these extremely low income units is not, so I'' m simply. ' Reason I put on ' t think.
I assume we ' re almost.
Call a concern, yes, okay, we have a motion to call.One second. -I ' m( indistinct) all right. Elect the movement by council Brown,( indistinct) – No.
Staff] Brown.- Aye.- [
Council participant Myers council participant, thank you, Mayor, I ' d like to make a movement. We have an activity by council. That motion passes for in support to against council participant lacking and, I just wan na state, assume this item as council participant Myer stated has been a lot longer than we anticipated for a second hearing, It was uncommon in my, for second hearing to have.
this much conversation and also, yet I believe as well as crucial we wear'' t have the possibility as body to have these conversations and increase issues in support of our components as well as you know, we still have emails can be found in as well as numerous in assistance also and also I would like to just state that there were some actually assets.
brought up and also I'' m really hoping that our intending personnel, your capacity to truly study this.
has been lead and really handy Butler, so I.
hope that an ongoing exploration into several of the discussion items today, specifically in pertains to exactly how we budget friendly real estate and nation various other,, referrals around being cost effective, such as a 50 DMI DMI look,, any of those recomme going ahead focusing on continued path of satisfying the need for our children.
in concerns to housing.So keeping that

being stated, you all for,, sharing that I would love to create suggestion to proceed things 27, which is modifications associating with small cell wireless.
and product 28, the testimonial and also other than final parks and also leisure yearly report, I'' d like to see if there would certainly be an activity to, move those to April 12th,.
the next, so that week on I have vice and afterwards Terry Johnson, I'' m satisfied to move those items and if that doesn ' t bring up any, I'' d like to ask yeah, manager Matt Huff, would that work with your team.
for the sake of time? We'' re satisfied to continue. both of those things, remarkable, exists a 2nd? We have the vice Mayor Watkins and also council participant Terry Johnson.

– Second. – So we have a movement to.
continue products, number 27 and 28 on the schedule to April 12th conference, we have an activity by vice.
Watkins, council member Myers. Oh, I'' m sorry, I was going to sorry, Mayor, I didn'' t I, my hand, all right. – Aye.
( indistinct) and so that brings us thing number 29, expiration.
of statewide evictions. And before welcome council member Boulder. Before we begin that item, I will call a five minute bile.
break sitting here. (laughs), so thanks, we'' ll return at 4:23, Thanks. Now we will start with our next program item.
number 9 for members of the public for council member, who'' s just joining us products number and 20 have actually been to the April 12th agenda, so now we will begin with product number 29 expiry statewide expulsions, the.
postponement added legal help and support for renters impacted by COVID for participants of
. the public for streaming this conference, if this is an item you wish discuss now is the time to a hire seeing the instructions on your pupil order will certainly be a discussion of the item by personnel followed by inquiries from the council, we will certainly after that take public remark and also then go back to the.
council for deliberation as well as activity, so now I.
will provide it over too.Yes, excellent mid-day. Keep in mind the common council.
in your program package is a condition upgrade with information about different sources that the city has offered in participation with the area real estate and also health and wellness division for lessees who are experiencing difficulty because of the COVID 19 emergency situation at, at your last meeting, there was a demand placed this thing on the agenda at the at the prompting of numerous.
individuals as well as organizations that are working with tenants that have actually been influenced by the COVID emergency situation, the emphasis of that was for.
certain for details demands, one was to.
license a regional lab quantity of expulsions for.
anyone waiting housing is vital repayments up until the end of 2022,, or until their existing app paid out two was to recognize resources of funds to keep the tenants housed a landlords, including ARPA the 14 million secured by Legislator for homelessness and or other sources and also to construct this into your financial year budget plan, as a backup for.
real estate is key three was to inject financing, bolster existing neighborhood legal aid.
companies as well as partnerships that offer pre occupant.
counseling and also lawful representation with.
special 10 for the over for the overrepresented undocumented as well as 4 need all expulsions.
between landlords and tenants with the objective of avoiding.And I would certainly include

that comparable request for sent to the various other cities in Santa Cruz region, along with the county the county of Santa Cruz.
board of managers. And I believe the area is also having an agenda product to discuss this, this afternoon as a result of that, I was able to collaborate with my.
city attorney as well as region council coworkers evaluation of potential for a more local halt as well as the proposition to require expulsion work contracts between.
property owners as well as tenants.And we evenly ended that ' cause of adjustments in the 'state law that were placed to affect during the COVID emergency situation the city in in addition to the region and also various other cities are presently preempted from these these types of actions, the eviction moratorium in addition to the required arbitration of situations entailing rent that became due in between completion or completion of September. one therefore therefore the referral is.
to focus on additional resources of funding as well as that is what the city has actually been,. has actually been venturing to therefore believe Bonnie Lipscomb is( indistinct) some of those initiatives I ' m not seeing her on, thank you, I ' m satisfied to respond to any. inquiries that you might have regarding the regarding the the possibility for an eviction halt the required me council participant Brown, thanks, Mayor, I do have one question regarding that, I, my understanding is from products that you ' ve sent us as well as additionally my added questions,. there are communities that are expanding their. expulsion auditorium.Outside of the housing is program throughout the duration of extended COVID emergency declaration at those,.

with those jurisdiction cities and offered that we simply elected to ha to prolong COVID. emergency for 60 more days, would that provide us similar. cover to something similar? So, so there was a duration.
of time before the passage of maybe K32, which is.
referenced in your program record throughout which cities were able to adopt expulsion halt statute, that that was particularly accredited by an arrangement of state regulation as well as the door to that shut city, any the city of Santa Cruz carried out in fact an expulsion moratorium statute that expired. in September of 2020 cause a brand-new state legislation entered well established one more evict that was statewide and also that that expanded the halt to September 30th one then with the passage of abdominal muscle 8 2 there was an extra securities, established for renters and property managers that obtained state aid with the real estate program and. that regulation specifically allowed cities that had those evictions securities in area currently to continue to have those in place.But the law particularly states. that any type of effort to broaden or prolong or act. An action that that happens. between August of 2020 and also March 31st, 2022 will have no impact. Before April 1st, 2022 and also then moreover, the law claims that a stipulation passed or. modified after August 19th, 2020
will certainly not apply to rental that came due in between March 1st, 2020 and March 31st 22, so the state legislation has specifically preempted, the city ' s capacity to adopt expulsion defenses that are for non-payment risk for that period, August 20, 20, March 30, I would certainly just add that based upon our research, we have not we have not, not seen any kind of city effort to pass additional or further expulsion securities since a 83 went right into effect California, the region of Los Angeles did take on an eviction security step that finished previously existing eviction in January of 22 as well as they ' re currently protecting that that action USA area Los Angeles.- Council member Cumming your hand. Hey Tony, I was curious,. have two problems here, one is that you have people. who kind of have relied on the government, its. word to attempt to obtain them rental aid and also they ' re at risk of if this runs out not only do they, this ends their. prone being kicked out.
Guess my concern is if a person waiting rental aid, it ' s forced out to those property managers
, they ' ll get that lease, well, that, that aid as well, since, this is something that ' s been functioned out with the tenant as well as property owner under the assumption that need to the renter be able to get the assistance, then they won ' t be forced out house, however if they are kicked out the property managers, then obtain that at that time, well create maybe if they obtain forced out as well as they don ' t, then they don ' t, it ' s a shed shed circumstance, but I wear ' t understand, or maybe a the proprietor gets the aid and also the person still gets tossed out, so I ' m just. curious concerning, yeah, I need to confess that I ' m not as accustomed to exactly how those. repayments are processed with the real estate program, so I can ' t really provide you a clear on that, It stands to factor to me that if an application'is pending I wear ' t know exactly how that and also a tenant is forced out unless the renter or a person.
brings that interest of the state program there could'be a circumstance where. the professional the application is process as late has already, again, I ' m not, negative. About that city does not directly deal with those applications.So I ' m not as
familiar with that. As well as it would certainly seem as well if the individual gotten it as well as after that finished up obtaining forced out likelihood,. they would go is quite low since lots of people already will shed rely on their federal government, so however I ' m thanks for the. information, yeah. many thanks, even more shed, a lot more trust fund. Thank you, council participant Myers, Simply a concern for personnel, I was just curious, I know the county has actually included well,, a
pair concerns, I presume, Bonnie, I understand that we were supporting as a lot as feasible rental support, so I'just intended to comprehend a. little more concerning what we ' ve done as well as whether we have, we are still give capability for individuals obtain aid, whether it ' s what I think, what kinds of. aid we are providing.And then I think for Matt do we understand anything from either semi participant stone or Senator Laird in terms of kind of efforts in Sacramento to attempt to attend to, these settlement results, various other things and whether or not there ' s. a, any type of, any kind of legislation that you understand is gon na advises'me of the ed farce whether or not there ' s a motion at the state in regards to attempting to, trying. to get this tidied up. So people not sure who, that can respond to those 2, but I ' ll toss those at thanks, I can talk to, however, yet and had one more conference, regrettably. I ' m gon na talk for. Ed here, but so simply can do it, so as far. as rental help, the city has provided the housing authority over 200,. around 200 K for down payment, so that ' s one item of that we ' re offering the city is additionally providing, has actually provided taxi around 238,000, I ' m gon na allow Tiffany help. me if I ' m, I'' m providing the wrong, the specific information., however that, that those. Monies have really been fully prolonged at this point? Tiffany, so the nod, yes, so as well as we do recognize that'taxicab has been collaborating with the area looking for more support for their programs, so I, that response among inquiries, yes, then councils, I just include to simply remarks,,'we ' re not mindful from. either setting up participant stone or Senator LA factor. in time that there ' s any type of active legal initiatives, at least that their offices are associated with there have been conversations in Sacramento around prospective expansions or, or a few other sort of eviction defenses that could be placed in area, as you may think of,,'can given the worry,. we all share throughout the state that there possibly being, a flooding of expulsions as these protections run out, however that, that work today seems unclear what direction the state might take, if, if any at factor and the guv ' s office has signaled has actually made commitment that existing securities with sundown as they ' re presently intending end of March,
having claimed that, the other question I believe you asked was what other job is. underway on a regional front, we have been in. regular conversations with Robert Bratner. the supervisor of housing wellness for Santa area on developing'a more official partnership. around continuing and also increasing regional support programs that'are in location, we located the area the most reliable giving legal academic and also mediation support to renters and also locate themselves in a placement, so in discussions with.
Well, with the location emphasis.
Watsonville as well as Capital as well as other partners.- Thanks, yep, I. would, there

' s an activity and also I ' m not (indistinct) right currently, but seeing that some. of these activities being obtaining in touch with our
state leaders additionally simply to obtain a sense. of what ' s happening, might be very helpful.Thank you, thank you,.
council member Myers, council member Terry Johnson.
They simply obtain word, counsel,. Go in advance, that ' s my analysis. As area council.
What I ' m also hearing.
is that the, that staff is recommending regional support group to support those, the forms.
of funds added to let ' s see, renter EDU lawful as well as occupant legal support, occupant education.
You see my notes below are there is that like kinda sanctuary or conflict resolution? I understand that Jessica dui stated'down payment
program, housing. authority and activity board financing are all those current and also valid sources.
– As well as my last inquiry, the attorney, we had numerous area participants relating to changing eviction notices.- Yeah, some council participants could remember that in November of 2019, the. I indicate, I can ' t say that there ' s no means to do it, I imply, what, what I give the council.

' Reason I wear ' t think. Presume my concern is if somebody waiting rental aid, it ' s forced out to those landlords
, they ' ll get that rentLease well, that, that assistance as well, becauseSince this is something that ' s been worked functioned with the tenant occupant landlord property owner the assumption presumption should ought to tenant renter able to get the assistanceSupport then after that won ' t be evicted homeHouse but yet they are evicted the landlordsProprietors then after that that back thenAfter that well cause create could be if they get evicted kicked out as well as don Put on t, then after that don ' t, it ' s a lose shed shedScenario but I don ' t knowUnderstand or it could be a the landlord gets as well as person support obtains assistance individual gets obtains out, so I ' m just. Thank you, council member Myers, Simply a question for staff, I was just interested, I recognize the region has included well,, a
couple pairInquiries I guessPresume Bonnie, I know recognize we were supporting sustaining much as possible rental assistanceAid so I'just simply desired understand a. little bit more extra what we ' ve done and as well as or not we have, we are still provide supply capability people individuals assistanceAid whether it ' s what I guessPresume what kinds of.- Thank you, yeah, I. would certainly, there

' s a movement and also I ' m not (indistinct) right currently, but seeing that some. I imply, I can ' t claim that there ' s no means to do it, I imply, what, what I provide the council.the council sometimes weighs a danger spectrand gives instructions with the understanding of that likelihood., I would include though that if a, if a lawful difficulty is brought in
the city'' s unsuccessful, we'' re additionally likely accountable for the plaintiffs, states attorney'' s charges costs, so it'' s not an inexpensive gamble take, all right, Vice Walkins and also council participant Myers, yeah.No, I value the clarification and I mean, just '' cause I. have the program right before me, some of.
the resources consist of the refuge, country legal the manual for proprietor protection.
down payment program, real estate authority have and so forth, so it'' s great to recognize, we have community partners who are working with us, who support our locals in the suggestion, it doesn'' t include to have a budget plan appropriation or return with budget plan in the referral as that something that you'' re desiring more quality as well as instructions on taking a look at you, Matt, sorry.( laughs) I figured as much, thanks for.
the concern, council Watkin. Council can certainly make clear.
that that is the instructions we were currently working to identify (indistinct) initiative. I would certainly also just include that.
we have a conference tomorrow that structure with our with.
That this mobilization of our area will be in place at the time of expiry, even though our That'' s. Thank you, council Myers.( laughs)- Sorry, yeah, I would certainly be prepared to, after you take it out to public comment, offer that direction.
as well as feeling, clarify that. Great, thank you, so.
If, you will certainly currently take this out to public remark.
want talking about expiry of statewide.
admission moratorium, extra lawful help.
and support for lessees affected by COVID-19 raise.
your hand either by dialing celebrity nine on your phone or picking the raise hand on your webinar code, It'' s your resort to'you ' ll listen to an announcement that you have actually been unmuted and the timer will certainly after that be readied to three minutes, I did have one team connect and have actually been authorized for extra time and that is Barbara Meister with Copa and also so let'' s bent on participants and also, I
see Barbara.

Meister with her handcuff.Go ahead as well as unmute on your own, thank you. Welcome Mayor Brunner, I want to, my name is Barbara.
Meister, I'' m representing Copa organization 23 member establishments across Monterey as well as Santa Cruz area as well as much of you have actually been meeting us over the last couple weeks and also obtaining our, our emails and letters.
upgrade your focus to this looming situation, I do desire to offer time to Elizabeth Cortez who Copa leader and who can share.
with you the experiences she'' s had over the in 2015 and also could additionally discuss her accessibility or lack of ability to access some of the.
resources you'' ve pointed out. Elizabeth ' s phone number is six hundred five one 4 one, see that as well as would you be able to unmute here.
and also I'' ll usage whatever equilibrium time she does? Barbara, I'' m not seeing that number.
Elizabeth Mun, there we go. Cross and also leader of, as well as I just chat you a little. Looking for assisting my.
experience being other and homeless things that.
you have been speaking for the last 40 mins. As well as first of all, I want.
to start by stating that I was affected by.
COVID 19, really hard.Me as well as my

partner lost our tasks, my other half shed 2 full time.
jobs, I shed my fulltime work. so after that we battle, we.
needed to invest throughout financial savings, after that, we also have to request fundings, personal lending therefore I end.
up obtaining house leasing, which took me a long, long period of time. I applied when the 2nd round began as well as I didn'' t speak with them. And also so in November proprietor earned money as well as that'' s when he
additionally got. e-mails from his insurance and he made a decision that he.
wanted offer this residential property. So we had to start.
That'' s when I look for the resources, some of the sources you'' ve stated. They don'' t help immigrants or individuals that just have a job permit, that'' s why I also been.
in the front office state this program, I got a handout from area bridges stating that there was program. When I called and also, and so.
discussed this program, they state that they didn'' t even know what I was speaking about, that. that program didn ' t even exist or it wasn ' t legitimate anymore.
as well as from what I listened to from a person who was stuck recently, it resembles programs stop working tally. I don'' t know
if that. person that was there, that they had to do with the program. The other thing is simply, simply browsing the residential property administration, the demands that are around, simply.
get an area like nine each. So everyone has to be making, that everyone needs to.
certify by themselves. Making 3 times the lease, each individual has to have two jobs, two years of proof of work, which much of us wear'' t presently have, since we lost our task.
in when the pandemic hit.Paying 45 to

$ 50 attributed, simply several of us wear'' t even. have that amount of money simply to leave like is means way too much. Elizabeth, that time has.
the timer has ringed. – Thanks for sharing.
your experience and Barbara, thank you for permitting.
the moment and discussing that remark from Copa. Thank you. We have our next remark.
from Raymond Panino, Proceed. – And also good evening council. Great night council, great night, Mayor. Thank you for your time today. My name is Raymond Canino as well as I'' m the CEO of Neighborhood Bridges.I ' m contacting to ask that the council include some extra motions onto the table and also potentially relocate ahead. on a conversation that includes letters of creating both. Legislator Laird ' s office, setting up participant, rock. as well as RVIs in connection to the real estate program,.
As a letter to the guv ' s office. There is no reason that we. all ought to go to ground the table afraid of tenants potentially being at a possibility as well as. at a point in which evictions could take place when they had. public depend on as well as public rate of interest of attempting to utilize the state program to get the needed. resources and also demands in order to pay lease and remain existing. This isn ' t just the. tenant and also the property manager, or it ' s not simply a tenant ' s concern. This is'additionally a landlord. concern in the feeling that a great deal
of these landlords. are likewise waiting on funds ahead in to
make sure. that they ' re able to pay their building taxes, to make'sure that they ' re able to adhere to all the costs. of preserving a home.We really feel like arbitration is a method forward to avoid. unlawful containers from destroying occupants future rental chances as well as an opportunity in which property owners can quickly involve with renters in a safe room that are most likely to obtain much better outcomes than looking for unlawful instructors, I think that what ' s critically vital today is that. you think about additional financing that helps sustain these sorts of programs like our eviction. defense collaborative that was begun, ' cause we saw the train regarding the hit cars and truck about a couple months back, 'we really wish that you remain to also consider other. policy services since re regardless of how much money you advance today,
you ' re not gon na have as much a substantial influence as you would certainly, if you changed your policies as well as search for other kinds of means to decrease illegal detainers one way is to. create into the area court system to ask that they inform both parties prior to and.
Or through having solutions that we ' re going to be,, wishing to help support households in the, in the near future with the support of the area, so I actually wish that you additionally take into consideration an extension of the moratorium in a way 90 to a blog post, I comprehend that it does not affect the people that are influenced during the settlement duration of March 31st. And also that ' s something that I. believe you ought to think about. Thank you for your public comment.
considering that they were published, it appears prior to the. conference, I ' ll type of checked out the one concerning
this thing I ask. Just how do you figure your. wisdom go beyond states choosing when'the eviction moratoriend? I remind the stay at home. orders as well as expulsion postponements were influence a long time. and also the remain at home finished last June, which was likewise a long period of time ago.Now the freedom to relocate. about and get one ' s affairs in order has then had a lengthy time to play out, there is likewise a surge of job opportunities, so'I put on ' t actually offer joblessness much thought as a reason, I put on ' t see any version of this suggestion of a blanket city, moratoriextension, or any type of required arbitration.'or any kind of brand-new contemplated, obligatory constraints. on proprietors seeing anything other than. Trashing property manager? If the state didn ' t send out repayments, it didn ' t send
out repayments, then that is little property owners fault, however you were and will damage. still perhaps serving property owners in some way pay. The rate for federal government
and as well asCapacity but yet after that ' ll consider think about sided action and as well asDropped thank say thanks to, you were told informed can ' t do that, here Below s the story in a nutshell, the leftist town community think state worship prayer of big huge welfare well-being handouts in victimhood two 2? And also they lean socialists over economic situation, the rest people count on. Freedom limited federal government with freedom, building legal rights, self dependence, individual.
duty, industrialism in the free enterprise, I. marvel which of those, the
council will certainly sideway time to admit the government really ruined the COVID reaction, after that not make property owners pay even more for government mistakes. as well as turn the normal.Thank you for your. remark, our next is Tanya. Go on as well as unmute.

– welcome, thanks a lot. My name is Tanya as well as I ' m the area bridges household. collective procedure supervisor as well as the program supervisor for the real estate regional partner network. I just intended to clarify that from an eviction. prevention viewpoint, the existing issue is connected adhering to, when we enter into
April,. proprietors can leave legally expulsion and also for nonpayment of lease, also if funding pay that rental fee is pending in the real estate is so we ' re likely occupants being kicked out while property managers. still in retrospection obtain rental fee, the candidates that we collaborate with are our. counties most vulnerable.They look for secret support ' reason they are experiencing digital. proficiency and also broadband issues and also are under an incredible amount of stress and anxiety

, our customers want to pay their end, but as been. disproportionately affected by the pandemic as well as what we really require is a couple of months for the. housing is essential program to overtake this, thank you so
a lot. Thank you for your remark are there any type of other participants that. wish to comment on this program item number 29? Okay, seeing none, they close. public comment and bring it back to council for. conversation and also deliberation as well as activity council.
participant Myers and also council member Cumming, council member Myers, you have your hand up, sorry
concerning that. I ' ll go in advance and make a motion there to are you gon na obtain two? We just ended up public remarks, so everyone ' s done there,. I would certainly make a motion to guide mayor. to engage with the region on the regional efforts. pertaining to, keeping, with any luck, maintaining individuals from being evicted, particularly with financial investment, whatever structures. that area has with each other in regards to financing for. several of services can use.And then I
would certainly include in that that we additionally potentially. receive our (indistinct )supervisor additionally obtain an. update for state, state legislators on as
possible that to I indicate to the council and also I assume that it Take that a person more time for clearness.

I won ' t I would certainly make an activity to direct manager involve. the original and area effort area
of Santa various other territory, consisting of coming back to. the council for authorization For approval ofmonetary contributions and also request supervisor to contact for state S to acquire update on an initiatives by our agents. regards to March deadline as well as the house trick, the state financing that ' s current.Okay, so we have a movement. by council member Myers, is there a second? I ' ll second that, alright, Council participant Cumming seconded and also council member Myers, have anything else to add or, fine, so council member Cummings had your hand elevated as well as after that.

council member Rock, Yeah,
Terry, I have a concern on this, ' cause I'had movement language pretty similar, however likewise I had some, an additional movement that. I was gon na make that would certainly provide extra straight after we vote on this activity,. there is the possibility to make an additional, a. different movement, right. Added activity, fine, yeah, so yes, I ' ll sustain the activity, which seems like would supply direction.
I would just ask for friendly modification, essentially one of the points I ' d included was in
terms of directingRouting Applications have been completed and also funds have been dispersed, so I wear ' t recognize
if that. The idea, so the letter, include that right into interactions state.Sure, wonderful.
As well as so I ' ll, I ' ll send out the. I assume we can just, we.
I believe the instructions we ' re hearing is that. as well as letters for regional elected delegation urging activity on I ' m, I imply, you. can install the language of so council member colder., I had my hand up a. 2nd, but I simply wan na as well as I ' m not gon na make a great deal of comments below, yet I just wan na state that'I do know three people that have actually been tossed out for lack of repayment of rent as well as all three of individuals have actually been rejected by master tenants, so. tenants that rent out a location and after that kicked them out when they leased a space therefore I ' m simply interested when the property owner ' s not always included, but there ' s a property owner, somebody functioning as a property owner, that ' s they call like telephone call like a master renter, I presume as well as and so if there ' s a way to consist of in the language that there ' s security for those individuals that resemble. sublet locations as well as just kind being taken advantage of that are not necessarily Least In a position of power.Does that make good sense From a, from a lawful perspective, the the subtenant is managed'the very same defense as it has renter rental fees straight from the proprietor, so, oh, fine, I believe, but I think it ' s it ' s consisted of.
Thank you, I assume that ' s where the legal education and also support and,, necessary and why that ' s requested a whole lot of

people don ' t actually understand or comprehend what rights they have, council participant Brown, sorry, I, my, my. question was answered. Sorry as well as council participant Cummings. Your hand is still up, I can place it down for currently, however I ' m gon na, I ' m prepared to make additional activity after we relocate on.Okay, Allow ' s, allow ' s take with this movement. That ' s on the floor, so we have a motion by council member Myers,. a 2nd by council participant Cummings as well as we.
I mean, I think, sorry, I. was just gon na say that I think it
might may worth those letters to some take action to avoid prevent. During this time, while. At exact same time.
So allow ' s see, we have an activity to route the city supervisor to engage in a local. eviction defense initiative
with the county. and other territories concerning avoiding. individuals from being'evict. Restore those initiatives Demand from state legislators immediately on efforts related March 31st pleasant. modification comings, direct the Mayor, create a. letter to assembly member rock as well as laed expressing. the demand to extend the COVID 19 eviction. section for individuals who have actually
requested. state rentals as well as urged them to do what is in their power to advise the state assembly and. Us senate up as an emergency item throughout session and. eviction protections until the have been and also.
funds in the market.
And I, there ' s one more, there ' s a bit extra language too, around composing the governor as well ' cause the guv can take executive action, so are you stating straight the Mayor to write. a letter to setting up participant Jones, legislator. lair and governor Newsom sharing the need to prolong the COVID 19 for people at a state degree for, okay.This is the, for those that applied, all right, Is the manufacturer of the motion responsive to that friendly change council member Myers, all right as well as we have a roll phone call choose Johnson.- Aye.- Aye.- Aye.
Looks frozen.- Aye.
– That movement passes stick. (indistinct) Okay, council member Cummings, thank you. I, one thing I

' d want say is that this is a significant government failing of the people throughout one of their times of greatest.
followed that they were not able to process the applications in a prompt way, offered that our state government is not eager to resolve the deficiencies currently think we require to do something to help shield tenants as well as
several of our lowest income homeowners as well as property owners that have actually not received rental fee this program, the trouble right here is that people need time for that applications to be refined in, I ' m in pleased to support this financing for even more lawful services for occupants resources, for tenants.But if people have already. sent their applications in our waiting payments, then. we need to do what we can to give them more time,. this council has spoken regarding choosing gold actions. and we ' ve progressed with the danger of and risk. of suits in the past on other products and this is a, I believe we owed a residents most impact by COVID-19 offer them with more time therefore I ' ve made a, I had a long motion as well as part of what council member Myers I just made remained in that therefore tried to a part of the
pieces that wouldn ' t get also difficult, but I have. added language that I would certainly such as, I recognize that
a couple of these things likely. not obtain as much support. The very first part of the movement would be bullets one as well as 3 direct staff to bring back ordinance. COVID 19 rental help and have not yet obtained their aid honorable for the first meeting in April, that will be straight to act to April 1st, 2022, bring back an. 19 danger rental assistance to learn their options, to lower, reduce mental tension and also after that I wear ' t know if I can make couple of movements in activity, but the other component of the activity would be to guide Mayor to write.
a letter area courts slash district lawyer ' s. office and judges promote and suggest arbitration services prior to sending unlawful detainer, the goal of solving disputes. and also staying clear of eviction.- That was the middle bullet?- Yeah, that was simply the second bullet.
The middle one that I review Tony after that, so Tony, I presume the question is this would be 2, possibly 2 different movements, if not I understand we can ' t have even more than three motions on the flooring, I would presume that you ' re bullet number 3 folded into the first bullet,'yeah, that was the, that was the intent That ' s appears like one activity, the 2nd movement be to route the Mayor to compose a letter, I would certainly suggest that that you attend to the letter if that ' s the instructions of the guidance, the administering court of the premium court and also omit.

If the state didn ' t send out repayments, it didn ' t send out
out paymentsRepayments then that is hardly any any type of proprietors, but you were and and also harm. The rate for government
and aptitudeAbility but then it ' ll consider think about sided action activity as well as, thank give thanks to, you were told informed can ' t do that, here ' s the story tale a nutshell, the leftist town believe think state worship praise of big huge welfare well-being handouts in victimhood two property? Your hand is still up, I can place it down for currently, however I ' m gon na, I ' m prepared to make added movement after we move on.Okay, Allow ' s, let ' s take with this motion. As well as I, there ' s one more, there ' s a little bit more language also, around creating the governor as well ' cause the guv might take executive activity, so are you stating direct the Mayor to compose. The middle one that I check out Tony then, so Tony, I guess the inquiry is this would be 2, possibly 2 separate motions, if not I know we can ' t have more than three movements on the floor, I would certainly assume that you ' re bullet number three folded into the first bullet,'yeah, that was the, that was the intent That ' s seems like one motion, the 2nd activity be to direct the Mayor to create a letter, I would suggest that that you address the letter if that ' s the direction of the counsel, the administering judge of the remarkable court and also leave out.In my viewpoint, yes, I would claim that the very same evaluation
would put on emergency situation protections for individuals
that have pending applications under the housing program. So I'' m, I wear ' t believe I require to state my suggestions on that, I believe council participant comings comprehends it
which'' s the direction of the council will certainly bring that regulation. Proceed and also second that, so I have another question, we have a, a very first by a movement by council member Cumings and also a 2nd council member Brown, what would be the timeline for this
emergency statute option? I review the activity as guiding that to be brought at the
first meeting in April, and after that it would be made
retroactive to April 1st.

It in fact, it claims on or prior to the first meeting in April. So if the special meeting was held then prior to April 1st, that might
be, it might come after that too, or it would certainly come at initial meeting in April and be retroactively, with the exception of April 1st as well as then the suggestion would certainly be
that we would certainly bring back item, figure out whether
an extension or sundown would certainly be essential of that
regulation at the initial meeting in August. Offered that we don'' t fulfill in July if by August 1st meeting in August, figure out that everyone'' s received their applications as well as this is only securing individuals that have actually submitted applications So if all the applications.
An upgrade.
-Yeah, thanks Mayor. And is the motion maker open to that? Okay, the Mayor additionally has the authority.
statute for emergency situation adopt, supply expulsion securities for people COVID leasing have not yet gotten on or before the initial meeting in April, that would certainly be retroactive first and also restore a product to figure out
whether an expansion or sundown is required, that the very first conference in August notification three days will permit more time 19 leasing to learn their options.Okay, we have a function called ballot. (indistinct) – No. As well as for the document, it'' s as a result of the lawful constraints that we listened to from the lawyer at an early stage. Boulder. – No. – Aye. Brown. – Aye, and I simply wan na.
apologize my video camera off, I keep getting went down as well as so I'' m attempting to remain in the conference. (laughs) Thank you. – [Clerk] Myer. -Aye.- No. I ' m sorry, I ' m sorry that we were electing on the second one. That my ballot is a no, that was a no.

– No. Okay, that movement does not pass.Five no and yeah as well as then the next activity, the straight the Mayor to create a letter to
county court for actually. there was language that direct Mayor to write a letter judges of the county court advertise and also suggest services before an.
illegal retainer objective of settling, preventing expulsion, we have a role telephone call ballot, could.
I suggest one small edit? – Yes. – Would certainly be to write a letter.
to the administering judge of the area court. One court council member Cummings are you alright with that language? Okay and we have a roll telephone call vote. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – That motion passes with one voice. Okay, I'' d likewise ask yourself if city personnel as well as there was a caller who made a comment about programs as well as I question if any kind of council member could make or making a movement or we can route staff to.
consider the effectiveness and also credibility of the existing programs that are the sources and also support programs that are in area and to make certain they'' re working as excellent, the Mayor heater in feedback to that the direction we'' ve gotten council to and participate in this local partnership will become part of that discussion with every one of our partners who recognize most reliable locations of investment, so I would certainly say that that'' s developed right into the impression we'' ve received.Course council wants make clear, that ' s our intent, I desired to make sure and also call that out if something is not available or not working ensure that. personnel are( indistinct).
Council member Cummings, I was gon na make that motion ' cause because you asked, make a motion, so (laughs), '' cause I don ' t need the aid on my hands, thank you, council member Cummings, alright, so, I eagerly anticipate writing. these letters as well as to an update from city staff after tomorrow'' s conference as well as eagerly anticipating some suggestions of moneying quantities that we with county 500,000, these locals for, so we proceeded, sure, fine, so currently we will,, carry on, I think we are at the moment of a shut session product.
and this is seminar with lawful advise, existing city of Santa Cruz, santa Cruz, there, any type of members of the general public who would.
like on the close session thing or make use of elevate your.
hand by calling star 9 on your phone or selecting elevate hand in the webinar objectives of your, when it is your time to, you will.
listen to a news that you have actually been unmuted, the timer will then be set to hang up.
when you'' ve talked about your thing as well as there any kind of participants that want to talk about this closed inquiry on the agenda today, None, I will bring it.
back as well as we will adjourn to shut session.We will certainly resume at

for oral. Is the city clerk ready? -[ Clerk] Yes. Is that an of course? As well as welcome to 3:00 p.m. session of the March 22nd 2022 conference of the.
Santa Cruz city council, I want to ask the clerk roll. – [Staff] Thanks, Mayor. Council participant Terry Johnson. – Existing. – [Clerk] Boulder. – Present. – [Staff] Cumming. – Here. – [Staff] Brown. – Right here. – [Clerk] Myers. Vice Mayor Watkin. – Below. – And Mayor Brunner. – Existing. For participants of the.
public that are streaming this conference, if you.
wish to contact throughout oral interactions.
now is the time to employ guidelines would certainly be on your screen.Oral interactions is a chance for participants of the area. plus on things that are not noted on today ' s schedule, you want resolving.
the council, elevate your hand either by calling cars and truck 9 on your phone or choose increase hand the webinar on your situation,.
you'' ll have three mins. Keep in mind that this is the time for council to speak with the general public,.
we are not able to participate in dialogue with each.
participant of the public, yet when we are able, we will.
Hi, without details.
reference to any type of agenda things, I would typically advise you once more, that employees have an equivalent, right? Not to join unions as well as
. any one sided support for union development coming.
from you is going against the equivalent civil liberties of those that do not intend to join and you ought to always then avoid of the exclusive.
organization labor connections regarding union formation, I would certainly likewise advise you that the cash designated right into the water division'' s budget, all come from users of water shipment and also, no cash needs to be.
reallocated out of the water allocate any kind of other purpose than a delivery of water, water, budget income made use of for any kind of various other objective in supplying water is a complete abuse of your syndicate water utility setting,.
It is a covert pack as well as it needs a complete.
When contemplating such it is dishonest and, quit.
abusive to do otherwise.Malcolm X was a Marxist that thought quite strongly in fierce revenge as a means to an end, this as well as.
supporting the complete damage of the criminal justice system was the thrust of Black.
Lives Matter activity, virtually from the beginning.
handling to attain eventually a total massive boost in criminal offense and also physical violence,.
consisting of enormous boosts in black murders that the self-admittedly Marx, this organization is associated with a missing 60 million.
donation team that Monica can give of the BLM was charged for 18 counts of fraud simply days earlier as well as the BLM proceeds to inflict the.
damages by its anarchist supporters, the ill approved BLM signboard was ruined, yet it.
is additionally virtually entirely used out, now, despite the outcome of compensation for that vandalism must not allow it to be repainted as it is likewise a glorification.
icon of that violent Marist, anarchist and fraudulent national company of the same name, the severely requires a defunding itself and maybe a few other remembrance.
of George Floyd might be thought about without.
the BLM stigma connected to it and not in front of municipal government, yet probably over by the cops station, which would certainly be better, who else, if anybody, by currently requires a remembrance of the lessons of extreme police you also require to terribly need to quit regurgitating the government COVID.
story for instance, by limitless of emergency extensions and to obtain enlightened regarding.
the harms COVID plan has '' caused including lockdowns the harm of coercively used.
requireds indiscriminately put on those with formerly contaminated remarkable resistance, to be compelled to accept the threats of mRNA adverse effects or on close to no threat youngsters, the complete ignorance presented toward the age.
health danger differentials, the joke and also effectiveness of problem fast.The truly limited. effectiveness of vaccinations, the rejection of effective. beginning medicines like IEC and also HQ for earnings. and also the indiscriminate violations of legal rights typically and also show me your documents mandate. the unethical interrupt dangerous plans require to change and also never ever happen once more, I see no leadership originating from you, but I do. recognize the effective pressures taking revenge, canceling those concern, the false federal government.- Okay, thanks are. there any various other participants that wish to comment on the world, which is products out( indistinct). None, we ' ll bring it back to council and also we have ended up the thing early. I would'such as to call a break till the following thing, yes, we have actually not had a break. So we will return at 7:00 p.m. for our next item,. which is product number 31, annual real estate component and also.
Thank you. We ' re returning from.
Is the clerk ready? Okay, next up on our council.
Evening council and also Mayor Brunner. Yeah, I can ' t see. I can begin talking to this.While we ' re obtaining there.
One is on the basic plan as well as the progression we ' ve made towards applying the general strategy that report has no details format demands.
added brand-new requirements were included in 2015.
as well as that has made this report a lot extra intricate,.
It additionally gives us some truly excellent data, these records used to just be called for of non-charter cities,. They ' re currently required of all cities as well as they'also if we do not file these reports, we lose out on a lot of state grant financing. Records is that we offer them to the city council council accepts the reports and also rec that we submit them to HCD and also OPR and the due date for sending the reports is a.
This first, very first section is on the, basic strategy record and also this is simply an illustration of some. The housing element. The overall is 2,736 units for the city of Santa Cruz, so it ' s virtually 5 times the size of our next slide.
as well as we have actually gone beyond every one of our housing requires except in the really reduced earnings group, this year we had one very.
Next slide. And also this, I was trying to. We had 709 preparation applications submitted that consists of not only application, however developing applications that did not require planning permit which a big number of no longer.
So, so they remained in. that category also after that for planning, permits accepted had a total amount of 445 building licenses released the 11 as well as building permits last 78 and as you can see in the income classifications, as you cross in the preparation.
applications, sent planning applications we'' re doing truly well on the very low revenue projects. And we'' re also succeeding on, on reduced end, since we'' re, we ' ve satisfied our modest as well as above modest, we put on'' t even need to consider those, however it'' s intriguing to see simply the total numbers as well as I need to tell you these, these are not additive, some tasks submitted their applications and also just how their applications
. authorized or had their applications authorized.
and also requested building permits, so there'' s some overlap right here, so you can'' t simply count those graves totals.Next slide.

In our, when we offered our report in 2014, there was a whole lot of concerns about exactly how we.
determined the expenses that rents for the ADUs as well as at that time we had actually been using a survey that was done during the process of updating our ADU ordinance, so the study had actually produced to obtain details for.
the, or works with, not necessarily to utilize.
for the annual report. So this year we prepared a brand-new study that was specifically get.
the type of details that we require for this report and also the housing division in ED, the housing department in.
the financial growth, division sends out annual.
reporting letters to ADU owners as well as piggy back on their letters as well as sent out a link to the study and likewise permitted people to publish out the study and send a paper copy and the outcomes of that study showed that our leas both the mean and also the tool rental fees were well below the.
HCD low income rent limits.So we were able to use to categorize the ADUs that had.
at low or no rental fees. Although those rental fees are not shown in this populace, it. ways there ' s one more, I assume it was 47 devices out.
there'that are generally being rented due to the fact that either, either rent charge or at substantially decreased rental fee as well as there were likewise a number I think it was around, it was much less than greater than five systems that were reported as being used for 5 good friends and household or as guest real estate, so they would come for weekend breaks yet not pay for it like, like an Airbnb or something, following slide.In enhancement to the housing. that was busy in the record, there are

some tasks that.
were accepted in one group or used in one category.
Of those are one 19 reefs street task, which is a total of 121 units, one, numerous of them are extremely reduced income systems as well as the 818 Pacific opportunity Pacific station southern that has a total of 70 units. As well as after that there ' s two various other. They weren ' t consisted of in
that last report record.

I ' m sorry, I ' m sorry that we were voting on the second one. None, we ' ll bring it back to council and also we have actually completed the thing early. Yeah, I can ' t see. I can start speaking to this.While we ' re obtaining there. One is on the basic plan as well as the progress we ' ve made towards applying the general plan that report has no specific format requirements.SB35 is a state regulations that needs that cities that have not satisfied or remain in progression in the direction of satisfying their,, be required to approve
housing growth tasks with on a.
streamline review project refined without any, so if.
we have actually met our device target by the end of the cycle, then for the initial four.
years of the next cycle, we are not subject to SB35. If we have met our over modest pictures, yet not our.
lower or extremely reduced, then we'' re in the setting that we'' re in currently where if projects are submitted with 50% or more of lower income systems, anything for 80% AMI or less, after that they are qualified for that improving procedure. If we have actually not met our over moderate goals, or if, certainly share after that would be subject SB35 for jobs that as a state legislation checks out that are.
at 10% of are offering 10% lower in for city'' s. inclusionary demand, whichever is greater and also because nearly projects are needed.
to meet the inclusionary demand, if we do not satisfy the above modest overalls by the midyear of our following cycle all tasks would need to go via this streamline process and also this table below programs the difference between the 6th cycle, which is on the leading as well as the fifth cycle, which is the lower cycle, which is the one we'' re in now, so this cycle
, we building. 180, extremely low income devices and next cycle, we need to offer 857 and also the other numbers.
Previous real estate elements we ' ve shared in residence, but there are additional requirements currently that( indistinct) we simply, we don ' t have the personnel and we.'we will be looking for a consultant to assist us with that, the other thing we should be conscious of is that ' reason numbers for on this sixth cycle RHNA are so high. We might need to rezone residential properties in order to show that there are adequate, properly zoned homes to satisfy our RHNA, it ' s feasible that mix of SB9, which enables 2nd units on a lot of single family parcels and our downtown development project, which is likely to expand the allowed real estate in the midtown.
And also I ' m just asking yourself. It doesn ' t truly inform. Like it simply feel it doesn ' t concerning it, that simply doesn ' t really feel like.
survey data could be helpful or, yeah, well, I have to say the first point that I discovered truly surprising is what is taken into consideration low revenue rental fees, I indicate, to me, those are not reduced income rental fees, they ' re fairly high and. that ' s due to the fact that it ' s based upon the average revenue and also our average income is quite'high here.I think I can let me dual check lawfully whether I can share the outcomes of

the specific studies with you, and also if there ' s no worry with that, I can send you the spreadsheet. It ' s rather fascinating. I didn ' t obtain as a lot, I suggest, we obtained 79 reactions, yet we probably got less than 40 of them included the leas, so it wasn ' t as practical as it could have.- I identify that it was not necessarily stand for, but it was. as well as yeah, anonymized, if that word constantly tripped me up, without the identifying– Thanks Council participant Brown, that was really one. of my questions as well around the ADU, numerous feedback. That was very handy to
learn. And additionally I was interested if. it was for relative that reduced or free rent, that component I didn ' t consist of in any way, due to the fact that I, that I just altered every little thing,. so it personally, I think indeed, have all those systems that are being used either low or complimentary income, however that isn ' t agent of what someone who ' s not. pertaining to someone with an ADU is gon na pay, so I, they were not those were not included.Because I would believe that. that would for just analyzing rent issue the relationship of the renter that, that would– In my viewpoint, we utilize. the leas, I attempt to vend over backwards to make it kind of concern proof for HCD, to ensure that if, if it, we were ever before examined concerning how we came number as well as why we were doing it by doing this, that I can based test. Thanks, council member Brown, did you have an adhere to up inquiry? Another quick one that I recalled, and this relates to the table. I believe it ' s a one imply a target of the low earnings target of'a hundred only. I ' m just attempting to comprehend constraints versus non-ED, it looks like 101 are deed restricted, is that, that are those units that are gon na go offline or? – The non restricted.
ones are, are, I assume nearly special may, may be exclusively ADUs, okay, Obtained it, thanks, council member Cumming, have a question, yeah.I had one inquiry pertaining to that, last declaration by council member Brown. I'' m just wondering, what is the city doing track the non-restricted.
units throughout time. Since you recognize that now, it may be that it''
s in. a reduced income group, but because it'' s not de-restricted, then there ' s absolutely nothing. that ' s applying that device to being
left as a (indistinct). as a'reduced earnings unit, so I ' m just questioning if. the city ' s doing anything, we ' re not, I see it as.
type of two various things, one is what'we. have to do to satisfy HCD and also the various other is what ' s occurring there on the ground'and also if it. were not a concern of HCD, wasn ' t, we didn ' t have to load a RHNA,'I wouldn ' t matter those ADUs in any way, I wouldn ' t matter anything, '. that ' s not de-restricted '
cause there ' s absolutely nothing. holding it at that rent, but due to the fact that we do have RHNA. and also HCD does limited systems as well as they put on'' t need us them.I proceed as well as benefit from that. That'' s not to claim that ' s. refraining from doing everything we can to obtain as numerous need restricted, low end devices as we can and also I'' m, I'need to say, I ' m thrilled at what ' s going on now, we have, we have so much cost effective real estate in the pipeline,.
It'' s really a citing I just wish I could assert it so that we would certainly get equally as 123 systems we need and also then the remainder of on the next cycle, they won'' t allow us save the following cycle, so we just have to that the timing is right.Appreciate that response

, thanks, thanks exist any kind of other council participant questions before I take it bent on public? Okay, so right now I will take it bent on public comment, if you were fascinating talking about item.
number 31 yearly real estate component and also general report card, elevate your by calling star nine on your phone or, or choosing Raise.
hand on the webinars your resort to below, a news that you been unmuted, the timer will after that be set three mins. As well as I'' m not seeing hands increased, I'' ll offer it another seconds and also see none, I will certainly bring this thing back.
for deliberation and a motion. No hands elevated. Member Cumming and also vice Mayor Watkin, I'' ll relocation to accept team record as well as actually I just state that accept component lem me claim that I approved.
the 2021 general strategy and real estate aspect yearly report card as well as the following staff submit the.
reports governor'' s office of planning as well as research study,.
The golden state division of real estate establish. Thanks, (indistinct). – I'' ll secondly that.- We have an activity by.
council member Cummings as well as a 2nd by vice mayor Watkin. More remark, otherwise.
we'' ll a roll phone call vote and we have a roll telephone call vote.

( indistinct) – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – [Staff] Brown. – Aye. – Aye. – [Clerk] Mayor Watkin. – Aye. – [Clerk] Mayor Brunner. – Aye. Motion passed all. Thank you a lot for signing up with.
us, Katherine Donovan, and for your details progress. Okay, following step on our.
agenda is thing number 32, sidewalk fending statute.
program as well as program demand for members of the general public portioning this conference, if this product is one you want to discuss now is the time in the instructions on your order will certainly be a presentation of the product by followed by counsel questions as well as then.
we will certainly take public comment (indistinct) So right now I will certainly turn over to personnel discussion as well as it appears like we have Elizabeth.
I ' ll start with some background of exactly how we got where we are today, we ' re below because of the law SB9-46 and that was passed in 2018 and it says, it was really concentrated on entrepreneurship and making sure that low earnings immigrant entrepreneurs could construct organizations and make a living via street vending.And so the law was really concentrated on making it. We can ' t regulate specific location or making people ask permission. You ' ll hear
that over.
Just a little bit of history on vending and Santa Cruz. we ' ve had two areas where. we ' ve had a considerable sidewalk vending in the city, in the past and as we think. regarding the pre SB9-46 time and also the message SB9-46 time Pacific opportunity, there is vending'on Pacific avenue today, it is not regulated.It is– oh, froze up below, yes.
Got you ' re back. Okay, terrific, sorry concerning that in the … Prior to SB9-46, we had actually permitted. Up to get the rooms that were there, we ' ve had a pair of pilot programs on
, on beach coastline, one in 2019 where we had permitted spaces and and also were.
regarding kind of the experience that we had in the summertime of 2021 following, but I just wan na state,. like every one of'these rubrics had problems.And what we are wishing to do.
I ' m gon na transform it over to per supervisor, Tony Elliot and he '
s gon na talk speak through with we experienced last summer. I recognize you were all extremely, extremely entailed hands.
issues from last summertime. I ' ll briefly cover some.
of the problems that we encounter as well as actually, kind of talking.
in behalf of a couple of different departments here, but. definitely from the parks and also recreation perspective. as well as the Jetty and coastline staff consisting of some of our temporaries seasonal team and also our real boots on the ground personnel work throughout. the was last summer.
So next slide please. All right, so in terms of shows in 2015, so what did we do? Last year we attempted a new technique, we had a lotto game system. where we picked six suppliers for marked locations, so those locations were situated near Cal coastline on, the deck above Cal coastline and after that the the optimal deck, type of the wood deck thus the ideal, so we had six areas where permitted vending was enabled and also we picked those with a lottery last springtime, what occurred over the program of the summer, the council knows as well as the community was a familiar with it was well. documented in neighborhood media and also we got a great deal of concerns. from the public last year.We had a lot even more than 6. vendors, so we had suppliers all up and also down walkway on the, on some side road and.
so those 6 suppliers, they were permitted. actually wound up leaving their area places, they sort of make extend down closer to the boardwalk to get much better locations, so simply loads and loads of suppliers 30, 40 some in some cases upwards of 50 suppliers down there on a few of the active holiday weekend breaks in 2015 with the planning department, the code conformity team work, enlightened as well as notify vendors in 2015 on the permit and also the policy that we had in location, the parks and also rec crew together with the public jobs division we release our garbage collection on as well as around the in beach street area as a matter of fact invested more than a hundred thousand dollars parks and recreation on overtime, additional dumpsters and also leveraged a great deal of volunteers as well to help with tidy up and after that a whole lot of enforcement substantial enforcement from the authorities department, once more,. concentrating on safety and security, well-being and also wellness really beginning in July. Next slide, please, in regards to several of the impacts these are four as well as I wan na highlight the 2nd as well as third bullet points on below particularly, yet we did have a, a fair quantity. of hostile behavior.Last year, we had battles in, in regards to just over areas as well as sort of turf. We had unsafe road conditions and this in the following product were. a few of our largest concerns in regards to public health and also security, with the number of suppliers. that we had on the pathway, the queuing lining up to go. to a supplier, as an example, those lines were creating. generally no space on the pathway, pressing all of the pedestrians. right into the bike lane. Bikes were then going. right into the driving lane, as well as in the driving lane, you. have both cars and trucks and also a train, so it ' s a really, extremely overloaded
area. And afterwards including the suppliers. in 2015, included a level of recommendation that developed substantial health and wellness as well as
safety issues, really dangerous road conditions, that are really kind of the core trouble that we ' re attempting to attend to with works with modifications prior to council receiving, the various other product I ' ll mentioned is just the extreme garbage, I know additionally was entailed in that and doing cleanups however substantial refuse garbage that made. its way onto the coastline into the aquatic refuge in a few of our tornado drains, there. were scraps discarded down tornado drains and oils. etc,'so from an environmental health and wellness point ofview, the amount of trash that we had was totally unmanageable as well as I wan na.
parked on side roads where food was being stored, so once again, just that kind of impromptu warehousing of different items in foods it was an additional effect in 2014, next slide, many thanks. In terms of the cops department, PD was doing nightly.
patrol look at the coastline as well as coastline street. They had at least 2 CSOs. existing, I think more than that lean on Lieutenant CROs that,. yet CSOs provide all day, two officers on overtime. every weekend PD was functioning directly with the county. environmental wellness department.I ' ll talk to that on the complying with slide, yet a great deal of sychronisation, car park enforcement, parks and rec too.
Faced last summer season? Following slide. And as we ' ve worked via this, both the presentation, yet this.

Previous housing elements we ' ve shared in home, yet there are added requirements now that( indistinct) we simply, we don ' t have the personnel and we. I didn ' t obtain as a lot, I imply, we got 79 feedbacks, yet we most likely obtained less than 40 of them consisted of the leas, so it wasn ' t as valuable as it could have. It personally, I think indeed, have all those devices that are being used either complimentary or reduced revenue, but that isn ' t agent of what someone that ' s not. I ' ll start with some background of how we got where we are today, we ' re below due to the fact that of the legislation SB9-46 as well as that was passed in 2018 and also it says, it was truly focused on entrepreneurship and making sure that low revenue immigrant business owners can construct services as well as make a living with street vending.And so the legislation was actually concentrated on making it. I ' m gon na turn it over to per supervisor, Tony Elliot as well as he '
s gon na talk chat through what we experienced last summerSummer seasonIt'' s a really, actually hectic location, a lot going on with bicycles, pedestrians, train popular, very active area and also after that obviously ecological impacts as well and also so what we'' re attempting to do here is look for resolute to deal with those those core problems facing.So thank you and

with that, I will certainly hand it off the following audio speaker, thanks.- Great night, I see councilman Boulder has her hand up, I didn ' t know, are we gon na wait up until completion
of the concerns or, all right, we'' ll wait for that. Okay, well, great night, I'' m truly happy to be here with you to discuss the draft pathway in the statute. So allow'' s get into it, following slide please. Prior to I dive into the specific, it'' s vital to just get as, or like vocabulary principles down as well as these ideas come from SB9-46, one principle is that of the stationary supplier, that'' s somebody that vents from a dealt with location, a roaming supplier is somebody that relocates from
the area and also actually just stops to (indistinct).

The term roaming supplier is not to be puzzled with the term mobile vendor, which is currently managed in SCMC 5-222, as well as those are food trucks and also those are not truly impacted considerably by– Following slide please. Section 582, is an area called walkway vending conduct as well as these are essentially, great neighbor rules. Therefore personnel generated regarding 22 basic specifications that we assume are necessary to adhere to when vending on and all of these are very closely related to public wellness as well as which is specifically what S force is attempting to access as well as the purpose of these rules is in fact twofold. Undoubtedly, this is a publicly readily available standard procedure that any type of vendor or cops policeman can understand and check out what it means and also how you'' re behave.But second and also maybe even a lot more significantly, these regulations are gon na the basis of the city'' s allowing choices and also when choosing whether decline or confirm sidewalk permit application. There'' s some transparency in what'' s gon na be tolerated, what'' s not gon na be. So I'don ' t demand to read all these to you, yet they are in area 5-82.0 Following slide, okay, so
one of staff ' s significant goals in placing this onward was to establish a citywide authorization program. As well as that is what is consisted of with all suppliers require to obtain a walkway, vending permit via the planning division as well as suppliers that want to operate in park or coastlines or various other parks and also bilities they require to also get an extra parks permit, which is gon na take into account some of things that are allowed by S 6, really is the vending influencing the natural surroundings? Following slide, please. Okay, so, place based constraint, we prepared some location based constraints in the statute, they were composed in a manner that is often tended to follow SB9-46, which truly disfavors broad.So what we

' ve come up with and what'' s ponder right here is stationary vending would be prohibited all year on Pacific avenue, yet just outside of the areas that the city
demarcated vending and areas. These are currently set up, are those little rectangles that get on opportunity established out by little copper circles, brass circles, their little and also there'' s a number of them where folks can go established, produced a table and engage those kinds of fixed tasks, stationary vending is likewise not allowed.You park or beach where there ' s already an inclusive', fresh that language taken directly from. It ' s likewise not permitted within 500 feet of a qualified farmer ' s market, additionally areas that are zoned specifically property.
This is one more language right from SB9-46.
And we consisted of within reside zone park because some input from the corporation on that one. And also within the city ' s open space, natural'and also beautiful areas, such as gold coconut Creek and Loren or Riverwalk and also this was input from the Okay
, and after that, so we have some locations where both fixed and roaming are rotated all year. On the metropolitan battle this was area that was crucial to the parks entertainment department that the there ' s simply not a lot of room available'to talk not to mention that kind of business and so those, it was very important to the parks department that that restriction be consisted of, additionally within the portion of the primary beach over which the city has leisure, the circumstance in Key coastline is a little bit complicated.Part of Main coastline is not technically possessed by the city, but is owned by the seaside come and also the city has a recreational easement only
over it as well as per this easement that is not permitted to enable vending for this 1930s judgment and also that would certainly be vending by both individuals who would commonly consider us a stroll suppliers. As well as additionally, that ' s likewise type of what keeps the side business from sending out from selling because location also. To make sure that was very important to consist of as well on the B road professional'deck and an additional area where personnel really felt that it simply obtained extremely, incredibly congested and there actually is not a great deal of location to be able to involve sales. and afterwards additionally just on a bike path road including within on-street garage a driveway or a public parking area. these are just clarifications and SB9-46 actually talked concerning vending from a walkway, yet we thought that it was essential to likewise include,, that are also contained within within other cities( indistinct )location, okay.And then it was and afterwards the the proposal right here is additionally essentially established that in the summertime season, suggesting it rule with October that there would be no stationary or roaming vending loud on the B road walkway, It simply obtains really crowded, there ' s not a great deal of space that Okay, enforcement the ordinance disadvantage management in system, which is called for by SB9-46, much this area is, 5.82110 and a great deal of this is taken basically precisely From SB9-46 and also there ' s additionally as called for by SB9-46, there ' s a constructed a determination that is consider by the team coordinator? Failure to conform, this was a significant problem that team had there'was a significant concern that we writing these citations folks wouldn ' t pay the citation, or they might obtain an ability, a pay determination that would lower them to extremely low amount as well as that the citations themselves wouldn ' t work to accomplish what is established out to be accomplished.So we made a few tweaks to try to deal with that, one is we defined that management citations can be released on this very same
day. Long that hr has broke down administrative. Again, the fear here was that some individuals would actually just take the citation as well as perhaps they meant to take, perhaps they didn ' t and they would certainly just take it as an expense business and they would certainly not, to make sure that was one stipulation that we included to attend to that we likewise added a minimal
empowerment area to be able to address the failure to conform as well, this is something that has actually been carried out in Santa Monica as well as San Diego likewise simply often, or that contains empowerment area, we tried to make it limited so that it ' s really simply people that use to relocate their things when they ' re asking go, however we ' ve got that as well as we think that it will certainly be effective in order to really achieve conformity, okay and after that I ' m almost done, but as we were undergoing the ordinance day something turned up that and also we resembled, oh, possibly this need to be made clear, so I thought we would include it right into the presentation as the last slide, we
were pondering the parks vending permit as well as it was,'I believe it was a number of our
understanding that a parks vending authorization would be required for any vending that would certainly be allowed on road on the walkway there, just because that pathway is actually a component of the park, there are benches, there are, individuals are viewing volley ball, it ' s really the entry to the park therefore we do really feel that it ' s essential to have the park spending authorization need for that as well, but it wasn ' t very clear in how the statute was composed that that would be required.So we would suggest that you add this underlying language below, which is to specify that the park spending would certainly be'required for pathway
suppliers that want to operate the City Park beach or various other facility within the jurisdiction of the parks leisure division, including that section of the coastline street

walkway run by the parks leisure division. That ' s just to clarify what our understanding was which would be our suggest. I think that ' s my entire presentation
.- Thanks.- I ' m gon na walk you through just the application of the statute. The statute itself and ensuring that it clear and also audio is the initial part. As well as then'exactly how we roll it out is mosting likely to be vital to the success for both suppliers and the city team who are billed with taking care of the application of the ordinance. You know we ' re really grounded in addressing the threats, every one of the regulation and after that just how we ' ll be applying our emphasis on public health and wellness and security, shielding the native environment, making certain that we are utilizing our fiscal sources properly and that we are offering these
diverse populaces that we know are engaged pathway keeping and vending with the spirit of SB9-46 as we roll this statute out, so to get based in what individuals needed', we did a great deal of outreach and a whole lot of interaction, Sarah, before she left.And after that I selected up the baton, as I claimed. And also did some more in the last weeks before we brought this ordinance as well as presentation to you
tonight we spoke with sidewalk suppliers, chatted with coastline companies and also coastline location businesses and downtown services, neighborhood based organizations that are serving especially the the Latino populations in Santa Cruz
. We spoke with our chosen authorities in 2014 when we were in

the middle of our 2021. Every one of the problems that we were having in 2021, some of our state chooses as well as local elects obtained involved. Therefore we ensured to obtain them in the loophole.
The headed out to city to employees and actually ask their opinions
about exactly how we should be applying this ordinance.And we also talked to the city of Santa Monica, which is kind of experiencing a great deal of the exact same things that we are around vending as well as also as a historic right here and also a great deal of similarities in between here, below as well as there. Therefore we desired to learn
from their experiences. So we heard a great deal of various
problems, but we heard a great deal of the very same concerns from different constituencies. Everybody desires us to advertise security, there, the individuals on all sides really desire us to have a look at the effects of bad behavior. So like we see in various other areas, it ' s not there are lots of vendors are doing precisely the ideal thing and so we wan na make certain that what we are doing is supporting those vendors that are adhering to the excellent neighbor regulations and afterwards making sure that we have we have safeguards in position for those that possibly aren ' t following the policies as much.We wan na promote equity throughout this. Pathway vending, make sure that making certain that that is a feasible and sustained company kind, yet additionally tax collection
that we ' re making sure certain our bricks and mortar businesses are not poorly impacted influenced the ordinanceStatute. And after that making conformity less complicated, I believe it ' s made complex. As well as so how can we come at this to make sure that we are interacting with individuals on all sides of the issue in means that they understand what ' s expected as well as and how to plug in, so among the important things that is pondered as well as application is idea of a one quit application for all pathway Instead than the sidewalk. vendor mosting likely to parks or mosting likely to planning or going to that, we ' re gon na assist them with all of the city allows that we require them to reach remain in excellent stead to vend within the city and also after that making sure that those guidelines are available and understandable.So when we speak about the licenses, it ' s a reduced license charge. There was an analysis after that and I assume this remains in your PA, this remains in your package of how we obtained to the $30 license cost, a cover city price it ' s valid for year. It will describe the desired time way instead of vending on the permit. To ensure that as our enforcement policemans go out and also send out, are working with folks to make sure'that they ' re sticking
to the regulations that they have that easily accessible ID, this likewise addresses problems regarding migration status and also the as well as the absence of rate of interest in sharing and sharing an ID.

if we have a vendor ID that actually places everybody on the very same having fun field. as well as just how they ' re interacting with with code enforcement or CSO additional called for authorizations, depending upon just how you desire'to vend, or you intend to vend you ' ll need a cap of parks permit as Cassie chatted about for beaches and also parks as well as parks as well as recreation centers,
a food permit.If you ' re vending food that comes from region ecological health and wellness, we would not use, not provide that license, however we
will help guide people to the place that they require to go to get the permit. Excuse me, if you ' re selling greater than 6 days in the city, you need a business permit and if you ' re doing even more than three purchases each year, you need a The golden state sellers. As well as so these will be depending on what the individual is doing
, will be required at the time of issuance of the walkway vending'authorization. We ' ll be examining off every one of these authorization that are called for based upon what they ' re advancing and wanting, we wan na

make compliance simple as well as simple on both sides, both for city team and also for the
vendors. So seeing to it that we ' re. doing a great outreach
campaign beforehand as well as I ' ll talk. a bit extra regarding that in the following slide.Having a noticeable system,. an advise suggestion versus a tag that someone places in their. pocket or in their budget. And after that making sure that.
every one of our interactions are bilingual which they are … That both the education side.
of points are bilingual, yet additionally the citation. issuance and monitoring, is that we ' re offering it. in English and in Spanish. We ' re education and learning and also outreach.
we ' ll make use of the moment, presuming. if we obtain your blessing on the statute this night, in between currently and also when the. ordinance enters into result to begin interacting with individuals in the main vending areas'producing
those program materials,. bilingual program products.

Work with some outbound.
supplier communications. I kind of strolled and also.
spoken with some suppliers down on beat road last.
week as well as got a feeling of we need to truly be. multimodal in the means that we '
re connecting so.
that we are getting to individuals in the method that they … That text message, is it a website? How are we', just how do they interact with communications and also. truly, truly clear presence and all of the areas that have substantial laws we ' ll be taking a joint enforcement technique. We assumed this was. really, actually important. The team came together.
as well as tried to issue fix and came to the concept, involved the suggestion that it doesn ' t belong in just one division, the code conformity policemans really find out about authorizations and also they can speak with folks while, police officers and also communities are service, officers can help. with those public wellness safety and also well-being effects that we spoke about, seeing to it that there ' s access and also egress and ADA conformities being recognized in the crowded locations which kinda point and then'of course, county region ecological wellness also has a duty to play as it associates with food vendors in this kind of enforcement technique of the regulation, we wished to focus our first, targeted enforcement on those areas where we truly recognize that actions modification needs to occur, where the regulations will. bring forward actions adjustment, that is really various. where we are today.So returning to the Pacific. Exactly how are we making certain that folks understand what they require to do? And exactly how do we likewise frontload. We have actually to be focused.
on, on that particular habits.

We have a map, these are.
the existing places on Pacific opportunity that are.
As well as these are the addresses.
make every one of the products were for your'factor to consider today.We type of got some more reduced technology variations to check out as well as then if we consider beach road, just, I wanted to mention kind of where those restrictions that we spoke about previously, so as you can see here along beach street, that would certainly be the pro during throughout April to October Powell beach has a concessionaire ' s arrangement therefore it would roaming vending would be permitted,.
we can try out is a concentrate on artisan,. so a focus on arts and craft vendors as well as those individuals that we understand are available, like the person in this photo, octavo his his partner makes all

the bracelets that are on his on his board there therefore having that restricted emphasis, I feel.
like they'have a smaller sized footprint there ' s less trash which we are, if, if there was a restricted day ending areas on that road area in between the beach. firm as well as suitable exposing grill that we can still work to take care of the wellness, safety and security as well as well-being effects, that we experienced last summer, nonetheless, by

not locking it down it does call for by knock, locking it down, completely feel like that exchange will certainly need more staffing to make it successful.Just a last bit, we.
Senator, legislator Allen was placing forward a. bill it ' s in for right now ' cause SB 1290, our payments actually made it in and I ' m very delighted to say as well as the things that we desired to place in.
You have a budget in. And also then there ' s equipment that goes along with up and then going ahead, we suggest a senior.

As well as likewise, that ' s additionally kind of what keeps the side company from sending out from offering in that location. From SB9-46 and also there ' s additionally as needed by SB9-46, there ' s a developed a decision that is contemplate by the team coordinator? I believe that ' s my entire discussion
. And after that making compliance less complicated, I think it ' s complicated. Senator, legislator Allen was placing ahead a. expense it ' s in for right now ' cause SB 1290, our contributions really made it in and I ' m extremely thrilled to say and also the things that we wanted to put in.And also we imagine that there
will certainly be appeals that originate from any citation, new citation program.And once more, augmenting that code conformity professional with some code conformity, assistance, agreement code compliance assistance in those 6 months in the April to October duration together with contract protection. And after that in regards to CSOs we would boost all of this with hours from our present CSOs on team as we did last summertime. As you saw in the packet, we have actually some recommended actions for you. I ' ll swiftly gone through those, we ' re recommending that you introduce for publication a statute disclosing the current metropolitan code and also placing this new
ordinance in its area, embracing a resolution to produce a brand-new pathway vending cost, or that walkway vending allow
that we discussed that ' s regarding$ 30.
Now we ' ll respond to any of your inquiries.- Thanks, Elizabeth, I will get to council participant concern and direct elevated Renee gold council member Boulder and also after that council member Myers.- First, I simply wan na state thanks so much, Elizabeth, for choosing up where Sarah ended.
And the initial one that I was asking yourself was
… And also I also wan na state thank you for the stakeholder engagement also, I assume that was actually important to making it a successful referral.

I did have a concern and also this was something that showed up in 2014 as well as I ' m simply and I didn ' t see it resolved in here is in your outreach with the vendors. Does anybody else wan na include? I have one more concern.
– I ' d most likely be( indistinct) question.
– That ' s a good call, thank you.- Thank you.
Council member Myers and afterwards council participant Terry Johnson.
Did you ever before cite anyone for any of
these storm drain drainpipeDiscarding I was just curious, I. saw rather a little bit of that when I was, I am not aware. I think currently that we have the, or it ' s all in one area as well as.
we and also it gives us the capacity to
really be clear concerning what. flavors we ' re searching for as well as so we have that. opportunity going onward.
– So that would cross. over Cassie when it come to, we have our tornado water statute with occasions services as well as so those two points speak with me, that activity was happening,'it would get … There would certainly be some citation. or a minimum of ideally much more, a softer technique to at first begin with, which is, “Hey, these go to the sea.” Is that kind of. running because warm water? Yeah, so, I mean, we. attempted to sort of challenging ' cause we intended to establish.
And also so we attempted to make it clear that the policies are the
rules regulations if it ' s something that ' s
not related to sidewalk vendingWalkway then.
you be affected by it.I believe one of the major issues with tornado water dumping is actually similar to catching individuals, I mean, possibly they might. do it before you as an individual walking by to the coastline, so if they see Bernie or if. they see a law enforcement officer, I think that ' s a lot.

less likely to actually like observe something, yeah. -As well as I assume, I indicate,. always an always an excellent technique is just making. sure we ' ve got material Spanish and also simply a little bit of a lighter hand, just potentially I understand when I would certainly go down and also clip the
beach or attempt to speak with even simply that lighter hand a little around just does resonate, perhaps not boiling down too far, today functioning
on that and after that my other question was, Elizabeth, there was a group of companies that we satisfied with most likely I wan na state, three or 4 times last year. It was a large team, 20. some weird service area. I would obtain these calls. as a Mayor and assisted to report down for a. meeting and those people have been followed this, I assume, I recognize so that. represented a great deal of the ownership of a great deal of business on coastline, yet likewise we obtained a letter from the desire
in and also a pair of others, yet is that the team when you were saying, is that the group that you were referring. to as a few of those folks we ' ve satisfied last summer?- We have actually been working with
seaside who is making a management. role with those( indistinct) services therefore, yes, I. assume we can confidently claim by the letters can be found in, that the message is going out on the statute. that they are helpful, those are my inquiries in the meantime, but yeah, seconding, if there. is a motion by council member Rock later.Thank you
.- Thank you, council member Terry Johnson. And also then council member— Thanks so much( indistinct) additionally restate( audio declines) Did have, sorry, I ' m like,( indistinct).
I did have this couple. of remarks as well as concerns. Elizabeth, you chatted regarding the supplier ID, it attends to the integration condition, hearing a little bit more regarding that, what is required for a supplier ID and also just how can we kind of. those community members that are undocumented that. they can be rest guaranteed that they can have equal accessibility?- Cassie could be able to speak. to the really details terms, yet I can speak normally. that we are asking for some identification, but they do not need to. be documented citizens. Is that right, Cassie?- That ' s appropriate, that ' s around.- So there is a requirement. for some type of recognition in the application procedure, but it is not it is not. citizenship associated.- Okay, wonderful, thank you.
As well as I was truly also pleased to read about the outreach.
that ' s been done so much, that ' s great, I ' ve tried to. attach some companies that'are involved with'. this community too.
I ' m interested in staying. involved as you all do the work, interested about the application, the growth for the authorization process. I understand this perception pass tonight, however, for us to consider. really use our health and wellness in all policies framework,.'as a guiding structure to establish what application appearance like.Think about that we can … I ' m certain we ' re gon na need to.
have some restrictions, right? In terms of prioritization. and also who we think about, I really hope that we can make use of the. health policies structure to make those. And after that( indistinct),. yeah, I believe (indistinct). Were all resolved, so, thanks.- Thank you, council member Terry Johnson. Council member Cumming.

– Thanks for the presentation. And also the work ' s being done on this.
I know it ' s been a few years as well as this initially started during COVID. We were trying when there were a lot of people marketing as well as. vending in the beach location and also we saw a whole lot of issues consequently in trying to get individuals to not crowd as well as socially distanced. was truly tough under these circumstances.But along with that scenario, there ' s a lot of negative. impacts we ' re seeing in terms of fashion and also. still adverse experiences. It ' s great that we ' re trying to figure out a means to figure out a way
to work function everyoneEverybody I did have a couple pair inquiries to IDs permits licensing. I guess my. question is it was pointed out that permit fee is gon na be$ 30. I ' m just interested,

. because I assumed I heard or possibly check out someplace. that in 2015 it was$ 500
. Therefore I simply desired to see. , if we can obtain information on what the authorization fee was for the suppliers down street last year..- It was, for beach street. specifically, so the $30 is for anybody that wishes to. choose vend on a pathway in the city of Santa. Cruz, so it ' s not particular to the coastline location. We yapped concerning the beach, I'assume due to the effect that have actually been occurring on the beach, however the $30 is

the walkway vending.
There are those other permits that could be called for like the parks as well as recreation permit, which that charge has actually not yet been the and also so Tony and also his team with the
Okay, from council to move ahead with this ordinance
will begin will certainly process and Procedure indicated that suggested would come would certainly for accrual by amassing.- Thank you, the next inquiry I had was– No, I think spirit of this is. I ' m just interested with the.
– I am not certain about that. one is a county, sorry,. the service certificate Butler, can you aid me with this one? Do you, are you familiar. with these authorizations? I understand the service licenses does, -It is. Which ' s what I was
gon na get on. Simply a moment back, just explain that, yes, there is a company. that ' s additionally, I was really simply looking to see if I can find that cost and also so I ' ll get back to you in just a second on that particular cost, to my expertise, there is not, it states around $175 total, so we might pay about. $175 for the business license about$ 145 in sidewalk permit, which is$ 30, so. 175 total is the price there.And to my knowledge, there. Is not a requirement for any type of, it it ' s basically
a tax?, It is, you wan na run a in the city and so you are paying tax and we after that make use of that cash or shipment of solutions.- Likewise, with the. sellers, the state sellers that is state licenses, I put on ' t think have an immigration normally. have a migration. we can validate that though
as well as return to you, I ' ve made a note back to you.- That ' d be fantastic, thanks. And afterwards I guess the. various other concern I have is, I check out correctly there ' s. conversation regarding bringing on one more service police officer. And also I ' m simply, so there ' s no. community service policeman being brought on.- That was a part of. the preliminary discussion, what we made a decision and also I can. allow Bernie talk with
this, yet simply our team, our group chose that perhaps we can make it collaborate with the current existing staffing, but I ' m gon na let the professional talk to it.Bernie, would you like to tell us regarding your staffing in your department? Yeah, we discuss this a lot and also obviously, we would love to approach. it with social work policemans versus
policemans, primary. Phone number 2, we additionally genuine that. by the time we would certainly be able to hire and also hire and also educate. an area
solution police officer in the summertime, lengthy gone. So we ' re mosting likely to resolve it with our existing team currently. And also as we pointed out with the partnership with the various other divisions, in addition to the region, like as well as in, along with the private security vendor, that layered strategy was, was a much better suitable for this coming summer, appears great, I just, I saw that in the team. record and also simply intended to bring that up due to the fact that I recognize that there are kinda training timelines, I was just curious, because I know that as well.Our police departments. had a kinda a difficult time hiring neighborhood safety and security policemans'. If that was gon na be a concern moving this onward, I was just asking yourself. As well as so thanks which concludes my remarks or my concern,. I ' ll have comments back.- Say goodbye to questions, we ' ll after that take it out to public remark. Currently, we ' re intriguing discussing sidewalk vending regulation. program and resource demand.
You can increase your hand by dialing star 9 on your phone. or select raise hand on webinars devices on your computer.When it ' s your turn to talk,. you ' ll hear a news and also the timer will certainly after that. be set 3 mins Going out to the one. participant with a hand raised. Zachary Davis, welcome.- Hey there you. All right?- Yes.- All right, yeah, just actual quick, I wished to claim as a company owner, I support entrepreneurialism'. for the spirit of SB9-46 as well as I also support law that allows both the walkway suppliers,. brick quarter vendors to benefit organization activity( indistinct) and support the passage
of this statute. I think helpful for any person worried. I do wan na reveal a little.
And also I ' m a little let down that that won ' t be a requirement, does appear like that I believe one.
That ' s my one( indistinct), many thanks.- Thank you for your remark. Okay,'wear ' t see various other participants.
Allow ' s see, council member Cummings as well as council participant Rock,. I have your hands please.
I put on ' t like, I assume.

are vending on the road during the weekdays, it ' s. normally just the weekend vacations'when we have one of the most issues.So allowing people to. in fact been down there and to
the team ' s point, also if we

wan na make that simply craftsmen might be an excellent way in the spirit of.
the state law to enable more vending because location
and also so'I assume that it would certainly, if we consist of some language around that and consequently I have actually offered some language, so, along with the staff suggestion, I have additional. language, which we route parks division to attract a resolution, developing a limited vending zone as well as or city demarcated. vending as well as display area on the street sidewalk.
road in between the third and also metropolitan road and. provide auto parking permits, vendors spent for those in.
the 2021 program failures, then under the statute language for 58.80.080, I simply wanted. to tidy up some language to ensure that it ' s clear that this. is related to restricting vending times and places. that under 5.82.080.- Council member Golder had. an intent to make a movement, little overwhelmed on the top. None of us can be, can. appear to be with your hand up things, so, sorry, (indistinct). We had two council participants. that tried to express that they were gon na make. a movement therefore, anyways.
– I just like to ask, what is the policy around making a, due to the fact that. in the past it was we waited till the end of public comment and after that if people were paying attention they put their hands up and after that today it ' s change making movements prior to things go out to public comment,. This is'undoubtedly off subject
conversationDiscussion but yet ' s happened in the past previous, that council members participants expressions that they would would certainly such as make a motion movement prior to to public comment.
And also other council. participants have actually increased their hands and afterwards were. contacted made motion.So I ' m trying to do what was historic technique therefore I waited till the individual had actually made their comment, I increased my hand. And also in addition, I had.
extra language, to ensure that became part of the reason I desired to make this. activity due to the fact that I have additions to the personnel suggestion also. -Go in advance and also continue,. council member Stone. And we ' ll phone call on council member Stone.- I should proceed?- Council member Cumming, after that we will follow.- Thanks. So the regulation language to improved that it ' s all year on public residential or commercial property and also areas that are zoned.
specifically property, including within live.
zone park and also this is under

that'bullet factor, 58.0.080, this is where vending can be. situated if you have a license.

As well as so we attempted to make it clear that the guidelines are the
rules policies as well as it ' s something that ' s
not related to sidewalk vending, then.
– That ' s correct, that ' s out there. It ' s excellent that we ' re attempting to figure out a means to figure out a way
to work function everyone, I did have a couple pair concerns associated IDs permits allows. And also I ' m just, so there ' s no. And also I ' m a little let down that that won ' t be a demand, does appear like that I believe one.and afterwards 582.080 P1 including
in from April 1st to October 31st streets and sidewalks road in between the metropolitan third
road without an authorization and also outdoors marketed areas and also in display screen areas as established of
parks and rec department 5.82.080 before year round on the road promenade deck out division as well as outside demarcated areas and also
Screen areas as established up by the parks and rec division as well as then in 5.82.110, this is relevant to charges or the citations and fines, it'' ll be $ 100 for
That'' s end of the activity. Sandy council participant, all right, we have an activity by council participant Cummings as well as a 2nd by council participant Brown. (indistinct) I take explanation.
really quick on the second. – The highlighted word. – Yeah, council participant Cumming stated outdoors city market areas, but motion language said.
within, so (indistinct). – Oh, so it'' s limited. vending times and also places, so it'' s restricted from–( indistinct )So it'' s restricted from.
April 1st till October 31st on the roads and walkways, each street between the.
metropolitan ward 3rd road without an authorization. And without an authorization.
then outside the location, yeah, need to be outdoors, sorry.So people

would certainly be able to vend within those demarcated.
areas with a permit. – May I ask a making clear concern? – Sure. – Would it additionally, would certainly it be.
and outside demarcated areas and lay areas? – Yes. Is that what you (indistinct).
– Yes. – And may I ask a clarifying.
inquiry to Elizabeth Smith? There was a lied about.
some choice choice towards completion. Is that what this is addressing? – Yes, I assume it is, it is providing the capacity to allow for some vending on– – The three to five spaces as well as option.

– Correct. There'' s much less uniqueness below and that'' s something that. the council ' s prompting, but I believe the intent has.
that choice option. I will certainly state personnel wanted a full lockdown of road, but we might attempt to cope with it. – And after that council member Cummings, had another concern.
Thank you. – Okay, so just to make clear the underlying portion or what you have added team recommendations?
First bullet, yes, second bullet, yes, third bullet, it'' s the additions are … The addition starts without. As well as after that the fourth bullet.
it'' s after cautioning.- And then that base.
bullet, fifty percent resolution (indistinct) as well as on the street and also pathway coastline. – Oh, must simply be pathway. And I would additionally include the.
coastline street boardwalk deck. – And another clearing up.
concern for personnel, the boardwalk deck, that.
was one of the areas along with the jetty that was.
recommended for many years round, no vending, is that correct? – Correct, it is the site.
of the license program in 2014 as well as we the Tony.
can talk to this actually, – So council member Cummings,.
The concept would certainly be that the parks and also entertainment division figure out where these locations, these location are. And these locations.
can be on beach road between the community ward third road as well as include the promenade deck, ought to they figure out that.
It ' s not truly securing anything in, it'' s simply claiming that these are areas that belong to the city where we'' ve seen coastline vending before, we ' ve suggested beach vending prior to and leaving those open as– – Can you clear up the complimentary license? – So last year they were.
and going back to 2020, there were members of the.
public who were engaging in the beach vending, they, when we quit.
the vending in that area, component of the outreach was.
that we'' d got to out to the suppliers, functioning.
with community bridges and having meetings ahead.
up with a program for them to be able to vend in the area.We then determine what that. program was gon na be as a city. These people paid the.
charges and then last summertime there was no enforcement. Numerous of these people that believed they were gon na be able to.
vend in a specific area, as well as they paid the fees up front, were then the spaces were.
elbowed in by other individuals in particular situations. And these people weren'' t,. didn ' t pay those. Therefore it ' s unfair that these individuals underwent
the process assisted. the city develop a lotto game, paid for the authorization. And after that when it came time.
for them to be able to vend, there was no enforcement and also that was and therefore, it was.
just an unfair circumstance for them to be in, so. – Great, supervisor Tony Elliot.
As well as so I'' d like to provide,. And likewise ask if anybody has.
– Yeah, mayor Brunner. We had 6 vendors last year.
that were permitted and also paid the start of the period, as an outcome of the problems encountered and also that council member.
Cummings simply recognized, we in fact did repay.
every one of those suppliers at the end of the period in 2014 due to the concerns that they faced, so they'' ve all been. compensated right now. – Thank you for that input. Supervisor Lee Butler. Thanks, Mayor Brunner,.
I was simply gon na go back to one of the concerns that you inquired about the slide that Elizabeth shared. As well as in fact, I was assuming.
you were referring to the one that Cassie presented with the staff asked for explanation, which I wear'' t think is recorded in this, yet I simply intended to call that out. If the– Let'' s see, 5.82, no it'' s the O9OA, is what Cassie had actually specified, which was just that a parks.
license would certainly be called for on B. So I simply desired to call.
– I'' ll just claim it ' s the team as well as suggestion with. – Great, that works, thank you. Okay, thank you for those information.
to clear up whatever Lee simply discussed is that not in below as well as I require to include it. So I don'' t think I obtained that.- I would certainly like for it to be added. its due to the fact that right here we are setting. 4 particular amendments to the code. As well as so I believe it would be excellent to just that'' s a certain. modification too, so it'' d be good to set that out.

– To send it to me actual or … – I think I did, I'' ll. forward it to you again. – Okay.- And after that we have( indistinct)
,. you have your hand up.- Yeah, thank you, Mayor,.
I simply desired to comment concerning the the enhancement caution. I think that we value.
the intent behind that, we all, I assume all divisions.
from code conformity to the region, to the police department, mean on education first.
on this type of point. There'' ll be lots of signs, yet I do wan na offer your.
interest, the trouble with trying to track advising amongst various divisions, if the authorities division of.
a social work policeman is issuing or speaking to a supplier, exactly how close the track that.
That simply is tough and actually complicated and also again, I form the intent and objective behind that. I think that that'' s. gon na be the intent of all city staff from the obtain go anyways, so that addition adds some issue. – Well, I'' m satisfied to.
people with spoken cautions. I'' m delighted to remove that. – Council member Cummings.
are you likewise taking into consideration getting rid of the cost-free licenses? – Recognizing that were … – Yep. – So, you guys (indistinct) sounds like council member Cummings has actually erased after cautioning.
and permit the bottom bullet. – And also where is it attempting.
to discover the permit? – The lower bullet towards the bottom scroll down, right there, that last component of the sentence. (indistinct) The second of the movement council member Brownish responsive fact I will certainly take it bent on council participant Rock and afterwards council member Myers, so I'' d like to offer us movement and also that ' s gon na be the.

personnel ' s recommendation.And I simply wan na express. exactly how aggravated I am with you council member Cummings, I seem like this is something that takes place rather frequently, where.
you control the movement to fight this truly particular language that staff hasn'' t had time to review. We place ' t had time to examine.
and afterwards you have us work out with you throughout night. Most of us had a possibility to give input on this, I recognize Elizabeth that.
with each one of us and you might have dropped.
this onward before tonight at nine o'' clock at night,.
I'' m calling the question.- I ' m gon na call a factor of order. – What'' s your factor of order?
on the floor also, so I believe you can hear.
council member Cumming'' s point of order may proceed to motion, It'' ll be an additional 20 minutes.The point of order

is that we are expected to be adhering to guidelines, as well as part of those rules. discussion forum are that we speak with the products prior to us, not. assault each other as coworkers, council participants as well as we ' re. expected to be setting an'example of community. As well as so point of order is that. we ' re intended to be talking'to the thing,. – Okay. – And I'' ll make additionally. remark later on, thanks. – Okay, as well as now– – There is an alternative.
prior to the council, the vote would certainly be accept.
the and also the motion council participant Boulder is.
made by council member Rock and also it'' s staff suggestion. With added with language.
added as well as there'' s a second by council member– Can I ask a making clear concern? – Yes. – It'' s my understanding, we require to vote whether to accept movement prior to we vote on the activity. I assumed I claim electing on the activity. – No, you'' re correct,.
council member Brown, that replace motion is.
whether to accept subs, there'' s also a phone call to.
' Create the inquiry was called whether it was a second concern was called on whether that'' s. a good vote on the subs. Okay, roll phone call.
We ' re voting to accept', you ' re voting on whether to accept this as a movement – Yes, aye. Member Terry Johnson. And also for the record, I'' ve been.
to make referrals, make modifications to activity.
our personnel recommendations when it'' s suitable. And the recommendations.
I supplied based upon input and comment from members of the area. No. – Broown. – No. And I'' ll see, my further document comment will discuss that. Actually, I'' ll say it currently
,. I just have to state this. It'' s my understanding that.
the function of city board as a legislative body is pass, mull over to our service in public, that is what I, when I.
was elected to office and also so in some cases it'' s unpleasant. Occasionally it takes a long.
time, yet mulling over and often words,.
a point, agenda things, these common method, it has prevailed practice on this council,.
I began following it 30 years earlier, I have.
watched several council participants do this as well as it has never ever been doubted that we have a right to do this, It'' s in fact our response.So I just had to state that for the record. – Council member Myers. As well as I simply wan na make a.
remark team, I wan na take staff for all their service this, the last 2 years have actually, have been really, really challenging down there, every person as well as I assume the as well as Elizabeth and also the entire group, I'' m actually. appreciative that you guys really obtained with each other as.
Mayor, hi and Mayor Brunner, no. I truly would like to think.
some minimal vending along.I assume and also when we discuss equity as well as we speak about some. of the spirit of SB9-46, I heard a number of times and people accessibility. I actually, after speaking with.
various perspectives on this, I do agree.
that limited could work. Either way it will be.
a take off the ground, that similar to every little thing.
we can continue to look and also refine at this as we progress. Let'' s see, it looks like the. sub the staff recommendation with Cassie Ronson'' s pass.
with a fourth three vote.Let '

s see, I still have actually a.
couple hands up Watkins, – I'' m gon na reduced my hand, – And also it resembles that.
ends our meeting today. As well as this meeting will currently be adjourned. Thanks everybody for being below with us.

That'' s end of the movement. It ' s not actually locking anything in, it'' s just saying that these are locations that belong to the city where we'' ve seen beach vending in the past, we ' ve advised beach vending prior to and leaving those open as– – Can you clear up the free permit? – I'' ll simply say it ' s the staff and recommendation with. It'' s my understanding that.
Allow'' s see, it looks like the.

As found on YouTube

PEOPLE – SERVICES – IMPACT