– Hey. Is our city staff ready? – Yeah. – Thanks, fine. Greetings, welcome to the 10:30 a.m. public portion of the shut session
of the March 22nd, 2022, conference of the Common council. , if you would certainly such as to comment
on a closed session thing, now is the time to hire the
guidelines on your display. In this component of the conference,
the council will get public statement, afterwards, the general public line
will be closed and also inaccessible. Please silence your television
or streaming device when you call and
pay attention via the phone. Please note, there is
a hold-up in streaming. If you continue to
pay attention on your television or streaming device, you
might miss your opportunity. I want to ask the clerk,
to please call the duty. – [Clerk] Mayor Johnson. (indistinct). – [Staff] (indistinct). – Here. – [Staff] (indistinct). (indistinct) (indistinct) (indistinct) Watkin. – Below. – [Staff] Mayor Brunner. – Present. Thanks. Currently, are there
any type of members of the public who want to take any kind of items provided on the shut session
program products one as well as 2, please elevate your hand
either by dialing celebrity 9 on your phone or select
Okay, allow'' s go out to guests. (indistinct) Okay. We are simply around to begin.
our afternoon session. Just returning from closed session. As well as it appears like, clerk,.
ae you all set to begin? Okay, so allow'' s begin.Good mid-day. Welcome to the 12:00 p.m. session of the March 22nd, 2022 conference of the.
Santa Cruz City Council. I would love to ask the.
staff, please call role. – [Staff] So (indistinct) Johnson. – Existing. (indistinct) – Right here. (indistinct) – Below. – [Staff] Mayor Watson. – Here. – Present. (indistinct) Okay, thanks, so let'' s see. Currently we will start with presentations and also the first one being a presentation, the Mayoral proclamation.
proclaiming March 2022, Red Cross Month for the city of Santa Cruz. and have Anita, (indistinct).
And (indistinct) here with us. [Male guest 1] Hi,.
I'' m below, we ' re right here. -Welcome. -[. Clerk] Mayor Anita ' s having– -Okay. I will go in advance as well as.
Whereas in times of crisis,. This altruistic spirit is component of the foundation of our neighborhood.
volunteers as well as contributors. And whereas in 1881, Clara Barton started the American Red Cross, turning her unwavering.
devotion for assisting others into a strong goal of stopping.
as well as easing suffering. And whereas today, more.
than 140 years later, we honor the kindness in.
our Red Cross volunteers here in Santa Cruz who.
remain to accomplish Clara Barton'' s life saving legacy.Joining the numerous
. people throughout( indistinct) that offer, offer. blood, donate monetarily or learn essential life offering.
abilities via the Red Cross. And also whereas nation of.
regional Red Cross volunteers, 189 in the area, give.
hope one of the most prone in their darkest hours. Last year in Santa Cruz.
region volunteers assisted 33 house affected by 24 residence fires by resolving their urgent.
like food as well as lodging, as well as giving recuperation support, gathering over 3,900 blood donations, given emergency treatment as well as CPR training to over 1,400 homeowners. Assisted family members of over.
500 pupils prepare for calamities through Pillow Situation task as well as aided over 40.
households of our militaries. As well as whereas simply worked as well as.
relieving suffering is essential stamina in our– And we devote this month of March, all those (indistinct) the worthy tradition of American Red Cross.
owner, Clara Barton, who obeyed her words.Quote, “You need to never think. of “anything except the requirement as well as just how to satisfy it.” Quote. As well as ask others, when in this.” dedication (indistinct ).
Currently, consequently, I Sonja Brunner, Mayor of the city (audio.
drops), thus announce the month of March.
2022, as Red Cross month in the city of Santa Cruz, as well as encourage all citizen to connect and also (indistinct) mission. As well as, I'' d like to welcome,.
Yeah, I'' ll kick it off. Yeah, my name'' s Anita Clarice and I'' m with the Central Post Phase of the American Red Cross. And as you see, joining me is Dan Rippy.I ' m the vice chair of the phase.
accept the unique promo, stating March as Red Cross.
Our objective wouldn'' t be feasible. During our annual Red Cross.
Month event in March, we honor their dedication.
to support people and also families in demand. And also on someone'' s darkest.
day, be that (audio decreases). When head of state Franklin Roosevelt released the first national, this tradition started nearly 80 years back.
Red Cross Month announcement, and also each head of state has.
complied with ever given that. Today, our job is.
powered 90% by volunteers, along with generous.
financial and blood donors, (indistinct). And we are always aiming to.
add extra volunteers. I'' m incredibly proud to.
share a few highlights of what we'' ve accomplished.
with each other over the previous year.We ' ve reacted to the worst fire disaster our location has actually ever experienced, a historical blood shortage.
and are now taking a look at how we can (indistinct) climate. I believe what may go to the.
top of our minds right currently, is the crisis in Ukraine. As well as I would like to share.
upgrade with our Red Cross as well as International Red Cross Assistance. International Red Cross.
teams are ground in Ukraine supplying immediate aid. For the past 8 years,.
International Red Cross have actually provided food, fuel for feeding, clinical materials and assistance for real estate, those living objectives as well are.
on the line of call. which was the Eastern.
border of Ukraine with– As conflict spreads, Red.
Cross groups are enhancing their assistance across the nation, giving first (indistinct).
When assistance can'' t delay throughout emergency situations, American Red Cross.
volunteers and also blood contributors tip up to guarantee people in.
demand receive relief treatment. Your regional Red Cross.
along with region partners has actually offered safeguarding.
feeding and also recovery to those influenced by the recent wildfires as we stream evacuees from Santa.
Cruz and also Monterey county. And also those homeowners displaced after the (indistinct).
tsunami that hit Santa Cruz. as well as for the healing initiative after the CZU, River Dolan and also (indistinct) wild fires, lots of Red Cross supplied.
over two as well as a half million in grant support to neighborhood.
companion companies where assisted locals.
with healing building. In terms of support,.
directly to those residents affected by the 2020 wild fires, the Red Cross sustained.
17 instances for 55 people in Monterey area. And 244,591 people in Santa Cruz county, supplying immediate.
help and also resources for long-term recovery.The Red Cross established
a sanctuary. at Carmel Center College in reaction to Colorado fire in January. Showing that our fire periods. have no( indistinct) period, and we require our communities prepared for one more (indistinct). dry summertime as well as (indistinct).
Anne ' s gon na take over and also. – Thank you, Anita. As well as once more, thank you for inviting us and for acknowledging Red Cross Month.
the United States needs blood, and one contribution by you can conserve up to 3 lives. Red Cross holds blood.
drives across nation for volunteer blood contributors who.
clearly aid those in demand. Over the past year, our.
blood supply has actually lessened to a vital level, number.
of variables, consisting of COVID.And we ask you to
please. support the effort to bring the capacity as well as. assistance blood drive soon. It ' s easy to make a consultation at redcrossblood.org.
and also redcrossblood.org. And also locate a hassle-free drive. We provide,.
Red Cross offer services (indistinct) force and.
worldwide services. Red Cross volunteers.
offer 24/7 worldwide assistance to help military families,.
consisting of much of who have experienced multiple.
releases over the past. In enhancement, as part.
of the world'' s largest humanitarian network, Red Cross employees react to international calamities and aid neighborhoods.
plan for emergency situations around the globe. Locally, we assisted over.
130 active service participants and also their households with.
their emergency circumstances, including monetary help and also emergency situation communication solutions. We were also able to.
provide comfort to experts as well as National guard members.
that may ask for (indistinct). training and solution,.
the Red Cross provide training service personnel, promptly.
adapting local areas to the COVID constraints as well as remaining to train.
as well as re-certify people in a customized environment,.
allowing our very first -responders to stay current.
( indistinct) requirement.They were able to do
. their work uninterrupted. In action to climate modification, Red Cross (indistinct )playing our component current altruistic effect on environment. We will construct the durability. of our organization as well as resilience of. neighborhoods and also the people we serve by adjusting our mission shipment as well as growing our functional capability to attend to the heightened effects and accelerating speed of catastrophe. We will further buy. environmental sustainability via reduction
of our carbon footprint, by supplying our knowings. with community environment education and also advocacy.
Those that share the. Satisfied to share that
our. (laughs )Volunteer position, every.
day individuals in our community count on the Red Cross.
volunteers for assistance. There are many methods you.
can assist neighbors in demand that are our most required setting. That ' s the response volunteers needed. Every eight minutes, Red. Cross responds to disasters across the USA. The majority of these remain in the. type of neighborhood residence fires. When a house fire leave families. stranded in the road, neighborhood Red Cross volunteers provide emergency situation monetary aid, psychological assistance as well as recovery,. help in their following actions( indistinct).
Who are interested in offering please go, excuse me, please go to redcross.org/volunteertoday. for your most required placements( indistinct).
And allow me go over that to you,. redcross.org/volunteertoday. I like to utilize the quote,. today decides tomorrow, if you would certainly such as volunteer tomorrow, I ask that you please indicator. up to offer today. We do need to obtain you right into our systems and be able to provide. you with vital training.
Once more, redcross.org/volunteertoday. In behalf of the American Red Cross, we thanks for this announcement. Most importantly, we would such as. to thanks and also the several of your city personnel. members who work very closely with the American Red Changeover the years to be a much better prepared city. for all kinds of emergency situation as well as catastrophe.- Thank you a lot. We appreciate you. sharing that information.
Thanks. Any council members have any kind of questions? Hey, moving on to our next presentation, we have Connie( indistinct ),. Economic Advancement division with a presentation and upgrade on the library housing.
car parking growth project.
– Thanks, Mayor and great.
( indistinct) council participants. I'' m Bonnie Lipscomb director.
And I'' m going to share my display. We are preparing a much more durable update, one month at those 2.
council meetings now, as well as I'' ll provide you a little preview of what we'' ll be talking. concerning( audio decreases). Really wanted to.
give you an upgrade today. As well as especially, simply talk.
concerning some of our highlights initiatives considering that our last, an update of where we are.
as well as the moment progression. A bit regarding the.
I'' ll provide you an upgrade. Considering that the last council.
conference in December 14th, our council approved the.
updated conceptual style and also website shows. We'' ve really obtained.
started on the total, not below, yet site survey,.
obtaining the precise (indistinct) for that as we ready.
to submit a application preparation that whatever is stood the manner in which we in fact know.How the( indistinct) on the website. We also started the. ecological analysis, we do have one more study by doing this, and I ' m intending to be able. to offer that to you at the
2nd conference in April. We likewise have underway. of (indistinct) record in addition to scientific examination. And then we simply submitted on Monday, submitted with collection at The golden state, a building for the library. And also I ' ll give you a little. bit more history on that particular.
Simply quickly, an upgrade. This is really slide of where we began on the far left of what. With that evolution of.
( indistinct) and support.So as you can
see pushback.
lower dimension of the broad, added real estate on the top, actually.
raised the square footage of the library on the ground.
or included the rooftop yard as well as rooftop area, I desired.
to give you simply a sneak peek of where we are right currently. We … These are certainly in progress. These are composed, but these.
are still what hopefully we'' ll be fine-tuning a bit extra throughout the rest of this.
month and be able to present totally designed (indistinct).
design level illustrations concept. And both for a collection of.
( indistinct )So this is a preview, as I. said, this extremely much draft, but this is really focused on what you saw in just the theoretical.
with some of the products, actually what it will certainly look.
If are standing in the Cedar Road auto parking lot today, like just as. Your following (indistinct) right throughout to the mid block collection. There'' s it from a somewhat angle, just slightly more to the south. So, (audio declines) and.
looking across the way.As you see up right here, you begin.
to see what it would look like on the roof deck which is.
connected with the collection. That'' s 4,500, 5,000 feet. And also currently briefly, I'' m just. gon na offer you an upgrade on the gives that our.
groups did on Monday. This is a grant called the Building Forward.
Library Framework Give. And it is via the.
California State Library, it'' s an affordable give program. Limit grant for the library. We are obtaining the.
maximlibrary give of the strategy. for the library (indistinct) job. Based upon the requirements, we seem like we will certainly be recurring for this give. This will assist us fund a variety of this, consisting of the photovoltaic panels,.
up-to-date HVAC system as well as access features.
amongst various other points. The majority section of the.
grant, near 8 million will certainly be especially for.
protection of the library. We'' re rather delighted regarding this. This will honor and make it possible for.
us on these functions, with the solar panels and.
the eco-friendly roof covering, really, to our objective of internet zero (indistinct) from the library project.So we ' re rather excited to have this, we listen to there ' s a great deal of. passion in our job as for grant in this grant program. So there'' s a relatively quick turnaround, we might satisfy on Monday to.
assistance from the library also, and our job below.
We'' ll upgrade you following month. Just briefly a.
project task timetable upgrade we are right now,.
Ahead to you in (indistinct). We had actually simply completed the.
theoretical design stage. So that was those illustrations.
that last time for principle, where we are currently is our next stage, after most likely a couple months ahead, we'' ll be our( indistinct ). As well as so we'' ll be ahead that stage. Following step we have fairly a few, we are expecting by.
completion of next week to be staying up there preparing. As well as this is a preapplication.
for our official application of that preparation for the various other departments regarding the project, an.
opportunity to deal with those (indistinct).
As I claimed for the end of following week, we'' re additionally planning for.
our following round of outreach as well as we'' re expecting this will certainly get on this thematic layout.
stage, truly concentrating on the collection, the collection layout give in addition to the.
library as well as so we'' re looking at mid month, mid. April for that upgrade, for having that outreach.
as well as concerning council with responses from that outreach for the (indistinct). We'' re also have actually been. having ongoing meetings, they'' ve been very productive.
with the farmer'' s market. We are right now concentrated on lot 7, this whole lot behind and the.
Delmar that goes in between city section is one parcel.
in, (indistinct) Cathcart. So from behind the Delmar.
right to Cathcart. And also we'' re doing … we had actually done some initial layouts in vehicle parking counts and they.
were called above structures they'' re created for the farmer'' s market.We ' re revisiting those, obtained.
Auto parking and not the farmer'' s market, however also with the various other. The suggestion of truly.
having the ability to participate in cathcart part and truly lean right into that pedestrian sale that is planned, which attaches up.
through the river stroll. So we have some actually amazing concepts now that with the farmer'' s market, I think we ' re in a truly great area. And also we ' re working with a feasibility research study of a pair different.
formats right currently. To make sure that'' s something that ideally in the future in the following couple of months we can bring forward to you also. We'' re additionally working with.
That'' s why the application is. We have some things in
there. They can see and update if.
there are any kind of expense implications before we go ahead. That'' ll be ongoing rest.
of thematic style phase.Once we obtain via somatic. design which first preliminary back on our. pre-app application, actually have the ability to really. tighten a few of our cost, and obtain that info. Back to you. As I claimed, our following conference on 4/26, I believe it ' s going to be. a pretty durable upgrade.
It is an off cycle upgrade. instead of waiting, 3 months we intended to you below because we believe we ' ll. have several points next'month to offer you. updates on on the job.
We ' ll also on 4/26, be. And also after that we are targeting.
I will certainly bring out( indistinct ). I just had a remark, I recognize, well, I'' ve been talking with.
people obtain delighted about is not just the possibility for environment-friendly roof, but if there'' s a capacity. for that environment-friendly roofing system room to be made use of for farming.
functions by locals who reside in the real estate units.So that ' s
a really … Kind of I don'' t know words for it. But when you consider.
having low income real estate with accessibility to education child care and after that health food.
production for families that individuals truly get thrilled.
regarding that as a possibility. So just something to.
think about when considering the green roof covering,.
that can be something to that the citizens can.
in fact make use of for generating food. That'' s an advantage that individuals. claimed that they would certainly like.- Great. we'definitely we ' ve been discussing what opportunities we could have for that. there are some load concerns.
in addition to the library with several of the glass and also kind of day lighting.However, we are that could. there be locations where we– That in addition to have.
quite a little bit of open area on the real estate program too. As well as so in some of those community rooms, we have marked areas children, teenagers, after that the neighborhood location. There could be some locations.
for some raising beds also. We'' re looking at all those up. – There is one various other.
inquiry reduce comment. I was thinking of.
within the context of solar is has there, has it likewise been thought about, potentially put wind turbines on the top? '' Reason I recognize that they.
have some that are smaller, they can also generate electricity.And so I was simply thinking of that.- I ' ll pass that on to the style group as well as those that are actually checking out several of the sustainability.- Many thanks.- Thank you, council member, Cummings and council participant, Terry Johnson.- Many thanks so much for the.
discussion, Bonnie, that'' s truly incredible to see.
all the work that'' s been done. If you, I ' m asking yourself.
could provide an update on the conversations on the.
community interaction as well as discussions on the.
present time collection website for this reason making use of that. – Sure, so we completed.
that process back in June for the existing collection site. And also we do have and also I can.
emphasize that with a link following presentation also, however.
we do have recommendation that came out of that process, which for the existing.
collection website suggestions are to look at that as a.
housing website, economical housing website with the Plaza area that possibly could be a future house for the farmer'' s market.So the farmer'' s market, I will certainly state, is delighted about that website. Among their issues is simply the timing. As well as taking a look at lot seven, it.
can either be an acting use temporary use, or if they like it, there could finish up being an irreversible usage. They truly such as to look.
at what is our following step? As well as recognizing that they.
can most likely to that site. Well, library finished.
and the collection moves into the new place. We were going with a.
schedule routine review them and and also of that need requirement, they'' re gon na need require.
have an acting place. What'' s the most effective location for them?
(indistinct) Okay, thank you, so let'' s see. I'' m below, we ' re below. Yeah, my name'' s Anita Clarice and also I'' m with the Central Article Phase of the American Red Cross. There'' s it from a somewhat angle, just somewhat even more to the south. We have some really exciting concepts currently that with the farmer'' s market, I think we ' re in an actually great location.It additionally provides them an
opportunity to decide they like, to make sure that'' s that ' s our plan with the farmer ' s market and also
for present library website, we have those suggestions. And I do assume that eventually
it would certainly be an excellent website, budget friendly housing project
and to have that element of a plaza as well. We'' re concentrated on the present job for the new job currently
We will go back and also look when we get past a factor
on the existing library site as well as start preparing for that.
– Great, thank you. As well as do you have a sense of, I mean, do you have a feeling of like timing of when we would go
review the referrals for the present site? I indicate, I know one step at a.
time and one task at once, we'' ve got a plate complete,.
Simply a basic feeling. – I assume probably it would certainly be sometime, my guess would certainly be at some point,.
my assumption will be squeamish. I assume we want to go sufficient.
down the course for that, have that plan and also that we'' re qualified for the current suggested site. And after that as soon as we understand that'' s. on that particular course (indistinct) Yet our current price quotes,.
– Yeah, obtained it, thank you, that ' s helpful.
– Thank you, next, I. have council member Myers and'then council participant Brown.
Participant Myers you ' re silenced. -'Actual quick inquiry, you. might have answered this but I '
m not sure, what is the predicted. construction time in'total amount, the entire point?( laughs )- It ' s in between 18 and 24 months.-'Okay.
– As well as right now we ' re looking,. pursuing tax obligation credit ratings possibly January of( indistinct). So ideally it would be next.
summer season before we begin. All right, that makes feeling. And we'' re still imagining that the city would certainly still hold on to affordable. We would certainly still be the manager.
of the affordable housing– In regards to all the– I mean, we may collaborate with a personal entity, however we would certainly still be taping.
all those restrictions (audio decreases) Those conditions will certainly be. – Definitely have the agreement on site. and our vision similar to.
several of our various other jobs with our economical.
housing companions financial investment is that we have that.
They ' d job would be. And certainly we own the. Most likely we'' re still.
a ground lease the designer and they would have their civil liberties. You need to sort of make it through that. That'' s something that in come onward when we'' re a little further. along in the( indistinct).- Thanks for your concerns.- Thank you, council participant Myers. – Mayor Brunner and thank.
you, Bonnie for the update. And as always assembling a really clear presentation and also offering us a lot of information. I have a couple of.
questions that are related to the large image of the.
website, the building envelope. As well as I'' m just questioning. where you ' re at discussions regarding establishing what the strategy.
That'' s one inquiry. -Thank you, council member Brown.
has dealing with this job. He definitely has been.
entering as well as going deep into the task. You will begin seeing.
his face in the future. And he'' s actually doing really. rising as well as very involved. I did wan na acknowledge him as well As much as the library dimension, you.
Yeah, we'' re holding the 35,000 for the indoor programmable space. We actually right now
.
be bigger than that. We'' re actually considering putting some of the cooling and heating mechanical.
We ' re functioning via that right currently, but, we have committed inside and committed as a project team that we put on ' t wan na go listed below the three, 5,000 if at all feasible. I put on ' t know if those will be shut out end of this fiscal year, yet ideally, we ' ll have much better extra. Most definitely that ' s quite why we ' re so thrilled for.
It was rather exciting. We simply didn ' t recognize. ahead of time exactly how that was going to appear and tell are the collection design based style truly act and check out as well as that ' s. where the survey came in.
It was truly important as. much as the budget plan features certainly, as we obtain component,.
Discover some of the facade includes we have.
now are and also outstanding, however I will state all that glass work pretty expensive, so today we'' re holding rather solid on the.
budget plan, however that procedure can be found in will certainly be actually essential for us.There are
some things there that we can do some value.
engineer, our budget plan now, we'' re confident that we can.
It comes with', I think that ' s actually great,( indistinct) going onward and in enhancement to that, we.
sharing, building and construction monitoring that really actually comes with as well as saves us rather a little bit of and also total the budget plan with the library would certainly simply alone or doing a so, I think we'' re obtaining a much bigger, far more state of the.
art materials collection than we ever before would'' ve. been with the existing site '' source of all this.So rather thrilled regarding that, but of program we need to.
get this following stage phase so that we can and really.
have our consultants go deep on the expense materials as well as then we'' ll have the ability to return to council and also actually show to you, fine, here ' s the standard,.
right here'' s the price of these, right here'' s some alternatives which ' s the degree of information that we'' re really wanting to and afterwards not. It'' s wonderful, it was truly. valuable when we were able to do that during the subcommittee process yet, have just how to activate the features as well as transform them off and obtain a feeling of what we'' re,. what we ' re looking at. Thank you value.- Thanks council, looks like that discussion.
Thanks, Bonnie lip. value the update. Expect the next one, April 26th. Okay, we ' ll now move on to. our following presentation product, this is a Mayoral announcement stating March 22nd is Jane
Day. existing, welcome Jane, I will go on and also review the announcement and then where.Whereas Jane me
a 50 year Santa head of state has offered with the San Lorenzo river tidewater Reve job, SLV native habitat remediation program valley women'' s club and served on the city of Santa Cruz park and leisure considering that.
thousand eight, consisting of functioning as vice turn 2020 and Karen 2021. And whereas Jane meal has actually involved hundreds of volunteers in ecological remediation work along the San Lorenzo river via the San Lorenzo river tidewater task and also whereas for the previous five years, Jane meal has actually led long-term initiative along the ES reef of San Lorenza river, her efforts produced the removal of.
large locations of intrusive and the planting and care.
of thousands of plant.Jane has placed
in numerous days of difficult labor herself as well as extra importantly has leveraged the source.
of various other organizations and also in the procedure attached thousands of people with the river,.
the river rock river walk and also whereas Jane has actually engaged with and also generated team work alongside her on the San Lorenzo river, including the neighborhood valley females'' s club, AmeriCorps, California preservation.
Corps, institution group, girl Precursors and the museof NA.And whereas homelessness.
have actually been a significant crisis and also their effect have been acute along the San Lorenzo river, among Jane'' s most see notable cooperation has actually been with the midtown nonprofit organization that collaborates with people,.
experience homeless with our life with them. Jane has actually run a program.
presenting road members, San Lorenzo River'' s indigenous. plant and also wildlife habitat as well as has actually provided training as well as skills on their upkeep treatment and also whereas the bench component of the San Lorenzo river flooding plane as well as previous homeless encampment in the location have actually harmed hole habitat at the river'' s edge as well as launched waste as well as debris into the river itself, this has been an issue of terrific concern and also with the aid of team produced a program to engage camp locals during that.
location, whereas in 2021 environmental team also referred to as best, there for certain harmed.
locations of the San Lorenzo Beland riverbank adjacent.
to the encampments in lower San Lorenzo park, this program has members of the.
residence and unhoused jobs side by our beautiful Ripan habitat of San Lorenzo river and also.
has better environment and the lives and whereas Maine Neo has actually been chosen and also freshly.
acknowledged as champ of this neighborhood by California parks as well as leisures awards program and whereas Jane places our heart and also soul right into unsettled work, the area and also the environment.And currently consequently
Ionia heater Mayor the city of Santa declare, March 22nd, 22 as Jane Day in the city.
of Santa in acknowledgment of the past 5 years, plenty of hours has actually volunteered her time while also engage with many companies and volunteers to improve the community and the habitat along the reduced San Lorenzo river for her continuous devotion, our environment park for her job as parks as well as.
chair, commissioner and recreation and also her special service creating conventional environmentals is actually a champ of welcome, – Oh, Mayor. (laughs) Sorry, I do want to claim that is with actual deep pleasure and humbleness that I get the proclamation.
of the Jane Mu day. I so grateful approve the honor and also the nationwide women'' s background by saling all past present, future.
ladies who follow their interest of involving.
their diverse community develop inclusive atmosphere,.
I'' m additionally unbelievably happy with all individuals that, oh God, I wish I wear'' t. have a cry that might maintain me day pass because this info is a testament of their.
courage.i, assistance and work celebrate every solitary person with all my heart, for their. payment for making
this state possible.( laughs) As well as thank you for every one of. you, every individual who made the feisty satisfied, thank like council member Myers and also council member coming have actually Excited that we have actually a day named after you this year.( laughs) You and I known each. other for 25 years on that river and also we ' ve grown plants and chilly weeds as well as done all sort of crazy points and attempt to show as lots of people concerning that river as well as how special it. is as high as possible. As well as so you, you just.
carry this lantern every day, when you stroll on that particular river and bachelor that you teach about the birds and that you discuss the history river as well as you explain all the special lawns that most of us, we both understand where they are which they ' re they ' re locals as well as they'' ve endured 20'years of basically simply misuse, so I simply, I can'' t say thanks to the Mayor more for acknowledging you and you are tough.
as well as you are a problem maker and also you do have among the most significant hearts I'' ve ever before known.So congrats to you my dear, thanks. We have actually been added exactly how we done. Thanks, council participant.
Myers, council member. As well as I simply wish to thank you.
for numerous years of job as well as love that you place into our river and the I residing in the coastline apartments most likely put on'' t recognize this, yet I would certainly drive by you kinda functioning on the river levy planting indigenous plants would certainly.
wan na quit as well as state hi, however there'' s not, there ' s actually nowhere. You can quit along the road, but just intended to recognize, I see you out there and I'' ve listened to a lot of advantages from individuals in the neighborhood who have actually gone down to collaborate with you as well as with the homeless individuals who are in the bench finishes to assist clean up the location down there on the weekend breaks and instruct the people down there about the indigenous plants.And I think it ' s through those type of efforts, we can actually help, show individuals that they can contribute something to our area and they can make a distinction and also aid up with people that remain in actually dark places. So thanks very a lot for. whatever you ' ve done. You ' ve done and remain to do, thanks. Thank you, I appreciate that a great deal. Council participant Brown, you.
Jane, what can I, what to claim? I'' m simply so thrilled.
what'' s happening today that we are identifying your.
really exceptional contributions to our, your dedications to social and also environmental justice are just steady, and you the large heart, large vision, as well as you have a vision and also.
you function towards that vision everyday and you bring other.
people in our neighborhood, our environment.So that vision of
a. maintain sustainable well for river and setting around. I simply, I enjoy you Burn out and also I ' m so glad to see you here'as well as for all you do. Thank you, thank you,.
I can figure, I presume I'' m unmuted. Thank you, I'' m still figuring out Zoom.
to celebrate Jane'' s sways the last decade. Mainly Jane and also I known.
each other for about two decades. Not only has she constantly been an environ, started out calling not,.
yet over the last years, he as well as I have a significant relationship as well as contributed not only.
ecological advantages, however also social benefit. I'' ve volunteer additionally the.
home make those of value for their task, make.
them really feel like people to actually integrate them in whatever. Doing as well as educate them regarding relevance of natural surroundings on the river. And after that Jane as well as our like finest buddies (laughs) so congratulations, Jane, such a wonderful day for you and also.
all your dedication.So thanks a lot for. allowing Leslie Arbor, the parks, correct? Yeah, yeah, she ' s I'' m. the city ' s city forest, for a few of you more recent council.
members I'' m functioning parks under Travis a lot. Oh, you'' re so welcome. Yeah, she'' s my lead. The project got me began.
is my wind under my wing. (laughs) Fantastic. Well, Jane has been an.
honor also are familiar with you and function along with you. Christmas day, you were.
(indistinct) Thank you, thank you, I so value it. The words place'' t been and been (laughs).
participant, phone call Terry Johnson to introduce the announcement problem recognizing the brand-new year as well as to.
show us scheduled occasions party of today. – Great, thanks, Mayor. I wan na thank you, Mayor Brunner for bringing this.
announcement right into our city. I believe it'' s the first ever. Persian brand-new year announcement. Thank you for your job. Persian brand-new year happened on Sunday and it'' s in Fari, it ' s. noun, which indicates new day. It notes the beginning of spring and also it'' s commemorated
by. over 300 million individuals around the world.It ' s
really about springtime.
revival, regeneration, rejuvenation, party of the altering.
of the period and coming out of the darkness of.
wintertime and also right into the light as well as the appeal of spring. It'' s been commemorated for over.
3,000 years throughout the world as well as I'' m actually excited, our.
community right here in Santa Cruz is now commemorating and also recognizing.
the Persian brand-new year. We are partnering with.
the Museof Art and Background and also the society of Iranian.
literary works as well as arts. And we'' re organizing an event this Sunday, March 27th, from 12 to 3 o'' clock at the museof art as well as background. We'' ll have a fifty percent sea of.
the 7 SS showed and there'' ll be a presentation regarding the Hine and we have a special, unique, honored guest that will certainly be there. Her name is Simon B Devon,.
she'' s turning 96 as well as she is gifting the ma an as well as silk woven rendition of the Cooper home same day. There'' s gon na be lots to celebrate as well as I wish that all of you out there will be able to join us, pleased Persian new year to all those out there.No following( indistinct) -Thank you for sharing that. Okay, currently we ' ll carry on in the schedule as well as I have a few prior to we. move right into our normal meeting. Today ' s meeting is being'relayed survive on tv network. 25 and likewise streaming on the city ' s site,. cityofSantacruz.com.
, if you want to comment.. on a program thing today, contact at the start. of the product you are
wishing to comment on using the. instructions on your display
. Please mute your tv. or streaming tool.
Once you call in as well as. If you proceed to.
And it ' s your time for public comment. Raise your hand either.
Currently public comment is listened to just on items. Advice is activity on as well as. not routine upgrade items that will be open for. public remark, throughout today ' s meeting are. numbers 32 on our program.
And our program is the city I ' d like to ask council members. I ' d like to ask, like telephone call on attorney, supply a report on closed session.
liability claims responsibility claims of Neil Bernardi Wright and the insurance claims of Armand Joseph ti, those are likewise detailed this mid-day on your approval schedule as item number 18, council likewise had a seminar with. its labor settlement, labor mediators.
concerning all negotiating groups as noted on. your article agenda, there was no reportable activity,
. thank you, council will currently examine the conference, calendar the schedule as well as revise it as necessary a call get in touch with the city clerk. provide any updates. There are no None this currently the
time for council participants that report out on at outside board committees and joint powers authority conferences that we have attended for future conferences, please come ready, supply an update on. any kind of conferences or actions that took place given that the. last council meeting so that the council and. public. (indistinct) I will certainly start my left council participant Brown.- Mayor, I have a really brief record
today, first I wished to not report. out on the (indistinct) county regional considerable products at our last conference, our plan. workshop, we place ' t satisfied normal meetings. aren ' t my last report.
We ' re working via that right currently, however, we have committed internally and also devoted as a task group that we wear ' t wan na go listed below the 3, 5,000 if at all possible. I wear ' t know if those will be closed out end of this monetary year, but ideally, we ' ll have better extra. You can stop along the road, yet simply wanted to recognize, I see you out there as well as I'' ve heard so lots of excellent points from people in the community that have gone down to work with you and with the homeless individuals who are in the bench finishes to aid cleanse up the area down there on the weekends and teach the individuals down there about the indigenous plants.And I assume it ' s through those kinds of efforts, we can in fact assist, reveal peoples that they can add something to our neighborhood as well as they can make a distinction as well as aid up with individuals who are in truly dark locations. Yeah, yeah, she ' s I'' m. the city ' s city forest, for some of you more recent council.
Persian new year took place on Sunday and it'' s in Fari, it ' s. noun, which suggests brand-new day.yet I did wan na highlight for people who are paying attention as well as
all of us receiv a press launch regarding this and also I'' m sure there will be an increasing number of statements happening this, but the city of Santa together with the local transf objective, will certainly be organizing a virtual
open house, go over segment to eight as well as nine of the seaside rail trail and also these
PM and also public discussion is truly essential welcomed, give us your thoughts on the design of rail route segments, so I. simply desired to highlight those, you can find that I, it might be on the city ' s website,. It ' s announced
at our website internet site I also likewise desired mention discuss at our last maybe areaLocation air resourceSource district area meeting, we got obtained update upgrade concerning. That was interesting news.
as well as I think I will certainly there. -Thank you for those updates.Okay, Council member, Mayor. – Let ' s see, a pair things to note, we we did have a Metro board meeting last month, as well as there will certainly be some additional products moving on worrying several of the capital expense that are configured over the following years, several of those being adding extra electric buses fleet, as well as checking out real hydrogen fuel cell buses as an opportunity as well, there is a requirement for diversity in the, as different, carbon lowered sorts of lorries come online, so the funding capital board, which I rest on did approve an one decade resources, budget financial investment i’m sorry, capital budget plan just in last week which will certainly be concerning the board on Friday this month, the Metro board meeting is Friday at 9:00 AM, so that we items continuing on that as well as I believe additionally there ' ll be some announcement'often doing concerning the look for the new CEO for City also, the various other item that I the various other conference that I attend this month was the standard Cruz area groundwater firm which body has actually submitted the groundwater sustainability plan for the locations drafted seawater, those, those.
plans have that plan was sent January and also city adopted budget this previous Wednesday evening and likewise is accepting a 7.6 million give from the state of The golden state and bringing jobs online for that, throughout the meeting this month, also the there was a statement.
that there is a drought dry spell advisory that the area, required to produce as well as I'' ve seen announcements in the paper but they are seeking individuals to sign up with that, that route advisory board that does need to be, can be by state law state legislation that was come on January, so any participants of the general public who may have an interest in, joining that need to search the firm web site minimal, restricted websites restricted on that particular, on that committee.The just various other point
I have is the telephone call functioning group has not fulfilled, just recently, yet pertaining to phone calls past year as well as likewise that will certainly be lots of their operate at the 10th wedding anniversary of the San cruise world surfing get, which is gon na be held out at long Marine lab, there'' ll be a community celebration, I five to 8:00 PM on Friday, April 9th as well as the, during the day period prior to the celebration, there ' ll be a, can be of numerous Marine as well as coastal supporters, surfs and also hosted by to save the waves and they'' ll be doing extra service producing a brand-new one decade kind of source monitoring plan for the globe searching,.
so again, the public event is a 5 day as well as the CEL, the celebration wedding anniversary.
Santa Cruz was named the 4th globe surfing exist'' s 11 currently worldwide therefore that'' s a fantastic event as well as the.
cowork group info during that, during that daytime nighttime Personally missed out on the downtown administration corporation conference, that'' s my record, thanks, Mayor. -Thanks, council Myers, council participant Brown,.
did you have a question? – I really had one even more statement, extremely prompt news,.
sorry, I forgot I did this last that'' s That ' s. Okay, allow ' s switch back and have that announcement. Okay, I'' ll be real. fast, so this week those of you, a few of you.
have, I understand, have actually done this in the past, but meals on wheels has reopened it, your dining website and we'' re commemorating this week and they are inviting chosen authorities, join no assistance for these programs and also join them for a shipment route or an eating site and also if there'' s a routine, I, that most of us get an e-mail about this, but if any person has an interest in today, so we have a few days left, you'' re able to go by website at the Nelson.
or take place a flight along they'' re welcoming our participant.I can speak to info.-
Thank you, council member Brown, okay, Council member Cumming.- Thank you, Mayor, mine is Flaco be authorized a R for. special fire research study also, sorry, we accepted an RFP for unique fire research, that ' s gon na be connected to potentially reorganizing fire protection countywide, at am bag, we had an information. product that was draft 45 transport strategy se.
That ' s my report,'I'' ll. I ' ll just quickly include that we had a rather pricey state and federal legislative update and also went over the governor'' s spending plan including a substantial amount of cash that, that rail transportation as well as rail infrastructure,.
absolutely no exhaust lorries and energetic projects as well as environment strength as well as (indistinct) projects have all those dollar amounts, yet take a long time. And then we chatted a little around, bipartisan framework, infrastructure.Bill and the, the, just how much dollars that would convert to and also how much we would certainly take. in our neighborhood communities.
As well as we additionally reviewed. the construct back much better costs primarily that there wasn ' t a, a load in there around which the items that were there, like budget friendly housing that Congressman Crave would be the, like include in the City upgrade. We satisfied with Santa Cruz.
city institutions committee the other day I assume yeah,.
the other day and also review the children'' s fund that this we ' re,( indistinct )a little over 200,000 as well as that doesn'' t consider the extra increase 12, 20%, so we'' ll, we ' ll expect to see funding there and also I'' ll let or vice what can state much more regarding that and afterwards we also got an update from city colleges where they'' re at, where with their. jobs, we went over the fencing of grade schools because of health and safety and security worries and our partnership with parks and rec department at to check out whether it'' s have some. Those were the main.
factors we talked about in … Allow me see right here, we did.
not, we have actually not met the community.
programs policy recently, I am now an agent.
for area activity board and had my initial conference.
with the organization, there were some highlights.
offered on the programs that carry out that they'' re implementing.And I think the
action. that are most pertinent to our discussions are their work around rental help and also simply in general, the effects that, that seeing on both occupants and also proprietors as well as the lack of the state'' s response,.
provid rental assistance. And afterwards we additionally discussed their youth homelessness program, young people.
homeless presentation program, along with their change age young people real estate voucher program, that'' s producing some actually fantastic end results, ultimately the young people action network, which I work as the.
city represe fulfilled recently with all the administrative.
agents throughout the area, it was a young people led meeting, which is always wonderful and had the chance to sort.
of share their vision for this partnership.
with, with jurisdictional agents, we we'' re working, directly with the young people network steering board to develop a.
young people intermediary that'' ll work straight with the.
city on city issues.And I would like to simply offer us, conserve the date for the city of Santa Cruz youth activity network appear.
that'' ll in collaboration with, with the teen center gon na take place April 27th at the London.
Nelson and. So whole lots occur, thanks. – Thank you, council.
participant, Terry Johnson, vice Mayor Watkin. – Yeah, many thanks Mayor Gosh. I think coming in the direction of.
completion, everyone'' s virtually covered a great deal of the common conferences we'' ve attended, however the only point I would really add is that indeed, in regards to simply improving what council for telephone call Johnson raised with our step, a successfully passed at this moment, there'' s a lot possibility.
for a much more integrated strategy to how to make recommendations to the full council, to really support, certain populations very early avoidance and at risk young people and also very exciting chance to help individuals in our community, so I'' m. actually expecting the following version of what that appears like, council (indistinct) Johnson brought up that the health policies committee has a meeting turning up quickly, so we'' ll have something to report on there after that meeting and afterwards in respect to both by 2 Mayor, I'' ll allow you speak to that, I was incapable to attend that meeting at this last time we had and also I believe Bonnie raised, the farmer'' s market,. there is a real interest in desiring to have a permanent place and not be moved often times as well as simply remaining to sustain the farmer'' s market at all you can and also finally, I would say that we did have.
our positioning meeting for the brand-new of treatment which is the,, the brand-new version of the, of the half.It was the fifty percent and now it ' s the real estate for health and wellness partnership as well as really a whole lot of possibility to relocate ahead a great deal of means to consider. exactly how we ' re Le leveraging our various sources, including the human service division,. numerous jobs underway outreach, along with union buildings. So even more to come there as really into what that new process will appear like and also council upcomings brought up that we have a public security board conference that was so we wear ' t have any support at this conference on'that thats my addition.- Allow ' s see, I will include verifying
that our see Santa our next meeting is following week, to ensure that is upcoming along with our health and wellness and also all. plan board conference that meets every other month, so that
will be on Monday as well as for the last year council member, Keary Johnson as well as myself and council participant Myers, we ' ve met the AAP API neighborhood team, a number of members and also they are intending, they are planning an occasion in might and likewise intending as well as. we were able to support them with a Memorial this previous weekend at Harvey west park, so let ' s see, we also had impromptu revenue meeting and in'that conference, we acted on income action at our last council meeting.We had recomme made the suggestion for a sales tax rise as well as
we acted on a few of activity things around that, what next steps are June and after that the by 2 conference this month there was discussion regarding the county staff that they previewed the record that they have mosting likely to their board today, the board of supervisors,, the last 6 months. and the next performance steps, shelter as well as. mobilization as well as rehousing wave upgrade and there was conversation on the void between. cost and housing and also connection to being homeless plus
funding update action strategy and I, I believe there their word memo, alright. And also there ' s additionally there was conversation on the city ' s three year action plan as well as several of the architectural. financial investments and those that along with decision. on the evict postponement that is coming up at the end of March as well as several of the locals that region that have not have actually looked for real estate, the state financing assistance and have actually not gotten financing. assistance yet, so we mentioned leveraging research on that, so I ' d say that was that those updates
, I ' d also similar to reveal that there are two,, public hearings coming. up relating to area election, March, April 19 and so I just wanted to truly make certain that our public understood March. 29th, at 4:30 PM via Zoom and or you can call in.And that information gets on the website. That ' s it for those now we will transfer to the approval program product.
These are items eight 20 on our schedule for members of the public who are streaming this. meeting, if you wish to comment on products eight via 24 now is the moment to call in, there ought to be instructions on your.
display, please remember to mute your streaming device as well as increase your hand by dialing celebrity and also on your or choosing raise hand in the webinars on your all products will be acted on in one movement, unless an item. is drawn by a council member, further review council members who council participant Cumming, thank you, Mayor, I require, I was.
gon na pull thing number 12 as well as I 15, 16 as well as 19, oh, down, sorry, draw 12, okay, Remark on 15, alright. 16 and also 19, thank you,.
council member Brown,( indistinct) Watkin, I just. wanted to make a brief talk about thing 6, alright? We have thing number. 12, layer and talk about 1515 and also so I will certainly go on then and start with and start with thing 15 as well as I will start with council
member Cumming.Thank you, Mayor, I just wanted to give thanks to participants of the public and also working with unionizing at Starbucks specifically union member name, Joe Thompson, that ' s leading effort young 18 year old activist. That ' s making considerable progress with, taking part the unionization initiative of the Starbucks employees and also so I wanted to give him a proclaim to all the employees that are available that are working with unionizing as well as just wan na say thanks to Mayor you and council member Brown for assistance taking. this forward and also council participant Brown for your. management and taking the lead on this, thanks. Council member Brown product number 15, Mayor and council participant,. cumings for your talk about this item for that were around listening, I simply wished to claim a pair of things, so this I, this thing is on our schedule today, It ' s. a resolution of support for employees at Starbucks. are part of an expanding wave of union as well as initiatives. at Starbucks across the nation and so the union is Starbucks United associated with SCIU conditioning to represent employees at.
over a hundred locations across the us, so this.
– Thank you, allow ' s see, we. Great, thank you so a lot, I just wanted to acknowledge as well as
thank.
single usage smoking item and also terminating use non.
rechargeable vaping devices as well as cigarette as well as stogie filters.
The movement for cigarette. and also tobacco wastes is sluggish and also it ' s constantly commonly.
extremely responsive California relocate this instructions,
I assume it actually relocate the needle substantially within the country and afterwards past, so it starts below and this gratitude as well as support ideally will assist obtain this over the movie, thanks for. creating that Council member Cumming that additionally comment on thing number 16, yeah, in a similar way, I just wan na thanks Mayor as well as council participant stroll for your support on this and I really want thank two area participants, Taylor
lane as well as Judkins, they ' ve been doing a lot of activist work with trying to prohibit the bud outlawing cigarette, however and filtered cigarette products.Because what we ' ve seen is that usually when people are at the coastline, if they ' re cigarette smoking these cigarette butts, which are made of plastic'up ground as well as in the sea and are a big contamination source to our atmosphere as well as likewise costs a great deal of cash when
it comes to attempting to tidy up cigarette butts, whether they ' re in the sea or whether'they ' re pathways in the area and. so they ' ve been placing onward a huge effort to. attempt to obtain territories throughout the country to prohibit solitary use filteringed system cigarette products and I anticipate continuing dealing with them as we move on to see how'Santa Cruz can be a leader. in this effort as well.Thank you so much council participant, after that we had
a comment on number 19, yeah. I just wan na reveal my admiration to personnel as well as the area. bringing this forward. This thing is developed Juneteenth as a citywide vacation and also back in 2020, when after the murder
of George, I understand that this has actually shown up as a topic of discussion and also although it ' s really tough to kind of make it, so at that point in time, simply attempting to recognize how we can you recognize, proceed to have operations operate in the city and additionally provide people the city has worked, bring this onward. As well as I understand we ' ve obtained work by council members at previous meetings to move in this instructions and also so I know it ' s simply actually amazing to see. that Juneteenth will be a, a city vacation for city workers this year and I really hope that various other services sign up with in as well as various other participate in as well as. making this a'holiday for their work paid holiday, thank you, council participant, fine, Right now, proceed to public comment as well as if there are any participants of the general public that wish to speak with any type of thing on our consent program with the exception of. thing number 12, which has actually been informed currently is the time please raise your hand by calling R. nine, we ' re picking increase hands from the webinar of your, the timer will certainly then be established, alright, so heading out to attendees by phone number finishing and also absolutely no nine one, go on and press our and also mute on your own, yes, simon, hi, welcome.- Thank you, I simply wan
na comment briefly on thing 20, which associates with evergreen cemetery, I know evergreen burial ground was started in the 1850s. and also was very actively used as the very first public burial ground in Santa Cruz for decades afterwards, however then came under neglect as well as abandonment and also is currently possessed by the. museof art and also history. while this is simply a little encroachment license I ' m excited to say this really stands for the next stage in our years long currently effort by volunteers throughout the neighborhood to boost. evergreen cemetery and also not only make it. a, a gorgeous and secure location for individuals to visit, however a lot more so make it a place people find out about Santa Cruz background and also a complete diversity of Santa Cruz background. from our Chinese immigrant area, civil war. professionals, London Nelson household began the first. companies in Santa Cruz et cetera and actually what this is, is the state,.
we got a state grant from the California galleries grant program.Doesn ' t generally offer grants to cemeteries, yet ' root cause of its use by thousands pupils who appear to find out local history are used on DDO, it ' s actually seen as the cultural and also so we got this give to boost availability, which will simply make it better for everyone,
, visiting evergreen. burial ground, not just for the older visitors who have difficulty browsing our old dirt course, however everyone out there and so I '
m truly excited this, the facilities project that ' s gon na boost the, a cemetery for years ahead as well as yet I likewise wan na say, I truly wan na give thanks to parks department since the only means to make this occur was to accept Harvey west park as well as to put some obtainable.
As well as so we ' re just thrilled to be at this point and also truly ready to I ' m program.
It ' s introduced
at our website and I also wanted desired mention point out at our last maybe perhapsLocation air resource, district area meeting, we got an update about fundingFinancing I ' ll just quickly add that we had a quite pricey state as well as government legislative update as well as reviewed the guv'' s budget including a considerable amount of cash that, that rail transit and also rail facilities,.
And there ' s also there was discussion on the city ' s 3 year activity strategy as well as some of the structural. And I recognize we ' ve gotten job by council members at previous conferences to relocate in this direction and also so I understand it ' s just really interesting to see. And so we ' re simply thrilled to be at this point as well as actually ready to I ' m schedule.Our next participant is Joseph Thompson and afterwards mute on your own,
there you go, thanks a lot, first of all, I'' d similar to to to begin with once again, by giving thanks to helpful Brown and also Justin Cumings for presenting this fantastic resolution in support of the Starbucks employees arranging not only at the sea water road, but likewise saw mission in previously, we have undergone a lot of tactic
since we released our project going back January 21st, this year, 2022 as well as because after that we'' ve United with each other as well as actually proceeding our job struggle, ever since we'' ve had regarding eight more throughout every one of The golden state that I'' ve been aiding arrange those shops, the current storage space documents actually this last
Friday in mill valley where the lead organizer at that shop is just 17 years old and simply showing that this activity is being led by youngsters that which'' s, that ' s the biggest thing
that resolution is combating for Newing to combat for is having youngsters and voices in power that can speak reality to power, so once more, thank you for all the council participants who determine to go solution.It shows that
you back up employees that are, who are organizing versus a multi billion buck firm who has actually picked to area profit for companion and companions that these places of workers are the ones who need one of the most sustain right now, '' reason we ' re in a battle not just secure organizing civil liberties for us, but to continue the worker movement and also really branch out labor, we'' ve been getting to out to various other local cafe, other nationwide changes too, currently as well as truly beginning to to unionize doors and also we'' re not gon na back down. We ' re not gon na stop getting and it'' s, it ' s so excellent to have the assistance of, of union members and union leaders who desire modification worldwide, so thanks all once again and I wish you do pass this resolution to reveal that Dan Cruz stands, are you strong and go obtain a union solid cup of thanks. Thanks, Joseph Thompson, our next guest employing on permission program things, item 12, I am enjoying you.Yeah, aye
. As to item number 14, the financed left us proposal of brainwashing, after that marriage in between extreme social justice groups with climate lobbyists, no, no and also empty, however, this is not simply a safe gold, be like extravaganza example of (indistinct) A to Z leftist poor word item like environment justice, however it is likewise quite a startling self-seeking public monetary demand meant to morph right into a mass prospective misappropriation of public monies, setting up an unelected politician drawing city wage to head a regional coalition, leftist political social justice Partnership kinds past the reach of the people focused on the complete spectrum of leftist, ideological conditioning, power, extreme social justice warrior program with the hope of attract pressure grants and also power to a somewhat unidentified, yet plainly left this function instead of the singular objective of boosted local sustainability, this suggested range of so-called compensated justice teams and neighborhood climate experts calls partially outside the petition'' s job, after that diagram, I fell short to see exactly how racism, justice, incorporation, variety and equity training creates one Booger'' s worth of sustainability effect
, however I never ever obtained infected by the college post modernist, Neo Marist conditioning, plainly some did, It'' s critically essential to stop the shunt of public tax cash that fund left wing radicals, I request this improper slide of hand overarching complete radical left this program ask for funds by an enormously overpaid SJW city bureaucrat.He declined now as well as set back for a much more limited extent revise with a sole concentrate on sustainability. I take sustainability concerns seriously, but I wear ' t pirate it to imply anything aside from a concentrate on the depletion or damages of Earth'' s natural deposits, which sure simply can not continue that the environment modification bucks spent will primarily also be squandered to understand certain disable climate impact is an additional aspect that also makes less desirable. I oppose the controversial items like item 15 and 19, yet unless bullet, I put on'' t have time to. Thank you are there any other that would such as on items with the exception of product 12 now is the moment to elevate your hand by pressing star 9 on phone or choose increase hand in the, I will after that bring it back as well as ask for a ballot on the continuing to be items of the consent program for carrying on the hold thing number as well as I see council member Myers, employee Brownish muted council participant Myers, sorry, I'' ll make a movement on the continuing to be Activity by council member Myers, 2nd recognize council participant Brown.I ' d like to ask the staff, take a function call ballot. – [Staff] Mayor council member commentary Johnson, Cumming. – Aye. – [Staff] Brown. – Aye. – Aye. I'' m gon na I
' m gon na. vote aye, however I wan na– Sorry, I number, I
simply wear ' t. seem like there ' s sufficient.
Is that a no ballot?'I think it ' s a no ballot,. you can
, I can ' t upstate. Okay, by Mayor Watkin. – Aye. – [Clerk] Mayor Brunner.
Allow ' s see, activity. We will now come back to item number 12 and also council member. Cumming, you drew this product, yeah, there was simply one, thank you Mayor, there was simply one small adjustment that I thought or one small information that was left out of the friendly, the pleasant change and the mins regarding thing number.
alternative emergency situation situation feedback program at, or federal on safe financing opportunities which accepted. As well as yet someone had connected to me due to the fact that we had actually stated having words focus on assistance intended to be in there at hour eight min 29 in the video from the last conference I brought up, whether we can include focus on Mayor stated yes, in a friendly change which was approved by them and also as an outcome, yet then.
looking at the mins of the, sorry, then taking a look at the minutes of the the min the last council meeting, the prioritized.
component was left out.So the only thing I was bringing up was simply having, so it was mirrored in the minute that it claimed prioritizing, say that proper was made and also I clerk Shrub up, yeah, yeah, thank you, council participant, you directed it out, I I'' m guessing you, perhaps sanctuary'' t obtained the email that I sent the other day to let you individuals recognize that was made, we did validate in the video and also prioritize, show, thank you significantly, alright, thank you, speaker, that means we will certainly involve a vote on item 12 from the March 8th meeting and also I have a telephone call Don, don'' t think we have a, I put on ' t believe we have a motion Needs to out to public remark And also we require to tipping ahead of myself, so for item 12, we'' ll bring it bent on public remark as well as if you would such as to comment.
Council member Myers seconded, – Aye. Johnson, member Johnson. – Aye.
one lacking, thank you. That concludes our program products. Relocating on into the program, we.
will certainly currently begin public hearing and also next action is agenda, number 25, 25 is a public hearing for 2020 2023. US department of real estate.
a city advancement referred to as head action plan.
for participants of the public were streaming this conference,.
if this is a product you desire to discuss now is the moment to contact making use of the instructions on your display, the order for this thing will be a present of the item by staff complied with by concerns from council, we will.
Take public comment and after that return to the.
council for liberation and action, I would certainly like to currently existing, I think it'' s lake. our handle, thank you. Proceed and my screen, this is the CDBG and house action plan as well as.
budget plan public hearing. I'' m Tiffany lake housing and management analyst and also economic growth also below today as our housing.
as well as advancement manager today to get moneying recommendation from this will enable us to keep me moving on and strike our continuing to be dedicate our yearly action, this is the yearly activity timeline, we'' ve already undergone a whole lot of actions in that process, most recently we brought programs board and the first council authorization enable us to stay on this line and strike our staying objectives as well as bring it back, second public hearing where the HUD spending plan is settled, then a dedicate the HUD in may,.
so the referrals we'' re today are all based on estimates.Our CDBG and also house funds rise and fall a lot for many years, however, for. this upcoming program year we ' re estimating will certainly have 605,000 our community growth programs and also we ' re estimating 425,000 CDBG, we'' re additionally estimating program revenue, our payments on finances made with CVG funds of 55,000 and also prior your funds offered. for free shows at 60,000, providing us an overall readily available of seven of that administration. is set by search formula 32,000, we also have rehab rehab administration for finance maintenance gives made with CPG funds at. 5,000, to make sure that provides us 583,000 available for.
programs as well as projects.This year, we obtained 4 applications ask for strategic
funding programs. Now these are all subject. to a 15% tasks cap, yet Nova Panorama is exempt to this cap ' cause it ' s neighborhood. based advancement organization, our C B. O, so the overall requests go to 190 F is suggesting. to money every one of the programs. In 2014 ' s funding levels. from the team facility to historical funding.
degree lowering at 35,000. We recommend to not.
rise financing degrees for any one of the programs until we recognize our actual word amounts from HUD to guarantee that we put on ' t surpass that. 15% public services cap, that ' s a total of 185,000 for programs, have'some updates for. some CDG financed programs for the very first two quarters. of the existing program year.So that ' s from July, 2021 through
December, 2021, so the very first one is for 2nd harvest food bank, they have given over 1.4 million pounds of food to Santa Cruz, actually some even more updates from the acquainted facility, they have actually provided a great deal of useful services to. the area, consisting of 50 hours of advocacy work over 700 clients, in addition to helping to. give 3 40 households to beach flex community. 36 usage we ' re able to participate in.
50 youth had individually.( indistinct )also obtained CDBG request for financing for project, the Depot park remodelling will be for.
project of its inexpensive housing for those living, with human resources HIV or aids in Santa Cruz as well as.
And once more, administration is set by HUD formula, 55,000, we have a picture set aside for community housing. The initial all-natural project. Last year, at the very least 23 of the.
current CPC meeting in February, that that CPC committee understand.
the all-natural bridges project is still eligibility, component. of complying with up on that, we met bud field. representatives who recommended that we required to.
competitively rank application. and since both projects, organizations have considerable growth,.
home management experience created a ranking matrix. utilizing the primary categories of task preparedness funding,. leveraging community.New job ' s capacity to assist.
the city as well as consolidated these were rated by. three exterior reviewers that all ranked task of the natural, so because there ' s not
appropriate financing to fund both jobs, ask teams advising to.
It is a HUD suggested finest practice to fund fewer at greater. We are looking for input to.
[email protected] lower programs, so again,.
based upon the initial budget suggested by council today, we ' ll be able to compose 22. action plan, we ' ll bring that once again for a second. public hearing where the HUD spending plan
will final as well as after that we will submit the annual action strategy on May 15th pending will become available as early as July 1st programs later. in the fall project.Now we have time for any type of questions, thanks, council participants have any type of questions council participant come, I did have a question certain pertaining to the funding being homeless, recognizing that we ' re putting 14 million towards that presently and that oftentimes we fail on having the ability to assist sustain economical real estate project, which is in length of homelessness, I ' m just questioning if you might explain. type of particularly what ' s expected to visit ' reason you know, we have a great deal of funds of putting in the direction of this product as well as wan na make certain that we ' re additionally putting funding in the direction of various other needs like'afford housing associated homeless, thank you for that. The survey itself,. Two inquiries checklist all of 'the available usages of the funds. It is a little bit restricted since it'' s residence funds, so similar,. comparable to the funds that we have every year this funding needs to go for either budget-friendly housing.That ' s especially targeted for homeless. It can go with occupant. based rental assistance is paid straight to property managers and there ' s some special real estate therapy, real estate targeted case monitoring. type solutions that are allowed, yet they all need to have a('indistinct) with. real estate as well as then there ' s a good quantity of constraints on precisely which sorts of solutions are enabled, so we we ' d love input for everybody, however it ' s those four main
use, could you just, could you provide those off once again?, yeah, so it is
board of real estate advancement targeted particularly. for the homeless lessee based rental aid, payments are made directly to'landlords specifically for those that homeless are. in jeopardy of homelessness special real estate counseling. and also being homeless and also to housing with unique qualification. and the various other is instance supervisor, thank you
. Let ' s see, I had an inquiry. for the attorney existing, say thanks to you.My concern, one of the requests in the discussion is an item that originated from
the housing authority and I. am a housing authority commissioner, so I believe I would certainly need to utilize myself from that if Yes, my recommendation would be that the activity the council takes on that different and also that as participant of the real estate board that you Thank
you, so the item residence financing, natural bridges. SRO, please verify that ' s the housing authority
development bridges, An application from the real estate authority as well as partnership not-for-profit. Thanks, we ' ll take. any kind of action separately.Are there any kind of inquiries. from council participants prior to I bring it out to public? Okay, I will certainly now head out to. public talk about this product and also are wanting a member of the public as well as wanting to comment on.'product number on our schedule. Both to 3 us division of housing as well as metropolitan development action. Currently is these increase your. hand press star'9 or raise hand in the webinar.
functions of your computer.
And also when it ' s your time to talk, you ' ll hear an announcement. that you ' ve been unmuted and also your (indistinct )will certainly be set. Okay, participant and also I ' m not. seeing any hands increased. I will bring it back to. counsel for as well as movement. The council member Myers. and also council participant cummings and also they are all cubicle items. Second, okay, so we have a. activity Myers participant Cummings as well as may we have a roll call ballot?- [Clerk]
Thanks', Mayor. Member Johnson.- Aye.- [Clerk]
Brown. -Aye. – [Staff] Mayor.- Aye.
– [Clerk] Mayor Watson. -Aye.- [
– Aye. Hopefully that ' s say thanks to you.Okay, so that passes unanimous with council participant Gold absent. Thank you, Tiffany (indistinct).
If this is a product you would like discuss currently is.
I will certainly bring it over to participants for any type of comment on your phone to use your hand Mayor Brunner, yes, I would certainly simply hi supervisor of planning, neighborhood growth, we usually wear ' t have discussions.- Mid-day, everyone,. I am a senior planner with the innovative preparation.
And also I really appreciate that, so there are a pair
of points that I do assume, are a little confusing and I recognize why they ' re confusing, so ideally I can, those below rather rather easily, so allow, simply share this PowerPoint, okay.So we listened to problems heard these flexible thickness devices are gon na boost thickness. We listened to that no various other. cities in the country do this point, we listened to that this proposition is gon na boost the elevation of structures that built or that this proposition should have complete EIR of it very own, we likewise'heard concerns concerning water as well as not having enough for any kind of new development and after that we also just listened to a great deal of stress and anxiety about the
means that laws due to transform in sexual and also type of simply this anxiousness regarding understanding what ' s coming down the.
At least those 25 years we ' ve had exactly SROs as we.
connects to the street.And after that certainly, open area and also auto parking requirements go along with domestic development and those sort of push of. domestic growth and also those kind of push the amount of structure space that can be available, to make sure that is. very, that is comparable.
I'' m gon na I
' m gon na. It is a little bit limited because it'' s house funds, so comparable,. Let ' s see, I had a concern. SRO, please validate that ' s the real estate authority
development advancement, An application from the housing authority and as well as collaborationNot-for-profit And also when it ' s your time to talk, you ' ll listen to a news.This action towards adaptable density units is sort of a halfway
step, an even more type based code, doing a totally kind based change is a huge endeavor and also something for afterward,, as for changing elevation, this proposal is refraining anything
dental expert most extreme type of real estate that our policy enable when the E R was secured the basic plan.So it is our idea that this quantity of was pondered, this quantity of number of devices was considered,. but we ' re speaking about is that existing. ability and shuffling the means it can used. that envelope to enhance expediency of projects, so you have actually heard us state, we think this. will enhance housing production, we do think that our company believe this will certainly raise housing production, yet this does not transform is the total amount of housing ability that is prepared for in our general plan and also researched in the E associating with water your council had the possibility to. listen to the discussion from our water division, I think in November of last year. about the urban water monitoring strategy and also.
obtained ta see all the numbers, I understand a great deal of individuals didn ' t have the chance to see that discussion and I'actually advise it ' reason it, it does reveal that the city of Santa Cruz remains in a various placement around water, a great deal of various other water. districts in our county.We actually have actually seen dropping need despite enhancing population.
as well as the estimates from our water division price quote that over the next 25 years via 25, they ' re predicting regarding a 4% rise in demand, yet that ' s. broadening an 18% increase in population and also all,. the majority of that advancement I ' d claim greater than 95% of that growth is included within the existing basic strategy, which goes to 2030, to make sure that'' s just an additional item of context, individuals might not understand that, so I simply wan na include that out there and after that in concerns to anxiousness concerning adjustments from Sacramento, I just wan na state, I share that in a,, in an extremely deep method as well as the fact of it is the state lawmaker is not I regarding anything pertaining to real estate, so you, we are gon na see modifications. coming out Sacramento.There is no day in the next 25 or 30 or 40 years, they ' re gon na stand still concerning real estate, so if we wait for them to quit, that means we quit intending
at all. as well as there might be some individuals that would certainly, that'that ' s not what. gon na hear suggested from our department, so let ' s discuss what is altering in this coordinate that remains in front of you,'so we ' re proposing to transform small ownership devices to versatile density systems, this. proposal was suggested by your, the change would enable that these kinds of units can be rented out, 4 offered. Whereas tiny possession. devices are only permitted to offer for sale, this would certainly eliminate the current limit on bedroom, so. currently small possession devices are limited to one room as well as it entire type of settlement. is based on lounge or a workplace, no one gon na sleep there as well as they put on ' t obtain developed to the exact same safety and security requirements needs of
egres that they would certainly have if they prepare for them to be a room, so we ' re recommending to lift that bit while keeping that. overall dimension requirement instead of 6 50 square. feet, we ' re suggesting to lower the minimunit size, current criterion of square feet. to square feets
, the gap between what SRO can can do therefore could do there
was this amusing like gas therefore recommending to lower the minimum side to that two. 20, to make sure that it compares with where SROs are required to have a complete set of (indistinct )functions, we are suggesting to include, not removed, we are adding recommending to add a demand for commercials to be included in 3 zone districts in the. midtown, the central enterprise zone, the. location south of Laurel, the C B D area and also the RTC, which is our residential tourist commercial, which is the coastline location, currently there is no standard that
requires. residential advancement in those locations, which. is an enabled to include a commercial usage, there ' s no requirement in our zoning that as well as we are recommending to add one in the computer area district today, you can do a 100%. household development.We are not suggesting to alter that mixed usage would certainly be'a choice,. when we come via in a few like twoish. months with the objective criteria in the new area areas that are gon na actually create.
areas for the very first time, we are gon na have areas where you can ' t do property only where you need to be integrating a. commercial use, that ' s gon na concern our area district and after that that would relate to any type of job that utilize this type unit, yet that ' s not something that ' s in area and presently in that CCU area area, we only allow blending uses on bigger websites that. more than 8,000 square.There are a lot of. websites in those areas that'are square and also so what we'' re recommending is that we. not call for commercial advancement in those places on those sites as part of this, the last adjustment that ' s suggested with this. from present ordinance to the thickness is this. mix real estate compensation debated the remainder of the regulation, they got on purpose and as you ' ll recall, likewise, this was the'point of opinion amongst your council also about whether these devices should stay in. standalone structures and also tasks as currently. needed for small ownership devices or whether they must be permitted to various other sorts of devices, we are advising that they be allowed to blend create this was among the primary catalyst
we ' re considering, this was to say these
little ownership devices,. aren ' t actually working.They ' re not being built,. they ' re not getting this like advantage of having alternatives for people who would certainly like. to invest their cash buy, you were square feet of housing and permitting them to be mixed in with other device kinds, we think is a method to sustain the advancement and also motivate of the little devices, now, if you ' re somebody who doesn ' t believe that tiny systems is the direction that our city need to be. entering, you probably aren ' t gon na similar to this which ' s simply where we are, that ' s plan dispute that we ' re having concerning. single room occupancy statute, there is no modification happening.There we are, what we are suggesting is to order our existing policy that precedes the basic strategy, we simply which, but so every little thing else is not transforming, I won ' t slide, but primarily nothing about elevation testing about.
obstacle, nothing about marking is supposed to.
change nothing about the inclusion mistake requirements, opposed to change with this proposition, so I wanted to provide one more little instance cause we spoke this in, however I assume it might as well as like the numbers on, so we have the information of this, yet it truly gets quite tiresome. rather rapidly, so I simply wan na kind of give an example if we take a look at kind of a 14,000 to 15,000 square foot website, so concerning a 3rd of an acre, let ' s discuss what we. can build there, right? What could be built there today? If we have that site in an area district that allows up a 30 volume units per acre, which is several of which is.
the standard that puts on great deals of our computer zone, you might obtain about parking. an open area and also tale limit.You could reach about. square feet developing area because structure envelope.
There ' s some space for. circulation and also garbage rooms take out a thousand feet. and after that you figure, you might get at that density. You ' re a 3rd of the acre. You can strike 10 homes and divided by about around nine square feet.
That would certainly be the.
ordinary dimension of the homes that might be improved that. website would be 900 square foot. That would certainly consist of 2
homes scheduled for low revenue household. So the adjustment that would certainly
come in these adaptable density devices, this is just how we ' re visualizing. it is that the versatile. density devices would certainly be included on top of those 10. So your density restriction is 10. That applies to everything that mores than 650 square feet of size. So you can obtain 10 units. that are that bigger size. We ' re handling the same. 10,000 square foot structure with a thousand feet for blood circulation, 9,000 square feet that were. currently surrendering among units.You can obtain
10 residences at 700 square feet, plus five more systems devices residence in the adaptable density device classification at smaller workshop size square feet. So this would certainly be an overall of 15 homes with 3 reduced revenue.
home as well as these projects would look the same on the exterior. You would certainly see even more mail boxes, okay. You would see even more mail boxes if they have, to the level they have.
Rather of those 10. That building form could.
be a little bit larger that structure envelope we ' re. estimating you could fit.
If your home, sRO houses. are around 300 square feet, you might fit 35 of. them on the same parcel.
And of those 7 would be reserved for extremely low revenue housing. That ' s kinda the. These are the department on particular, which is an SRO advancement.
And also currently I understand individuals are stating, however you ' re not showing the density.So allow ' s look at'what you actually do if you'actually desired to whatever out.
Okay, so what ' s shown on. the top here at what ' s cloud
today, so we have our. sous, our little ownership units, maximdensity, the tiniest unit you can do is 400 square foot home, we ' re considering that very same kind of one third of an acre website, exact same kind. of constructed dimension we ' re estimating, you'can fit on that site as well as of those booked for'. reduced income, if you ' re looking at SROs and you, you it out, so the SRO that you ' re allowed'. to make even facilities after that
you could put 70 of all on the exact same website, 14 of those would be reserved for very reduced income. family or'individuals for our FDU proposal, if we consider taking that completely to the maximdensity and taking those devices a smallest healthcare facility, we would enable those.
regional real estate needs appropriation, which is the number of real estate devices assigned to every territory in the state,
by the state as an objective for preparing for new real estate building to meet
future demands, so we ' re in respectable'shape now, so today, santa Cruz is just missing our VNA on one revenue group, so really low income group, we have enough units in the. pipeline to possibly meet that goal by the end of our by the end of the time period, when we have to build them, which is completion of 2023, so fingers go across do our following cycle of RHNA is substantially extra aggressive, this is true of all 6 cycle real estate components throughout the state.Everyone is obtaining a lot. a lot more hostile housing numbers that they need to prepare for as well as what happens if we. wear ' t need those numbers is that we go through S 35, so market price real estate has an appropriation under that. local real estate needs allocation as well as our market rate allocation for the next cycle, which starts at the start of 2024, is that we have to create by 20 by 2031, a minimof 1600, over 1600 brand-new market price residence and they analyze us midway the real estate cycle through that period, so we have to have half of much housing entitled entire structure permits by the end of 2027, that 803 real estate.
devices by the end of 2027 which is greater than we have actually integrated in the last seven years, so we, in order to satisfy this objective, you. require to nearly double our manufacturing, so simply to be clear, this is state loss, if we are able to fulfill this, if we ' re able to satisfy this 4 hr market rate manufacturing,. then S3 five continues that does today and has requested the last 5, 6, 7 years and. we ' ve had one application.So it only uses jobs that supply 50 %or even more budget friendly. housing, if we missed out on that, we dropped a more stringent group where every little thing that we authorize right here in Santa Cruz would be done. is virtually whatever. I guess I shouldn practically every little thing that we do, multifamily real estate would certainly end up being qualified for 35 ' reason. drop here where any kind of task that gives 10% inexpensive real estate qualifies that. and our inclusionary percent is 20%, that would certainly be nearly every little thing,
so there are a couple of exemptions to state law, however so we ' re worried regarding that
, we ' re interested.
in preserving whatever local control the state permits us to have.
And also one of the methods that we do that is by enabling and also finding methods where we can obtain unit developed, so that ' s type of the reason for bringing
this forward and and also for ways methods we can supportSustain We ' re not cost in terms of making it be restricted, then what extra can we.- That ' s an actually great question.So, the only way to.
It ' s not like you have. Bunches of options? That ' s simply the truth of our market, so within that kind of restriction. without a fee constraint, we'' re constantly gon na be. considering the market setting those prices and. so really what we can do to lower price for home is purchase, do they wan na buy square or they only wan na purchase square? Do they wan na spend for car parking or do they not wan na spend for parking? ' Cause they put on ' t have a car and now. vehicle parking will certainly be unfunded.So checking out the inclusionary element of this is definitely, not lost'time, that would be that that ' s a certainly an idea that we'might explore and.
SROs do have a various I need that have to be you really low earnings instead than reduced income, so I think there are points that we'could talk regarding that, yet I put on ' t, I don ' t understand that there ' s a concession that we with, there are concessions we can give that will decrease cost? And with reduced costs comes the. opportunity that reduced lease comply with, however it ' s no warranty the marketplace is always gon na establish that as well as our'market has a whole lot of impacts. on it and also is honestly restraint, there ' s not a fund, so challenging one, you have something you wan na add, currently, you, you covered it, with the inclusionary. comments, the inclusionary applies to this for 20 %at reduced income, which is 80% of the area average income and also as Sarah discussed for SROs, we do have a various limit it ' s, it ' s 50 % of the location median income.Now that does give. that provides an automatic qualifi, or I believe it ' s a 35 %state density reward SROs, sROs gotten approved for 50, thank you and also our various other. typical inclusionary certify.- Great, thanks for that. information, thank you. thanks, council member.
Good am I so I believe, I assume again, we'' re blending thickness reward. Of our zoning? They would end up being component of.
So thanks for that, I, that and I presume that ' s component of my concern, I didn ' t a circumstance with density incentive, like a thickness benefit. job circumstance with Fs, the situations gave us, which
were extremely practical and I assume that is where I ' ve heard most of, since when you speak about a dental bonus task where you have essentially a base, then that limitless thickness a thickness perk piece of it then potentially, I indicate, there ' s absolutely nothing that would certainly stop a programmer make an application for a thickness benefit and after that all of those, of elevation as well as setback regulations that you claim are, remain in the we have the capability to.
They ' re required to. Once again, I ' m trying to figure out just how we shake that, I indicate, it ' s very hard to comprehend.
what that could be.Right, so I think it ' s, it ' s, I presume I ' m simply trying to understand my under, I presume my understanding. is indeed, we could actually have, we might in fact have, removal of obstacles if an F project requests density. Okay, so, yes. Okay, so how about I show you just how we do identity application? ' Reason I believe this is for a. whole lot of folks get used, what we ' re speaking about transforming is the base of zoning, so essentially with an FDU, you might obtain an incentive of density without any waste, we would certainly keep. our Levels location like that, that example that. I revealed you, where you go from 10 systems to 15 devices, when you add ADU, you ' re still. fulfilling a three'story'height restriction,'you ' re still meeting, you know, all of the obstacle, giving all the auto parking that ' s in our base therefore yes, you take that and also you use the thickness bonus offer, It ' s a 35% thickness bonus offer on that.So lem me simply share my display, I have 'a couple instances that can.
kinda show this. ' Reason I just wan na clear that thickness that doesn ' t a thickness limit, wrong, there ' s restrictions, we do SROs, so let ' s consider an SRO job genuine quick and just see how they did that. This one ' s not an SRO project, yet'this is a task, this. is front river front proposition that entered this programs,. a 35% entity perk. Moving from below, this is a proposal that all of our zoning requirements, this is a need for. density benefit application if to submit an adapting. job and after that your density benefit proposal has to match that in terms 'of the unit dimension, so if were consisted of, they would be consisted of. here, so this building would look the same, however it would certainly within'building would look the exact same and it would units inside, this is a thickness bonus offer application, this is one 30 facility street.This was an SRO established, so you can see SROs are done specifically the exact same way as what we ' re speaking about. with Fs as well as they ' re much more thick fit, even more SROs, they have to be no
bigger than 345. square feet on standard.
They ' re gon na be as well as they can be smaller?
' Reason they put on ' t have an automobile and also currently. SROs do have a various I demand that have to be you really reduced income instead than low revenue, so I believe there are things that we'could talk regarding that, but I wear ' t, I don ' t recognize that there ' s a giving in that we with, there are giving ins we can provide that will reduce cost? Again, I ' m trying to figure out how we shake that, I mean, it ' s extremely hard to comprehend.
' Cause I assume this is for a. great deal of folks get made use of, what we ' re talking regarding altering is the base of zoning, so basically with an FDU, you could obtain a perk of density without any kind of waste, we would keep. ' Cause I just wan na clear that thickness that doesn ' t a thickness limit, not right, there ' s constraints, we do SROs, so allow ' s look at an SRO task real quick and also simply see how they did that.They might be 50 feet on
standard, so this needs to fulfill all of the standards
that are in the zoning code and in the location plan as well as we review this to see to it that it feeds all of our requirements, that'' s the base and after that they obtain the density incentive and you go this forming strategy, this reward proposition, so because this is an SRO proposal, they are giving 20% of their units at really reduced earnings, which state density Yeah, I suggest that'' s state law? That offers you five more incentive systems. I suggest you live in a.
neighborhood community a long time and as well as kind of think believe'' s. all gon na look the same over the years and then new laws.
You wear'' t wan na make sources. As well as so you you end up with an unforeseen five, six, seven building.
We really wouldn ' t be under and also might have the ability to obtain out'under that that ' s poor regulation, but that is regarded in the community as something that, you know, truly is developing much denser and also customer and greater housing, so I presume my, my concern or my remark, I guess, both is this puts a device in the tool kit that kind of generally takes the SRO and also the sous as well as sort of. provides this center area. Your, your overall
design style a building structure always going to be guided led those, those basic standard flooring location, all those things that we know understand are on the books now how does this, where, how exactly how the design,. how do the objective design typical type of concerned play below? Right, I indicate, I assume. we all assume objective design criteria is a. location for the community expression of what people wish to see as a bit extra right as well as this that have any bearing on what we wind up seeing in our neighborhoods,. or exactly how do they– Exactly how does it associate with that kinda story? But I ' m type of considering that timeline of all the points that. the planning department is and also so now below ' s this other, then you wear ' t need to go right into a whole lot of detail, however perhaps just a few comments to assist under stand, if this was on'guide we pass our unbiased criteria proceeds to move our wider preparation set of tools in, I think right into. a location where there ' s possibly extra predictability,. even more understanding around what points will resemble in the future provides with any luck much more guidance in relation to the type of requirements that we desire in the look that we desire, yet we ' re still not fairly there yet, right, so is that not true or real? I ' m very, I ' m, I ' m describing this really opaquely, however I ' m wishing it ' s type of, I ' m simply trying to assist, assist the neighborhood recognize that there ' re not gon na'be 11 tales,'call buildings next to them in the following, attempting to, trying to sort of put this in context of exactly how you are kind of. moving further defining what aesthetic in any type of kinda area in the city, how much time that will take, there will be tasks that obtain via in between once in a while, sorry, Is that sorry? Yeah, that ' s I indicate that ' s okay, so so the objective standards is RA is like rapid (indistinct )mm-hmm, excuse me, we ' re planning to be at the preparation commission on April, whatever second meeting in April 23rd, 5th, something like that, the Thursday of. that third week of April, so very first 21st, fine, many thanks.( laughs) April 21st mark your schedule. Those, what those requirements will certainly do is so I ' ve talked a lot about how we have the structure envelope and that, this regulation is transforming the structure envelope, those. Objective criteria can push on that building in ways that our zoning regulation presently doesn ' t
. We can ' t minimize the general like mask that can go in the building, we can ' t lower that the one that people are gon na get delighted about or is the 2.75 location proportion that ' s pairs locations on and on water street we can ' t lower that overall flooring area. proportion, yet'we dictate exactly how it ' s just how it ' s positioned on the site as well as exactly how that
footage is made use of, so one of the things you ' re. gon na see our change area between smaller structures and smaller sized, shorter structures'that are following door, you ' re gon na see demands for articulation on exteriors as well as demands for products as well as create so that,, we obtain structures that while they may be larger, they ' re gon na be larger, I imply, that ' s just truth. matters, these buildings are gon na be larger than what ' s there now.Cause a lot of the city is actually underbuilt contrasted to what it ' s allowed to develop, yet they ' re gon na be more'attractive buildings than what we ' re able to regulate to currently at this moment, so we ' re gon na have and also the thickness bonus ed, several of those standards, they can, you recognize', you, if there ' s. a physical preclusion from the amount of thickness benefit on the site, then the standards need to and also it ' s tough to make that argument for features of the products and articulation and reform and also top quality of open room', quantity of open space, you can make that debate, you can make that disagreement as well as height. without a doubt, setback those things pressure just how much of the structure get built, so it ' s gon na make renovation.
It ' s gon na make we have a lot more control than we have today and also the thickness perk is a real'fact of life in California, now it, it applies to every jurisdiction in the state in the very same way.So the item that we have a bit of a control over is exactly how based on SD 35 are we right? Is that, that legislation that actually,.
When we, really restricts our ability to apply any and also so. at the unbiased requirements? I understand that inquiry is gon na come up, however what regarding the density. benefit and the thickness rewards here today, it ' s right here,
. currently these sites have this quantity of building volume that they ' re enabled to construct as well as they can come in with the thickness. incentive project now and also we won ' t be. eliminating that alternative for them, we are gon na. be assisting them concerning just how make that building. appear like it belong here, that ' s practical, that ' s valuable. Okay, thanks, thank you, Mayor Myers. I imply, council participant Myers, I just intended to
add another thing, Mayor, yes. Principal organizer for sophisticated planning. I just wished to include onto Sarah ' s aims also and also just reiterate that the, the little units prior to you currently with the FTUs put on ' t change any type of building kind today that would be built under. our current purpose criteria, so as well as any kind of, any look and also feel of any type of household. developing that was sent today wouldn ' t change under, under this FTU regulation, It ' s purely concerning including density on the within that building, so no place would certainly there be something that would really feel or look or'be taller?, absolutely nothing would be different than today, It would just be what ' s on the inside and also potentially. just two even more smaller.Thank you, that ' s also thanks, Mayor. Thank you a lot'at this time, I do see raising, I also had a
for additional time that was accepted, so I will begin with your hand is raised to go on, Mayor, this is, this is Martin, I have just one question before public remark, if Okay, go ahead, I simply, I assume it was reacted to, yet I just wished to make certain that in pertains to policy should, if that ' s being suggested there ' s, understanding from staff. that'the applicability of SB35 would be reduced possibly significantly and also that. we wouldn ' t undergo SB35 being caused that this could be possibly a tool for us to have in ahead of time actually in terms. ' Cause we don ' t wan na be. in the placement of having a number of
'S jobs for'us.
Just how can you just reiterate that? Is that exactly how you see it?
Certain, yeah, I can talk. regarding that a little much more. So 5, as I mentioned,. uses to territories based on how well they ' re
. meeting that regional housing need allocation and also there.
are two different tiers.So some jurisdictions in. the state like Santa Cruz are meeting a lot of their. classifications in of the RHNA as well as so in those territories,. SB35 just applies tasks that provide even more than. 50 %or even more as economical, dedicated budget-friendly units for reduced earnings or reduced families, there ' s. another rate for folks that are truly not. obtaining any housing built.
It ' s 10%, so in those.
jurisdictions now, anything that can be found in.
As well as we assume this is one.
might decently raise real estate production and get us closer to satisfying that objective. SB9, will help with that.If we get nine applications, I ' d know that
we ' ve fulfilled lots of yet, but possibly aid us'with. that anything that we can do to like maintain real estate.
manufacturing up is gon na help us limit the and also the variety of
. tasks that get. Thanks.- Yeah, I appreciate that information or simply kind of more. As well as I assume that ' s consistent. When we did the real estate excursion as well as paying attention tour desiring kind of even more as well as similar and also less larger growth, with a great deal of what we listened to. So I Thanks, you are. a participant of the public curious about commenting.
on the 2nd reading and also last adoption of. ordinance number 1022-2, small housing devices,.
– Hi, welcome.- Hi, thank you, there Philippine speaking on part of Santa Cruz tomorrow. I wan na say thanks to personnel for.
It reveals amazing strides.
Especially, we ' ve permitted even more than double the reduced earnings
units devices our goal.We ' ve also permitted. There are still two even more.
years left on this RHNA cycle and also we are just beginning.
to see some of proposals utilize these new state housing regulations.
The growth in our real estate production will certainly be considerably influenced.
Santa Cruz is one little city amongst lots of cities as well as counties that brand-new state laws were created to impact as well as we are doing much far better than most.
base density optimums in zoning as well as usage are applied
, this FDA proposition significantly especially lowers the minimsquare video from 400 square foot.So made use of to 220 square foot FD utilized. This would certainly boost the base thickness of prospective made use of to then. calculate these massive density bonus offer, we are simply. starting to comprehend we have truly thought about currently, the FDU statute need to both environmentally do to evaluate just how it influence all elements of our sustainability, It ' s crucial to
acknowledge the hard work and creative thinking of staff in placing this ordinance together. This might have been an actually interest.This might have been an actually fascinating tool for addressing our budget-friendly real estate needs, if Santa Cruz. were operating beyond the( indistinct) of the new state laws as well as this regulation particularly aided construct de-restricted really reduced earnings devices while not producing the.
potential of intense density market rate units,. which places cost also additionally unreachable functioning course and trainees in our very looked for after place, we have a really limited caring ability for all sources. and also infrastructure. Our functional land for housing is one such constraint as well as
it, it is utmost significance that if we change our little control over land usage policies, that we still have it be really specifically. to incentivize only really low in boosting. this ordinance presently does not, but we wish it may, give thanks to you.Thank you for your
public comment, I will currently question remainder of the guests as well as the first phone call is Excellent. mid-day council participants. I ' m hiring, in. support of this regulation. I ' ve spoken prior to I believe to keep in mind, among the truly helpful tools that this regulation will enable us have is much more options for people, whether they ' re occupants or or looking to get one of these smaller apartments, we currently have our SRO code that allows more density than, than these homes or, or, or condos would produce, however
this is nearly providing us even more choice is and extra devices to to have even more homes for individuals in our area, I additionally wished to mention the cost element of this I ' ve been low revenue,. generally my whole grown-up life and right now the real estate. authority delay checklist ' s yet on a SB8 voucher is shut. I assume there ' s like 12,000. When you put on ' t have the, people on that delay list as well as. alternative to hop on section 8, you have actually restricted alternatives to. locate areas that are cost effective and you understand even if these were the restricted low revenue devices,'which 20 %of them will
be, anyway those systems would certainly. need to go up on the lottery,
and what takes place to individuals like me, who wear ' t jump on the lotto game. that wear ' t have accessibility to those houses and need to. pay'more for other homes in our neighborhood? So I think that the manner in which it is, it ' s gon na offer more alternatives for us and we can check out other methods. that we boost affordability in our neighborhood, yet it is.
really detrimental in terms of obtaining people. that require affordable houses in to produce these.
constraints and obstacles on these types of devices.
that make them tougher o pencil out for market price designers that are building them when.'we currently have other options for cost effective housing.Developers come in and build.
a lot more cost effective units anyhow. So this is not a panacea of cost, yet it has to do with producing extra choices for market rate housing and producing more budget-friendly market rate.
Thanks.- Thank you, our following telephone call is Kyle Kelly.
– Yeah, thanks. Mayor council as well as staff, it was an excellent presentation, I spoke throughout the very first reading, yet because this returned again, I desired to come and also talk and also
speak with every one of you, these,.
It doesn ' t have to be the same method that land values, ' reason I put on ' t understand if any person right here has actually. ' Reason in this instance for how.
much we ' re at now, being homeless, overcrowdedness, commutes,. I know lots of you are interested in the. rail, however it appears like it looks actually inadequate. You state individuals should. be able to commute in, but we ' re not gon na create. much more options for them to live right here, we have to. develop a lot more choices for individuals to live here, if we ' re gon na. state immigrants rate, you require to broaden choices for. them to find and live below. 'So these are giving a lot more choices. Possibly it ' s not best exactly what you want, yet they ' ll give alternatives for a lot extra household, friends for ourselves, for every person else that we know, so thanks, thanks for supporting this.I actually hope that.
– Hi, I ' m Jonna Payton, a lengthy time Westside. And I wouldn ' t have to. It wouldn ' t imply more for real estate, specifically for young individuals like me without indicating bigger.
And for that reason I highly motivate us, thank you, thank you for your public remark, our next telephone call.
Yeah, that ' s I suggest that ' s all right, so so the unbiased criteria is RA is like fast (indistinct )mm-hmm, excuse me, we ' re preparation to be at the planning payment on April, whatever second meeting in April 23rd, 5th, something like that, the Thursday of. We can ' t lower the overall like mask that can go in the structure, we can ' t reduce that the one that people are gon na get excited concerning or is the 2.75 location proportion that ' s couples places on and also on water street we can ' t lower that overall floor location. I ' ve talked before I assume to keep in mind, one of the actually beneficial devices that this regulation will certainly allow us have is much more options for individuals, whether they ' re occupants or or looking to get one of these smaller apartments, we already have our SRO code that allows extra density than, than these apartments or, or, or apartments would certainly produce, yet
this is just simply giving us more even more option and and also extra to to have more even more residences people in our communityNeighborhood I also likewise to speak talk the affordability cost element this I ' ve been low incomeEarnings. It doesn ' t have to be the same means that land appreciates, ' reason I put on ' t know if anyone here has in fact. Perhaps it ' s not excellent what specifically you want, yet they ' ll provide choices for a lot a lot more household, pals for ourselves, for everybody else that we know, so thank you, thank you for sustaining this.I actually wish that.Hi, good afternoon, I would like to say thanks to team preparation, commission
council for identifying a trouble low use single tenancy device as well as give those that
Currently and (indistinct )as a tenant and as a. young gift specialist. I assume( indistinct )would, it really provides me really hope that.
starter once again and also truly like the concept of a building, a various dimension homes in it, some workshops, a person rooms, some two.
bedrooms that fit individuals as well as households in different conditions. in life I think expanded ownership, huge for stability as was discussed absolutely nothing would boost ability tenants than really having the possibilities to phone their very own house.
banner, It would supply even more choices with center course and also expand middle class being secured outta capital to possess their own house in Santa Cruz, It would supply investment in our area and also actually reinforce.
the connections to neighborhoods right here by having the ability to have an area Santa Cruz, I additionally truly like innovation from the staff doing.
Thank you, excellent afternoon
,. Mayor and council members, Elizabeth( indistinct), in behalf of the Monterey. Bay Economic Partnership, our real estate campaign.
includes a broad coalition of community members,
local. employers and companies to support for and militarize.
an increase in real estate of all types as well as income.
levels in our area in 2018.( indistinct) Partnered with envisioned real estate to publish our white paper,. what realistic plan adjustments can enhance housing price in the Monterey Bay area,. where we lay out numerous ways, regional federal governments. as well as conveniently raise real estate manufacturing, we are delighted that the city of Santa Cruz
has actually worked towards embracing our referrals. anywhere feasible in line with our ninth suggestion to zone for thickness, we support.
team ' s suggestion to authorize the flexible density thickness system regulation in order. to add in the direction of a manufacturing of a varied mix of housing types within the city of Santa Cruz, we particularly log the FQ. regulation as it removes for more missing center type residences in Santa Cruz that will certainly be.
Our following is phone number ending in 5. Go in advance and silence on your own, press 6 or unmute, there you go, welcome The episode, construct more units with the dense incentive at 50% that the, that more systems below even more, it goes greater,. When are we on a road.
Vote, thank you, our following finishing 4, go ahead and unmute on your own. Yes, welcome, thank You,
. I ' ve worked for seven years in this community and Midtown resident., this entire topic is.
the planning payment and also why there was only. a 4 to 3 votes.It likewise deserves keeping in mind. that the inclusionary is just on the base, not with the density incentive is weakening the impact of affordable health and wellness of points, but that ' s why you ' re now seeing just 5 %, instead of the 20% you can also because. of the thick parts, you can remove away the. defense of troubles, auto parking requirements as well as elevation, as well as open room, you can additionally waive the advancement requirements, It ' s. likewise not easy to understand why you ' re accepting this or attempting to authorize this now before the objective requirements and also my understanding is that they wan na boost the height a lot more on the base, there ' s no mention about type factor plans as well as where those were where they additionally influenced by the density bonus offer, that really is. exceeded the conversation. And also there ' s been no instances giving by advanced preparation to reveal that if you consider 9 0 8 sea road,. they initially suggested 396 units of sous at 4 60 to 6 48, if you check out it with 220, they can count the car parking, they account tripping away business, but adding. the result, the advantage of their car park generate 559 units.You presume that by adding even more density to a present atmosphere or, form element that you have no additional effect, which would be ridiculous and in fact, because specific project, I believe last time I checked, they added an additional 9% at 433
, so you might go over a few of hundred units in less. than three and also a half acres, these are dramatic. changes and also without a big out, without a. further analysis, without a true basic plan. amendment process, which has actually not been carried out in the, you actually put on ' t have a sense of the real.
impact on the area. As well as likewise understand that.
the order strategy, which was only at 55 years per acre versus 150 units, plus you had hundreds of people objecting to it, people do care, there was, I think of 2,400. that signed that application three or four years earlier,. there was 300 individuals that
business individuals. that signed a request, particularly service people that got on ocean street,. water as well as SoCal, recognizing the effects it would certainly. carry their businesses.I think that you just. just can ' t claim that this is a minor change in the code, but this supplies more choices when it ' s never been showed to deal with price as well as actually, shed it ' source of the high bonus, please, you really much For your remark.
' Cause students have these devices that pay for economical prices, of course they do I ' m. with them on that subject.But what has taken place to. Okay and also our city ' s. right to do its very own land, usage planning and also lose our. Yes, all these trainees need cost effective and also comfy real estate
.
the St George resort. However the pictures do that, that ' s the case and also you show pictures. of little advancement that they
' re planning in the pipeline, 10 tale structure therefore do not embrace this action, we put on ' t desire 10 tale phone calls, truths to these boxes all over our downtown utilized to simply their task, thanks for your comment, our following customer ' s telephone number ending in eight, 9, nine.Go ahead As well as hi there, can you hear me? Yes', wonderful, thank you.- Hi, this is Ben,. student real estate union phoning call to enter your last minute below. I really wish to repeat. our company ' s full assistance for the ordinance and also the adjustments it brings and truly. going back to the phone calls setting about transforming our character at the university, I believe I kinda that narrative discuss
just how appropriate and also so when we speak about building real estate, when we state the university must be. developing all your houses, city must be'constructing all your houses are (indistinct) and.
both have a commitment for those issuance, so I think the concept that we ' ll shed our area personality by permitting individuals belong to live as well as approaching this issue with dilemma from a situation tax obligation from.
I ' ll allow that 4,.
seven, have your hand up and also go in advance and also unmute yourself telephone number ending in. Hello there, hello, hi, my. name is Patrick Katie. I ' m just contacting to. assistance flexible D devices. I work as an instructor in the area and I assume this kind. of housing would assist and various other kind of solution'. workers discover a place to live below in the area.- So I think are you end up? Okay, following caller. caller phone number finishing in 8. Hi, can you hear me? -Hi, I can hear you. Thanks, many thanks for taking my telephone call. I simply wish to see these. ballots on this ordinance zero, the general public document.
for this thing today was 4 to one once again, please listen to the voters of your city, particularly on a regulation. that would have such massive and also challenging to imagine. effects on every one of us.I concur with the people. who ' ve been discussing the desperate demand for. a lot more affordable real estate. There ' s no question about that, yet there are severe. troubles at this this moment as well as the unintentional we ' d be dealt with. with mean we ' d be even worse off than we are currently for decades to find.
As well as I see council member Brown with Amanda council Member Council council member coming after that council participant Brown, thank you, Mayor, I had one more inquiry for team, so the there ' s this, the solitary SROs is what wasn ' t. being generated, appropriate. We ' re obtaining one or two every couple of years, which. Yeah, so we had this kinda question on why aren ' t we.
of both existing jobs'to kind of talk with them. about what they ' re seeing with their project. And also the agreement was.
that the largest problem that developers cited was the need that they
So a lot of programmers really choose to at least rent for some of. time after when as well as interested. They truly checked out that as a hindrance and also
it ' s a challenge obstacle financing, and especially specifically the wayMethod the coordinate was created, that it would certainly permit as much as half. of the devices to be printed can make it hard for. private buyers to get financing, and. then you ' re in a situation where you can only sell. to all cash money customers, which is simply truly difficult. Like at any type of size of house. Therefore they just felt like. there were a whole lot of restrictions around that as well as if'they wanted. to build that housing kind, they would find a various. location where they can develop likes or one bedroom under.
a various kinda cap where they would choose SROs, which are restricted to rental.
Well, it ' s additionally ' cause it ' s. an exclusively project.Like that ' s likewise a problem. Only that, so there ' s no,.'it simply hasn ' t really.
restriction on services. so just '50% you rented was.
a large thing in the money that we heard. To make sure that has effects not.
Got it, well, thank you. If we ' re gon na relocate. And also up until we have a better understanding of the effects of the.
brand-new real estate legislation pertaining to thickness perk, our goal are various other and also typical real estate manufacturing actions that will impact neighborhood. Okay', we have motion by council member upcomings there a second, yes, I I ' ll second that I put on ' t wan na lose
the flooring that Okay, Let ' s just take, read this activity,
have an initial by seconded by
Brown, okay.Can I'ask personnel a concern either for Sarah or Butler, would that activity is you see any type of timeline with that said movement and also clarity with a few of those items on that one? (laughs )I will take an appearance and sort of Bonnie, could youshare it once more? ' Reason there are different. timelines for each of those that I believe would certainly be valuable to talk with, so allow ' s begin with inclusionary, we can, we can have a look at inclusionary that can be done succeeding to this coordinate being passed or that could be done separate from it, normally we, to a, a pretty deep dive with inclusionary because
we wan na ensure that we are doing something that is going to still be feasible, still ensure that projects can obtain built.That claimed we have, we have a requirement for SROs and if we were looking at, as an example, matching. that SRO standard that is something that we can come back to the council with in,, fairly brief. period of time, It would it takes a few months minimum to do that, plus there. are workload effects and chance expenses understand genuinely it ' s possibly 5 months or we have the ability to port that in to get the work done, to get it discovered, obtain it. to preparing payment, get their suggestion. and after that to bring it to the city board, to make sure that ' s type of the timeline pertaining to that, unbiased criteria, sarah stated that previously we, this been going to the planning payment on April 21st, we will certainly be proceeding to guidance quickly thereafter.Right, we require to comprehend.
And I simply keep in mind that. Currently enabled right now under the general strategy?
So where Sarah was speaking about the 2.75 R we may have building heights that wear ' t fit a 2.75 R, where location ratio, the. housing responsibility act does not permit us to use. those elevation criteria when we wear ' t have … when you can ' t achieve the. full density enabled by And also so once more, as we.
pointed out several times, this FDU proposition wouldn ' t adjustment. the massing or the range and we come back with the objective standard, It will have implications.
30 or 40 feet in height, if the full thickness can ' t be attained in that limitation, we have to permit greater under the housing responsibility act the modified corridor strategy, I ' m not sure precisely what ' s being.
So with regard to regulations, if we ' re waiting on. regulation, I suggest, sarah, with this pointedly prior to if we ' re waiting on regulation that ' s gon na happen on a we ' ve seen even more real estate regulation and the last 5 years after that we saw in the previous 15 as well as that ' s gon na continue to take place, we ' ve got ta keep proceeding our method. with developing real estate consisting of generating devices at all revenue levels, but if we were waiting on what occurred with regulation, the earliest we would be doing something. Is end of this year? Governor indicators points in. the duration of October of each year as well as. oftentimes we ' re scrambled
going to get those. Updates in place? Therefore we may not have the. capability to find back with this and right now as well as
at that. factor we ' re in the next.So I value like'. maintaining an actually close eye on what ' s happening at the day level. As well as occasionally we do wan na resist on, we ' re doing, for instance,. with our SB9 laws with communities and several systems, because we understand that real estate and also. area growth in the state, they maintain informing us that they ' re gon na come out with policies. We ' re preparing for that
in the next following or two2 so for this particular issueConcern I wouldn ' t recommend you ' re waiting for what ' s gon na happen take place the housing legislation because. that state thickness benefit is gon na apply regardless, as, as we ' ve learnt through number of. color, looks like Matt could have one various other.
point that( indistinct)
and I simply wanted to. point out also, in relation to understanding the impact you know, this proposition before you doesn ' t allow these FBOs anywhere
that SROs aren ' t currently permitted as well as so the SROs currently have a greater strength as well as intensity of development than the FBU can ever have.And so we can look to'them already begin under what, what is. possible on those websites in regards to thickness, so I just intended to make that, that point again, that,, we'' re actually not changing any, any of the influences correctly in terms of,
, in regards to Brownish then council member Myers Mayor, so I do have some comments, but I examine occurred as Lee, as director Butler was connected to the question around increased possibility for raised
for his thickness project.And so I desired to ask where that goes to, it ' s my understanding. that the planning payment had really hoped to explore this and I believe weren ' t able to do that.
' Cause trainees have these devices that afford inexpensive prices, of training course they do I ' m. with them on that subject.But what has actually taken place to. And also I see council participant Brownish with Amanda council Member Council council participant coming then council member Brown, thank you, Mayor, I had one even more concern for personnel, so the there ' s this, the single SROs is what wasn ' t. being generated, right. Well, it ' s likewise ' trigger it ' s. an exclusively project.Like that ' s additionally a problem. 30 or 40 feet in height, if the complete density can ' t be attained in that limit, we have to permit higher under the housing liability act the changed corridor strategy, I ' m not sure exactly what ' s being. We ' re anticipating that
in the next month or two2 so for this particular issue, I wouldn ' t recommend suggest ' re waiting for what ' s gon na happen with the housing real estate regulationsDue to the fact thatAnd also so I'' d like to understand where that, that, what this staff positions on that particular, what, what took place
at that meeting, where there was an attempt to begin to relocate a proposal like that
ahead from the preparation board directly to us, so as well as that was happening fairly a while earlier, we'' re speaking about seriousness and also we can'' t wait more Mon extra months months, however they place ' t had a possibility to have the conversation that I understand at the very least some commissioners wish to have, so I'' m just wondering where that'' s at and also why, certain.
Pleased to talk to that, The preparation compensation did have a, a discussion on inclusionary. and also that recommendation has been forwarded to the Mayor, the product has not been brought to the council yet, but will certainly be at some point I place'' t had a, a control with the Mayor with respect to when that,, will actually
occur.Great, all right, so I wan na.
make, so it is in the mix, however it just it'' s not been focused on. So I also wan na be clear that the, the inclusionary referrals for the that originated from the preparation payment incentive were, were connected to thickness incentive and also not particularly pertaining to FDS, there was a conversation concerning FDU on a similar timeline, however those, those as well as the preparation compensation, identified several of the issues linked with that,
. because some of those suggestions would actually not motivate the manufacturing of really low,, income devices, so.
that, that is gon na take a great deal of analysis, that'' s, that is gon na get on a, a longer timeline, then a straightforward change we desired to just match FD to SRO with going to 20%, very reduced, as opposed to 20 %reduced, you record all that, that was a lot (laughs) I do and also, I have, I and also I appreciate that. I disagreed somewhat with the degree of pick figuring it out, however I'' ll just do that.( laughs )An offline conversation, I do.
have some extra comments I wan na make and I'' m gon na tip back and I'' m gon na chat concerning the
.( audio declines) that I respect '' reason I ' m
propositions. forward which people I see that are struggling.
and also I want us to think of that for a minute, we.
hear from members of the public, we need alternatives, we need.
selections, we recognize that nobody has truly any type of choices right now.We do have– We have an undersupply of.
housing, I identify that and also I'' m not opposed thickness,.
Let'' s speak about someone that one could kind of.
picture, speak about this terrific, cost effective deliberately Activity. Allow'' s discuss a Santa Cruz City Park, who gains, I'' m just gon na round it 18 park as well as straight employee and also I'' m in a grounding, however I'' m gon na remain that park as well as direct employee as well as I'' m type of is a composite of experiences that I. recognize happening our rock citywide that worker lost their housing to a lease, that worker is residing in their car on friends at $18 per hour, currently I'' m gon na deposit the reality that employee.
and once more, a composite could be functioning 20 hrs.
That is not because we didn ' t develop enough real estate in the past, that ' s not because we didn ' t build enough real estate over the past nonetheless many years, that ' s since there is an increase people with the capability to pay even more rental fee as well as property owners that will certainly charge it, so the present average rate of is 24 95, which is rather darn close. Yeah and we all struggle, I recognize that, but who aren ' t in that we chat regarding option all of that, I really feel like there ' s this detach from the truth that low wage family. If we ' re gon na offer.
I fall short to recognize just how structure less aids those housing the most, I fail to recognize exactly how structure less doesn ' t rise competition for the existing devices that we have here', I am actually privileged to have secure housing had steady real estate for a number of years. That wasn ' t constantly the scenario that I located myself and my family members in, there was a letter that was. sent out in by a Mr, charlie VA who speaks about his.
I imply, that was me.
real estate for everybody.This is concerning developing real estate for youngsters or maturing moms and dads as well as for that city employee, it ' s about developing real estate for him or her, It ' s regarding building real estate for our middle course suppose the 30,000 commuters that enter our city to function had an area to live, just how would that effect environment? Where is the intersectionality. of choices that we make around real estate and also land use? If we ' re devoted to environment,. that ' s just just one location. I recognize'most of us on this.
Allow'' s not have high surges all. Why are we proposing to proceed to, hasn ' t been working,. I will certainly not be sustaining the movement, thank you, thank you, council participant Myers, and also then like council Myers, yeah, I simply I additionally just wan na state on, I won'' t support this movement and I just, I, yes, I guess I likewise simply truly wan na direct out considering that I'' ve been on the city council,.
Now, economical housing programmers, I.
can name five 5 budget-friendly real estate jobs are going on right now, they'' re in the permitting allowingProcedure got obtained permanent.
so we'' ve spoken with individuals. I was especially struck by the instructor that called today, made a location to live and it'' s a starter for them. Ideally they get.
maintained by having a residence, perhaps they can assemble the funding to in fact purchase it, this.
offers us the adaptability, excellent device, let'' s test. It constantly alter in ordinance, It ' s not going the means we will on and there will certainly be future city councils that will certainly modify this with time, this is a tool in our land use toolkit as well as it'' s there to try to get us for housing, not in six months, not in 6 years, we really start making points happen and we'' ve seen.
that trajectory already, currently started and I'' m sorry, but California is. individuals enjoy California.They relocate to California.( laughs )And after that they tell us, “Oh, you. shouldn ' t be developing this.
” I imply, it ' s ironic to me. that a'great deal of this comes after individuals obtain settled in The golden state, after that they ' re like, well, like.
Allow'' s simply
try, do some.
a home below in Santa Cruz, so I'' m not gon na support this motion. I do, I would be to make an activity, to progress the. team, thank you, Mayor. Thank you, council participant Myers, I see council participant and also. Brown with your hands up for the benefit of time, do you have any additional remarks you ' d like to make? I do, fine, Go in advance, council number coming and afterwards council number Brown, I just wan na claim that the objective of this is not regarding the manufacturing of real estate in our community, It'' s regarding making certain that if we'' re gon na relocate in. this direction, that we'' re resolving the price issue.And when
people are regarding individuals that are trying to get stabilized in the area, that'' s me, I'do not. own a home,'I ' m a tenant. The only thing that ' s protecting me and the placement that I ' m in right currently is the truth that I was privileged to locate a proprietor, maintaining their rates. reduced and I here frequently a lot of my buddies in the area,'I ' ve heard it, we ' re gon na be resolving this late our schedules too when we reach eviction protections.But there are lots of
. individuals in this community that are attempting their. musicians able to remain below and also when they obtain 20% lease rises, searching for someplace. else where they can live is incredibly hard.
The concern below is attempting to. figure out how we can increase the quantity of inclusionary,. each restricted budget-friendly real estate that
. can come into new devices. Since as our planning commissioner, as our planning director said,. as our planning division has actually stated, that the just.
way that you can keep affordable real estate in the.
community is by making it derestricted, so if we ' re
. gon na speak about building units in our area with hopes that
the size will make budget friendly, after that. they need to be derestricted, since that ' s the only way to make certain that they ' ll be permanently. inexpensive in the long term, that ' s what we ' re attempting to do is maintain budget friendly housing. all time in that'. That ' s all I have to.
claim, council member Brown.- Yeah, thanks, Mayor.
I just wan na state, I fall short how. progressing with
a proposition that would basically promote, facilitate even more market rate real estate.
without any type of affordability, any type of additional price is mosting likely to profit the functioning households and also the people that you all are driving here, I simply give you a circumstance of somebody who could never in a million years possibly rent out if they (laughs) had a flatmate, one of these devices.
that we'' re discussing, I'' m I ' m hearing oppositions in what my colleagues were saying, one, we are not doing an excellent job.What we, what we ' ve done, hasn'' t worked. As well as at the exact same time, the very same council participant claiming we ' ve met our objectives, see, later on today we we'' ve fulfilled our objectives to ensure that I hear oppositions around the timeliness of the bus back now, when it pertains to constructing market rate real estate, you understand, additional.
affordability demands. But when we speak about.
a little (indistinct) the percentage of inclusionary unit, we need to study it permanently therefore I would certainly simply motivate people to believe concerning that when you choose what.
stressed as well as what needs even more carefully and I would likewise encourage us concerning the fact, not just concept of housing, supply matching for meeting the demand of the and I'' m all for not waiting and I'' m prepared to in fact make Say thanks to council participant Brown, I assume this has actually been a good discussion as well as I value.
every person'' s input on emails. I assume there were around 7.
e-mails with various issues, thank you to preparing personnel.
( indistinct) as well as Butler for clearing up a few of.
the questions that I had from those issues around density, as well as just how this policy drives development.Those problems were
clearly addressed which it ' s not changing. versatile density devices, the
size as well as you know the height setback, the inclusionary requirement. Those concerns have actually been addressed. We have to ahead meeting. the requirements of our community in
the very best way as well as you understand, this is something that we can progress is support that with. extra versatile device that provide
options.I fully believe that and also has.
what council member Cummings brought up, continuing to function. on methods to fulfill economical de-restricted pay for housing. in our city will certainly be a top priority with this change in adaptable. to head to flexible thickness device. This is just one item of that, will get us so lots of individuals. will certainly require real estate option. With that, I ' d like to take.
a vote on this existing motion on the flooring by council. member and also seconded
by council member Brownish and also. we obtain a roll call vote.
Yes, no, sorry.- No.- Aye.- Aye.- No.
That movement does not pass two in support. You have one application as well as.
For Butler, I Gon na ask if, could comment, sure, thank you, Mayor I was simply attempting to make certain that I'comprehend this and I think
that and I think that I obtained it now,, you ' re suggesting that we come back to you, so we would certainly go to the planning payment with a changed ordinance that consists of the very same provisions of the FDU as well as except we would certainly also loop in inclusionary changes as well as you want those to go from the 20% that they presently are to 25 %as well as that and also after that at this, when we bring those back, that ' s when we would certainly bring the amended resolution.So the modified resolution directing, okay. I understand what you ' re suggesting, (laughs) and I, wasn ' t quite sure that I got it the very first time. That ' s 20 %at reduced earnings with 80, which is 80% very immediate, I believe, given that the uniformity or the distance of FDS and SROs, I suggest, I would certainly wan na work with our financial development team who comprehends the funding of that,, a lot more thoroughly as well as much more completely as they develop some budget friendly housing jobs in our community, however I think that modification if we, if we changed FDS from low to really reduced and maintained it at a, as well as sorry and also changed it to 50% AMI rather of 80% AMI ' reason that evaluation, we ' ve currently obtained the SROs that have been developed that, that are being created back,.
Making certain that there is that tasks are still sensible? We wan na get the maximamount.
If we ' re not obtaining any, supply inexpensive real estate.
That ' s correct.They ' ll examine will.
( sound drops) that I care about '' cause I ' m
proposals. That is not because we didn ' t construct enough housing in the previous, that ' s not since we didn ' t build enough housing over the past nonetheless numerous years, that ' s due to the fact that there is an increase people with the capability to pay more lease and also proprietors who will certainly charge it, so the existing average rate of is 24 95, which is pretty darn close. Yeah and we all struggle, I understand that, yet who aren ' t in that we talk regarding option all of that, I feel like there ' s this disconnect from the fact that reduced wage family. The only thing that ' s protecting me and also the placement that I ' m in right now is the reality that I was fortunate to discover a property owner, keeping their costs. That ' s 20 %at low revenue with 80, which is 80% really instant, I assume, offered that the consistency or the nearness of FDS and also SROs, I mean, I would certainly wan na function with our economic development team that recognizes the financing of that,, extra thoroughly and also more thoroughly as they develop some affordable housing projects in our area, however I think that modification if we, if we switched over FDS from low to very low as well as kept it at a, as well as sorry and also changed it to 50% AMI rather of 80% AMI ' reason that evaluation, we ' ve currently got the SROs that have been established that, that are being created back,.Yeah, I think that
intricacy, that component for lots of individuals to understand is not just the unit count, however actually whether someone can get the funding, whether long term holding the property over time, managing with that building and construction loan duration and after that into with any luck filling the units complicated, so I believe you maintain increasing bench as well as people are gon na go construct, develop housing, various other places, not below, tan Cruz, so
thanks, Mayor Council, participant Brown, I just
a, a quick historical review below, very recent his for those that are out the council as well as,, a few of us were and will remember this previous common council established that the most effective method to obtain housing built was to react to programmers needs and also decrease, I exclusionary centered that required job, I did not that area neighborhood members with
the city, we obtained a Kaiser showing
that that was the wonderful spot for penciling out your task and also five participants of the council that,, we were told through a research by Kaiser Mar that that was the
just means we were gon na get real estate was to area members, took legal action against the city, they had no various other choice to attempt to guarantee the will of the individuals by a ballot of individuals action O was maintained at 15% inclusionary would certainly criterion, then we had a minute where we had a common council that
thought application would certainly ahead in increased park as well as so we increased it, we were
informed, so as well as after that Kaiser Marten discovered a means to
show us that maybe done, right, absolutely nothing had changed in the real life, like in the material globe, absolutely nothing had actually altered, but we then obtained a research telling us
we just factor we'' re getting very low income and also low earnings units entirely with ideal by the state of, on those devices, I'' m talking about market systems And the city is, is wisely utilizing our very own properties and also dealing with our companions to actually bring those things to permission, there was also make use of a new law that we were able.
to place specific tasks today, that they.
got permitted ideal away.Jesse Marsh
is a fantastic instance of that. So the state leveraging this reduced and also very reduced revenue housing, it'' s not our inclusionary. regulation, that ' s leveraging this state legislation, then. city intelligently utilizing particular homes, take advantage of, attempt to put location. The inclusionary price proportion right currently is not producing these extremely reduced income devices is not, so I'' m just. gon na push back on that particular. And also I truly, I just, I'' ve kind of finished with the dispute Mayor, I'' d like to call the question on the. 'present, on'the present motion. ' Cause I wear ' t think. we ' re gon na go anywhere as well as we can discuss this. in the council office about whether we'' re we ' re. on the ideal track or'not.
However I assume we ' re almost.
two hrs on this. I would call the question. on', on the present activity on the court, that ' s a, that '
s a movement to call a question. or needs motion.Call a question, yes, okay, we have a movement to call. One second. Okay, we have a roll telephone call vote.'For discourse( indistinct )- Aye. -No. – [Clerk] Brown. -I ' m( indistinct) fine. -[ Staff] Myers.- Aye. Mayor Watkins. -Aye.- Aye. Okay, so we are now movement. houses for ballot on the activity to vote on the motion which '
s for us, so let ' s do a roll telephone call. Elect the activity by council Brown,( indistinct) – No. – [Staff] Cummings. – Aye. – [
Brown.- Aye.
Staff] Myers.- No.- No.- No.- Okay, so the activity. by council member Brown not asked for no,
all right,. Council member Myers council member, thanks, Mayor, I ' d like to make a motion. number 2022 managing small housing devices,. changing small possession( indistinct) amendment. as well as adopter resolution licensing getting the city fashion as regional coastal amendment last, all right. We have an activity by council. member Myers, 2nd. As well as we have a roll call vote. – [Staff] For Johnson. – Aye. – [Clerk] Cummings. – No. Brown. No. Myer. Yes. – [Staff] Mayo Watkin. – Aye. – Aye. That activity passes for in favor to against council participant missing as well as, I just wan na say, think this thing as council member Myer said has actually been a lot longer than we expected momentarily hearing, It was uncommon in my, for second hearing to have.
this much conversation as well as, but I assume as well as vital we wear'' t have the possibility as body to have these conversations as well as elevate worries on part of our components and also you understand, we still have e-mails coming in and lots of in support as well and I would such as to simply state that there were some truly great factors.
brought up and I'' m wishing that our planning staff, your ability to actually study this.
has been lead and extremely valuable Butler, so I.
hope that an ongoing exploration into some of the conversation items today, specifically in relates to how we budget-friendly real estate and also nation other,, recommendations around being budget-friendly, such as a 50 DMI DMI look,, any one of those recomme going forward focusing on proceeded course of meeting the requirement for our children.
in relation to housing.So keeping that
being said, you all for,, sharing that I would certainly such as to make for suggestion to continue items 27, which is changes connecting to tiny cell wireless.
as well as item 28, the testimonial and also except last parks and also recreation annual record, I'' d like to see if there would certainly be a movement to, move those to April 12th,.
the next, to make sure that week on I have vice and also after that Terry Johnson, I'' m delighted to relocate those things as well as if that doesn ' t raise any, I'' d like to ask yeah, supervisor Matt Huff, would that collaborate with your team.
for time? We'' re happy to continue. both of those items, remarkable, is there a second? We have the vice Mayor Watkins and council participant Terry Johnson.
– Second. – So we have an activity to.
proceed things, number 27 as well as 28 on the agenda to April 12th meeting, we have a motion by vice.
Watkins, council participant Myers. Oh, I'' m sorry, I was going to sorry, Mayor, I didn'' t I, my hand, alright. May we have a roll call ballot? – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye.- 4 in support as well as one.
( indistinct) and so that brings us thing number 29, expiration.
of statewide evictions. And also before welcome council participant Rock. Before we start that product, I will certainly call a five minute bile.
break resting below. (laughs), so thanks, we'' ll return at 4:23, Thanks. Currently we will certainly begin with our next agenda item.
number nine for members of the general public for council member, that'' s just joining us things number and also 20 have actually been to the April 12th schedule, so currently we will start with thing number 29 expiration statewide evictions, the.
halt extra lawful aid and support for lessees impacted by COVID for participants of
. the general public for streaming this conference, if this is a product you want talk about currently is the time to a hire seeing the instructions on your pupil order will certainly be a presentation of the product by personnel adhered to by questions from the council, we will certainly then take public comment and after that go back to the.
council for deliberation and action, so now I.
will certainly present it over too.Yes, great afternoon. Remember the common council.
in your program packet is a standing update with info concerning different resources that the city has provided together with the region housing and also health division for renters that are experiencing challenge as a result of the COVID 19 emergency at, at your last meeting, there was a request placed this item on the schedule at the at the urging of numerous.
individuals and also organizations that are collaborating with tenants that have been impacted by the COVID emergency, the focus of that was for.
certain for specific demands, one was to.
accredit a local laboratory amount of evictions for.
anybody waiting housing is vital settlements till completion of 2022,, or until their present application paid 2 was to identify sources of funds to keep the occupants housed a property owners, including ARPA the 14 million safeguarded by Legislator for homelessness and also or various other resources and also to develop this right into your spending plan, as a backup for.
housing is key three was to infuse financing, coast up existing local lawful help.
companies and collaborations that give pre renter.
counseling and also lawful depiction with.
unique 10 for the more than for the overrepresented undocumented and four call for all expulsions.
between proprietors and renters with the objective of avoiding.And I would add
that comparable request for submitted to the various other cities in Santa Cruz region, along with the county the area of Santa Cruz.
board of supervisors. And I believe the county is additionally having a schedule item to discuss this, this mid-day as an outcome of that, I had the ability to function with my.
city attorney as well as region council colleagues evaluation of possibility for a further neighborhood postponement in addition to the proposition to need expulsion job contracts in between.
property managers as well as occupants. As well as we evenly ended that '' reason for modifications in the state law that were propounded influence during the COVID emergency situation the city in as well as the region as well as other cities are currently preempted from these these kinds of actions, the eviction postponement along with the mandatory arbitration of situations involving lease that ended up being due in between completion or the end of September.
one therefore for that reason the suggestion is.
to focus on additional resources of financing as well as that is what the city has actually been,.
has been seeking to therefore think Bonnie Lipscomb is (indistinct) some of those efforts I'' m not seeing her on, thank you, I ' m happy to answer any type of
. inquiries that you might have about the about the the capacity for an expulsion halt the necessary me council member Brown, thanks, Mayor, I do have one question regarding that, I, my understanding is from materials that you'' ve sent us and likewise my added questions,.
there are communities that are extending their.
eviction auditorium.Outside of the real estate is program throughout the duration of prolonged COVID emergency statement at those,. with those jurisdiction cities as well as considered that we simply voted to ha to expand COVID. emergency for 60 even more days, would certainly that offer us similar.
cover to something similar? So there was a duration. of time prior to the flow of possibly K32, which is.
referenced in your program report throughout which cities were able to take on eviction postponement statute, that that was especially accredited by an arrangement of state regulation and the door to that shut city, any type of the city of Santa Cruz performed in truth an expulsion halt regulation that ended. in September of 2020 cause a brand-new state law entered well-known an additional evict that was statewide and also that that expanded the postponement to September 30th one after that with the passage of abdominal 8 2 there was an extra protections, put in place for occupants and proprietors that looked for state help with the real estate program and also. that legislation especially enabled cities that had those evictions defenses in area already to remain to have
those in place.But the law particularly specifies. that any kind of effort to expand or extend or act. A step that that happens. in between August of 2020 and also March
31st, 2022 will certainly have no effect.
Before April 1st, 2022 as well as then in addition, the statute states that a
provision arrangement or.- Council participant Cumming your hand. Hey Tony, I was curious,.
Think my inquiry is if someone waiting rental support, it ' s forced out to those landlords, they'' ll obtain that rent, well, that, that help too, since, this is something that ' s been functioned out with the renter and landlord under the assumption'that ought to the tenant be able to get the assistance, after that they won ' t be evicted residence, however if they are kicked out the property owners, then obtain that at that time, well trigger maybe if they get forced out and they wear ' t, then they don ' t, it ' s a shed lose scenario, but I don ' t know, or it could be a the proprietor gets the help and also the individual still gets rejected, so I ' m just'. interested concerning, yeah, I need to admit that I ' m not as acquainted with just how those. repayments are processed via the real estate program, so I'can ' t really offer you a clear on that particular, It stands to factor to me that if an application is pending I put on ' t understand just how that and'an occupant is forced out unless the tenant or somebody. brings that focus of the state program there might be a situation where. the pro the application is process as late has currently, once again, I ' m not, not positive. Concerning that city does not straight deal with those applications.So I ' m not as familiar with that'. And it would seem as well if the person gotten it and after that finished up obtaining kicked out likelihood,. they would certainly go is quite reduced due to the fact that many people already will lost count on their federal government, so however I ' m many thanks for the. clarification, yeah. many thanks, more lost, extra trust. Thank you, council member Myers, Simply a concern for staff, I was simply curious, I recognize the area has involved well,, a pair concerns, I presume, Bonnie, I recognize that we were supporting as high as possible rental help, so I just wished to recognize a. little much more concerning what we ' ve done and whether or not we have, we are still give capacity for people obtain support, whether it ' s what I think, what sort of. assistance we are providing.And after that I guess for Matt do we understand anything from either semi participant
rock or Senator Laird in terms of kind of initiatives in Sacramento to attempt to deal with, these repayment results, various other things and also whether there ' s. a, any, any kind of regulation that you recognize is gon na'reminds me of the ed farce whether or not there ' s an activity at the state in regards to trying to, attempting. to get this cleansed up.
Individuals not sure who, that can answer those two, but I ' ll toss those at thank you, I can speak to, yet, however as well as had an additional conference. Ed here, but so just
could do it, so as far.
around 200 K for down payment, to make sure that'' s one item of that we'' re supplying the city is likewise supplying, has given cab around 238,000, I'' m gon na let Tiffany aid.
me if I'' m, I ' m providing the incorrect, the precise information.
, yet that, that those.
cash have really been totally extended now, right? Tiffany, so approval, yes, so as well as we do recognize that taxi has been functioning with the region looking for more aid for their programs, so I, that response one of concerns, yes, then councils, I just add to simply remarks,, we'' re not aware from. either setting up member stone or Legislator LA point.
in time that there'' s any kind of active legal initiatives, at least that their offices are associated with there have been conversations in Sacramento around prospective expansions or, or a few other kind of eviction securities that could be placed in location, as you might picture,, can provided the concern,.
we all share across the state that there possibly being, a flood of expulsions as these protections end, but that, that work today seems unclear what direction the state might take, if, if any type of at factor and also the guv'' s office has signified has actually made dedication that present defenses with sunset as they'' re presently intending end of March, having claimed that, the other inquiry I assume you asked was what various other work is.
underway on a local front, we have remained in.
normal conversations with Robert Bratner.
the supervisor of housing wellness for Santa region on establishing an extra official collaboration.
around proceeding as well as increasing local support programs that are in area, we located the location the most efficient giving legal academic and also mediation assistance to renters and find themselves in a setting, so in conversations with.
the area, they were bringing a proposal to.
the board of managers today to assign $500,000 factor effort.What we would
such as to.
do, assuming they approve that proposals at a conference in the future for a budget appropriation.
to add in the direction of that. Well, with the area focus.
being lawful mediation, most effective on the ground,.
that appears to be the instructions it'' s going as well as sounds like. Watsonville and Capital and also other partners. – Thanks, yep, I.
would certainly, there'' s a movement as well as I'' m not (indistinct) now, but seeing that some.
of these actions being obtaining in touch with our state leaders likewise just to get a feeling.
of what'' s taking place, might be really valuable. Thank you, thank you,.
council member Myers, council participant Terry Johnson.My inquiry
was simply dealt with today. Why time was additionally in concerns to funding. As well as I was asking yourself if board had already vote on that at this point, we.
would have that info, but I wear'' t recognize that, so but I value the regional method. Council member Cumming. They just hear, guidance,.
that the board of manager. Thank you for that, so clear up the lawyer can not legally establish expulsion. Proceed, that'' s my evaluation. As region council.
that were preempted from enacting an additionally.
expulsion moratoriat this. As well as so the source readily available.
we did obtain communication from community bridges that Santa Cruz, the number of applications for the real estate is neighborhood bridges,.
the lead company for handling the housing.
is procedure in the region, but the city of Santa Cruz,.
the variety of applications was 32 applicants with.
just 300 moneyed so far.And so, it seemed that the. following step would ' ve been an expansion to safeguard. those applicants as they wait on fundings speaking with state level, that disbursement is slow-moving. So what I ' m likewise hearing. is that the, that personnel is recommending local assistance systems to support those, the forms. of funds contributed to let ' s see, renter EDU legal'and renter lawful support, renter education. You see my notes below are there is that like kinda refuge or conflict resolution center? I know that Jessica DWI mentioned down payment program, housing. authority and action board funding are all those existing as well as legitimate sources. readily available assistance anyone that is dealing with potential.
Any kind of timeline on that, provided that we ' re nearing the end of the month?- Yeah,
some council members participants recall remember in November of 2019, the. I imply, I can ' t say that there'' s no way to do it, I indicate, what, what I offer the council.
' Reason I wear ' t think. Oh, I'' m sorry, I was going to sorry, Mayor, I didn'' t I, my hand, all right. Thank you, council member Myers, Just an inquiry for personnel, I was simply curious, I recognize the county has actually involved well,, a pair questions, I guess, Bonnie, I recognize that we were supporting as a lot as feasible rental assistance, so I just wanted to recognize a. little bit more concerning what we ' ve done and whether or not we have, we are still offer ability for individuals get aid, whether it ' s what I guess, what kinds of. Tiffany, so the nod, yes, so as well as we do know that cab has been functioning with the region seeking more assistance for their programs, so I, that solution one of concerns, yes, after that councils, I simply include to just comments,, we'' re not aware from. Any type of timeline on that, offered that we ' re nearing the end of the month?no, I value the explanation and I suggest, just '' reason I. have the schedule right before me, a few of.
the sources consist of the refuge, rural lawful the handbook for property owner safety.
down payment program, housing authority have and so on, so it'' s wonderful to know, we have community partners who are functioning with us, that sustain our residents in the suggestion, it doesn'' t consist of to have a budget appropriation or return with budget in the referral as that something that you'' re desiring much more quality and also instructions on taking a look at you, Matt, sorry.( laughs) I figured as much, many thanks for.
the question, council Watkin. Council can absolutely clarify.
that that is the instructions we were already working to recognize (indistinct) initiative. I would certainly likewise simply include that.
we have a conference tomorrow that foundation with our with.
Thank you, council Myers. (laughs) – Sorry, yeah, I would certainly be ready to, after you take it out to public remark, give that direction.
and feeling, make clear that. Great, thank you, so.
If, you will currently take this out to public comment.
have an interest in commenting on expiry of statewide.
admission moratorium, additional lawful aid.
and support for lessees influenced by COVID-19 raise.
Go ahead and unmute on your own, thank you. Welcome Mayor Brunner, I would such as to, my name is Barbara.
Meister, I'' m standing for Copa organization 23 member establishments across Monterey as well as Santa Cruz region and also a number of you have been meeting us over the last pair weeks as well as receiving our, our letters and emails.
update your interest to this impending situation, I do intend to offer time to Elizabeth Cortez who Copa leader and who can share.
with you the experiences she'' s had over the in 2014 and might also discuss her gain access to or inability to access a few of the.
sources you'' ve mentioned.So Elizabeth ' s phone number'is six hundred five one 4 one, see that and would you have the ability to unmute here.
and I'' ll use whatever equilibrium time she does? Barbara, I'' m not seeing that number.
Her name is with her. Elizabeth Mun, there we go.- Hi, great afternoon,. my name is( indistinct )and I ' m a member of Holy. Cross and also leader of, and I just speak you a little. bit about my experience with a few of the programs that you simply and also exactly how I'' ve been managing. Looking for aiding my.
experience being homeless and also other things that.
you have been chatting for the last 40 mins. And also first off, I desire.
to begin by stating that I was affected by.
COVID 19, really hard. Me and also my husband lost our jobs, my spouse shed 2 full time.
tasks, I shed my fulltime job. so afterwards we have a hard time, we.
had to invest throughout cost savings, afterwards, we also have to request for loans, personal lending as well as so I end.
up using for home rental, which took me a long, long time.I applied when the 2nd round started as well as I didn'' t speak with them. Therefore in November property owner obtained paid which'' s when he
additionally got. e-mails from his insurance as well as he determined that he.
wanted sell this home. We had to begin.
That'' s when I look for the resources, some of the sources you'' ve mentioned. They put on'' t assistance immigrants or individuals that just have a work authorization, that'' s why I additionally been.
in the front workplace discuss this program, I obtained a handout from neighborhood bridges stating that there was program. Therefore when I called and also.
stated this program, they state that they didn'' t even recognize what I was speaking about, that. that program didn ' t also exist or it wasn ' t legitimate anymore.
I put on'' t understand
if that. The various other thing is simply, simply browsing the building monitoring, the requirements that are out there, simply.
obtain an area like nine each. So everyone needs to be making, that each individual needs to.
certify by themselves. Making 3 times the rent, each individual has to have two work, 2 years of proof of work, which many of us wear'' t presently have, due to the fact that we lost our work.
When the pandemic hit, in. Paying 45 to $50 attributed, just a few of us don'' t also. have that amount of cash just to vacate like is method way too much. Elizabeth, that time has.
the timer has ringed.
– Thanks for sharing.
your experience as well as Barbara, thank you for allowing.
the time and speaking about that remark from Copa. Thank you. We have our next comment.
from Raymond Panino, Proceed. – And excellent evening council. Great evening council, great night, Mayor. Thanks for your time today. My name is Raymond Canino as well as I'' m the CEO of Neighborhood Bridges. I'' m hiring to ask that the council include some added activities onto the table and also possibly move on.
on a conversation that consists of letters of writing both.
Senator Laird'' s office, assembly member, stone. as well as RVIs in connection with the real estate program,. as well as a letter to the guv ' s workplace.
There is no reason we. all must be at ground the table scared of lessees possibly being at a chance and.
at a factor in which expulsions may happen when they had.
public trust fund and public rate of interest of attempting to utilize the state program to obtain the needed.
resources and also needs in order to pay rent and also stay current.This isn '
t just the.
renter as well as the property manager, or it'' s not simply an occupant ' s concern.
This is also a property owner. We really feel like arbitration is a means ahead to stop.
you take into consideration extra financing that helps sustain these sorts of programs like our eviction.
defense collaborative that was started, '' cause we saw the train about the hit cars and truck regarding a couple months ago, we actually wish that you remain to likewise consider other.
plan remedies due to the fact that re no matter how much money you put forward today, you'' re not gon na have as much a significant effect as you would certainly, if you changed your plans as well as search for various other sorts of ways to minimize unlawful detainers one way is to.
compose into the region court system to ask that they notify both celebrations before and.
an unlawful detainer about the possibilities.
to get totally free arbitration via one of our services.
or via contracting services that we'' re mosting likely to be,, really hoping to assist sustain family members in the, in the near future with the assistance of the county, so I actually wish that you additionally think about an extension of the halt in a method 90 to a post, I understand that it does not impact individuals that are influenced throughout the payment duration of March 31st, however.
honestly, the regulation is not meant to.
Thank you for your public comment. Our following, our next has.
considering that they were posted, it appears right before the.
I remind the remain at residence. Now the freedom to move.
Trashing property manager? If the state didn ' t send out payments, it didn'' t send out repayments, then that is barely any proprietors mistake, yet you were and will certainly damage. Liberty limited government with freedom, residential property legal rights, self reliance, personal.
comment, our next is Tanya
. Proceed as well as unmute.
My name is Tanya and I ' m the community bridges household. I simply desired to make clear that from an eviction. Thank you for your comment are there any other attendees that.
participant Myers as well as council participant Cumming, council member Myers, you have your hand up, sorry
concerning that.I ' ll go on and make a movement there to are you gon na get two? We just finished public comments
, so everyone ' s done there,. I would make a movement to direct mayor.
to engage with the area on the regional efforts. relating to, maintaining, hopefully, preserving individuals from being kicked out, specifically with investment, whatever frameworks. that area has together in terms of funding for. a few of solutions can make use of.
And also after that I would certainly include to that that we additionally potentially.
regards to March deadline as well as the house secret, the state funding that ' s existing.
Okay, so we have a movement. I ' ll 2nd that, fine, Council participant Cumming seconded and also council participant Myers, have anything else to add or, fine, so council member Cummings had your hand raised and then. I was gon na make that would give additional straight after we vote on this movement,.
I would simply ask for pleasant amendment, essentially among the things I ' d consisted of was in
regards to routing. whether that staff or the Mayor to compose letters to our representatives also prompting them to do. what ' s in their power. Take this up as an emergency. thing throughout their session to extend the eviction protections.So applications have been completed and funds have actually been distributed, so I put on ' t recognize if that.
would serve. Yet the concept, so the letter, include that right into communications state.
And also so I ' ll, I ' ll send out the. I assume we can just, we.
I assume the instructions we ' re hearing is that.
Does that make feeling From a, from a legal perspective, the the subtenant is managed the very same security as it has occupant rental fees straight'from the proprietor, so, oh, all right, I believe, but I believe it ' s it ' s included. Thank you, I believe that ' s where the legal education and learning and support and also,, needed as well as why that ' s requested a great deal of individuals put on ' t truly recognize or comprehend what civil liberties they have, council member Brown, sorry, I, my, my. Your hand is still up, I can place it down for now, but I ' m gon na, I ' m ready to make additional motion after we relocate on.
– Kind of I have. At same time. So let ' s see, we have a movement to route the city manager to participate in a regional.
expulsion security initiative with the region.
and other jurisdictions relating to avoiding. people from being evict. Restore those efforts Demand from state lawmakers as soon as
feasible on initiatives relevant March 31st pleasant. modification comings, guide the Mayor, create a. letter to setting up participant stone and also laed expressing. the requirement to extend the COVID 19
expulsion. area for people who have applied
for. state services as well as advised them to do what remains in their power to urge the state assembly and also. Us senate up as an emergency item during session and also.
eviction securities till the have been and also.
This is the, for those that used, all right, Is the manufacturer of the movement 'open to that friendly modification council participant Myers, alright as well as we have a roll telephone call vote for Johnson.- Aye. Looks iced up.
– Aye.- Aye.- Aye.- That motion passes stick. in favor one.( indistinct) Okay, council participant Cummings, thanks. I, one point I ' d want say is that this is a major government failure of individuals during one of their times of best. requirement, a lot of these area participants that
. have requested this assistance to follow the guidelines set by the state and also our local neighborhood to aid safeguard them throughout a time when our federal government told them not to work, remain at home'with greater great,. the area, these individuals have gone with the process to deal with their property managers and also our waiting payment, the federal governments.
The first component of the activity would be bullets one and also three direct personnel to bring back statute. COVID 19 rental help as well as have actually not yet gotten their help honorable for the initial meeting in April, that will certainly be direct to act to April 1st, 2022, bring back an. 19 risk rental support to discover their choices, to lower, reduce psychological anxiety and also then I put on ' t know if I can make few movements in activity, however the various other part of the movement would be to guide Mayor to create.
a letter region courts slash area attorney ' s. workplace and judges advise and also advertise arbitration services before submitting unlawful detainer, the objective of solving conflicts. as well as avoiding expulsion.- That was the center bullet?- Yeah, that was simply the second bullet.
The center one that I check out Tony then, so Tony, I guess the question is this would certainly be 2, possibly two separate activities, otherwise I understand we can ' t have even more than 3 motions on the floor, I would certainly think that you ' re bullet number 3 folded right into the initial bullet,'yeah, that was the, that was the intent That ' s looks like one movement, the second activity be to direct the Mayor to create a letter, I would certainly suggest that that you attend to the letter if that ' s the direction of the advise, the administering court of the superior court as well as omit. the district attorney ' s office, who has actually. no involvement whatsoever in the feature of the DA ' s workplaces to impose criminal condition, civil unlock. If we could have that language upgraded then it sounded like the 3rd. bullet can simply go the– I have a question for, Tony'( indistinct )the eviction notification period from 3 days, days, I, my understanding is that. we were pre from that.In my point of view, yes, I would claim that the very same evaluation. would relate to emergency securities for individuals. that have pending applications under the real estate program. I ' m, I put on ' t assume I require to reiterate my guidance on that, I think council participant upcomings understands it. which ' s the instructions of the council will bring that statute.
Does that make feeling From a, from a lawful viewpoint, the the subtenant is paid for the very same defense as it has tenant rents straight'from the proprietor, so, oh, okay, I think, yet I think it ' s it ' s consisted of. Thank you, I believe that ' s where the legal education and learning and also support as well as,, essential as well as why that ' s asked for a lot of people wear ' t actually recognize or recognize what rights they have, council member Brown, sorry, I, my, my. Okay, Let ' s, let ' s take with this motion. The middle one that I review Tony then, so Tony, I presume the concern is this would be two, potentially 2 different movements, if not I know we can ' t have even more than three activities on the flooring, I would certainly think that you ' re bullet number 3 folded up into the first bullet,'yeah, that was the, that was the intent That ' s appears like one movement, the 2nd activity be to guide the Mayor to write a letter, I would certainly suggest that that you deal with the letter if that ' s the direction of the advice, the administering court of the exceptional court and leave out. I ' m, I put on ' t assume I need to state my guidance on that, I assume council member upcomings recognizes it.Go ahead as well as second that, so I have one more concern, we have a, a very first by an activity by council participant Cumings as well as a 2nd council participant Brown, what would certainly be the timeline for this
emergency regulation alternative? I review the activity as guiding that to be brought at the
initially conference in April, and also after that it would certainly be made
retroactive to April 1st.
It really, it says on or before the first conference in April. If the special meeting was held then prior to April 1st, that could
be, it can come after that also, or it would come with first meeting in April and be retroactively, except for April 1st and also then the concept would be
that we would restore thing, identify whether or not
an extension or sundown would be required of that
An upgrade.
– Yeah, thanks Mayor.
I ' ll begin my comments by simply stating, I assume we all shared our, that go through the influences of this as well as I an actually offered that we ' re partnering with the region and also area to offer what we'can at the neighborhood level that are affected. and I assume that coming from that place. I believe for me, in terms Of what we ' ve listened to, our city lawyer as
the area council, that the threat linked with this the initial bullet in direction isn ' t always, I think, worth what I think we can do in('indistinct). And recognizing that LA is now connected up in a suit in relation to this,
so for me, I assume and also for knowing we had 2 additional product and this is not the, that I believe I suggest that we divided the movement in and after that take the take on the first bullet. And also is the activity maker open to that? The intent was the initial activity was to have it be two different movements.
Allow ' s, yeah, Mayor, I
I ' m sorry, I left my hand up I ' m I'donPut on' t need demand else.
statute for emergency situation embrace, provide eviction defenses for individuals COVID leasing have not yet obtained on or prior to the very first meeting in April, that would certainly be retroactive initial and also revive a thing to determine
(indistinct) – No. – Aye. – Aye, and I just wan na.
apologize my electronic camera off, I keep obtaining went down therefore I'' m trying to remain in the meeting. (laughs) Thank you. – [Clerk] Myer. -Aye.- No. I ' m sorry, I ' m sorry that we were electing on the second one. That my ballot is a no, that was a no.- No. Okay, that movement does not pass. 5 no and also yeah and after that the next motion, the straight the Mayor to compose a letter to
region court for in fact. there was language that straight Mayor to create a letter courts of the county court advertise and suggest services before an.
unlawful retainer goal of settling, staying clear of eviction, we have a function call vote, could.
I recommend one small edit? – Yes.
– Would certainly be to compose a letter.
to the administering court of the area court. One judge council member Cummings are you all right with that language? Okay as well as we have a roll call vote. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – Aye. – That movement passes unanimously. Okay, I'' d likewise question if city personnel as well as there was a caller that made a remark concerning programs and also I ask yourself if any kind of council participant could make or making an activity or we can direct staff to.
take a look at the efficiency as well as legitimacy of the existing programs that are the resources and also assistance programs that remain in place as well as to make certain they'' re functioning as excellent, the Mayor heater in response to that the instructions we'' ve obtained council to as well as involve in this regional collaboration will certainly be component of that discussion with all of our companions that recognize most reliable areas of investment, so I would suggest that that'' s developed into the impression we'' ve received.Course council wants clarify, that ' s our intent, I intended to make certain and also call that out if something is not offered or not functioning see to it that. staff are( indistinct).
Council participant Cummings, I was gon na make that activity ' cause since you asked, make a movement, so (laughs), '' cause I put on ' t require the aid on my hands, thank you, council member Cummings, alright, so, I eagerly anticipate composing. these letters and to an update from city staff after tomorrow'' s conference as well as eagerly anticipating some suggestions of funding quantities that we with county 500,000, these citizens for, so we continued, sure, okay, so currently we will,, go on, I think we are at the time of a closed session item.
as well as this is conference with legal guidance, existing city of Santa Cruz, santa Cruz, there, any kind of members of the general public that would.
like on the close session thing or utilize raise your.
hand by dialing star 9 on your phone or selecting raise hand in the webinar objectives of your, when it is your time to, you will.
listen to an announcement that you have been unmuted, the timer will certainly after that be established to hang up.
when you'' ve talked about your item as well as there any participants that wish to talk about this shut inquiry on the schedule today, None, I will bring it.
Is the city clerk prepared? Yes. And also welcome to 3:00 p.m. session of the March 22nd 2022 meeting of the.
Santa Cruz city council, I wish to ask the clerk roll. – [Staff] Thanks, Mayor. Council member Terry Johnson. – Existing. – [Staff] Stone. – Existing. – [Staff] Cumming. – Here. – [Staff] Brown. – Right here. – [Staff] Myers. Vice Mayor Watkin. – Here. – And Mayor Brunner. – Present. So, for participants of the.
public who are streaming this conference, if you.
wish to call in during dental communications.
now is the time to hire guidelines would certainly be on your screen. Oral interactions is a possibility for participants of the area.
plus on things that are not detailed on today'' s program, you are interested in attending to.
the council, elevate your hand either by dialing vehicle nine on your phone or picking elevate hand the webinar on your case,.
you'' ll have 3 mins. Bear in mind that this is the time for council to speak with the public,.
we are unable to involve in dialogue with each.
participant of the public, however when we are able, we will.
address any type of questions elevated after oral.And so I will take it. bent on our attendees, I see one hand increased the. name, I am enjoying you, yes. Hello there, without particular.
referral to any schedule things, I would typically advise you again, that workers have an equivalent, right? Not to join unions and also
. any one sided assistance for union formation coming.
from you is breaking the equivalent civil liberties of those who do not wish to join and you ought to constantly after that avoid of the exclusive.
service labor relations regarding union development, I would likewise advise you that the cash alloted into the water department'' s budget plan, all come from individuals of water delivery and also likewise, no cash ought to be.
reapportioned out of the water budget plan for any kind of other objective than a distribution of water, water, budget revenue used for any kind of other function in supplying water is a total abuse of your monopoly water energy placement,.
It is a covert pack as well as it needs a complete.
When considering such it is dishonest and, quit.
violent to do otherwise.Malcolm X was a Marxist that thought fairly strongly in terrible revenge as a means to an end, this as well as.
advocating the total devastation of the criminal justice system was the drive of Black.
Lives Matter activity, nearly from the inception.
managing to attain ultimately an overall huge boost in criminal offense and also physical violence,.
consisting of large boosts in black murders that the self-admittedly Marx, this company is associated with a missing 60 million.
contribution personnel that Monica can approve of the BLM was billed for 18 matters of scams just days earlier and the BLM remains to cause the.
damages by its anarchist advocates, the sick accepted BLM billboard was vandalized, however it.
is additionally practically entirely worn, now, no matter the result of compensation for that vandalism should not allow it to be painted as it is also a glorification.
sign of that violent Marist, anarchist and illegal nationwide company of the very same name, the severely needs a defunding itself and also possibly some various other remembrance.
of George Floyd can be thought about without.
the BLM preconception affixed to it and not before city hall, but possibly over by the police station, which would certainly be better, that else, if anybody, by now requires a remembrance of the lessons of excessive cops pressure you additionally need to badly require to quit spitting up the federal government COVID.
story as an example, by limitless of emergency expansions and to get educated regarding.
the harms COVID plan has '' caused including lockdowns the harm of coercively applied.
requireds indiscriminately related to those with previously infected superior resistance, to be compelled to accept the dangers of mRNA adverse effects or on close to no risk kids, the overall lack of knowledge displayed toward the age.
I would like to call a break till the next product, yes, we have actually not had a break. We'' re returning from. Okay, next up on our council.
schedule is product number 31, yearly real estate component and also.
basic strategy development record for members of the.
public that are streaming this meeting, if this is an item you desire to talk about currently is the time to call using the directions.
on your display, order will be a presentation.
of the thing by staff followed by concerns from guidance, you will then take public.
remark and after that go back to guidance for deliberation as well as action.So at this time I
will currently hand it over to, it appears like we.
have our Kathryn Donovan, elderly organizer and also Matt, (indistinct) – Thanks. Evening council and Mayor Brunner. Allow me just bring up my PowerPoint. So our presentation.
tonight is for our basic and also housing element annual.
reports for in 2014. Oops. You can see the screen, but I can'' t appear to ahead it to you,( indistinct) display sharing, – [Staff] Yeah, I can'' t
see.- Okay, allow quit sharing. Technical difficulty. It worked out. I can begin speaking to this. while we'' re arriving.
-Okay, go ahead. -Following slide please.
Okay, so these by the. state, they ' re submitted to the real estate and also neighborhood. development division as well as the'individual ' s office. of search and planning. One gets on the basic plan as well as the progression we'' ve made in the direction of carrying out the general plan that report has no particular format demands.
and also is much more a basic record on changes to zoning general.
strategy changes interagency participation, infield growth and significant job development, In.
contrast, the housing component report has a complex as well as really lengthy Excel spread sheet that is offered by the state that specific jurisdictions fill in which record was relatively very easy till regarding 2018.
when new requirements entered into play and after that.
added brand-new requirements were included in 2014.
which has made this record far more intricate,.
It likewise offers us some actually outstanding information, these reports used to only be required of non-charter cities,.
They'' re now needed of all cities and also they likewise if we do not submit these records, we lose out on a great deal of state give funding.
much of which we actually use.So it'' s really crucial for us. And the process for the.
Records is that we offer them to the city council council accepts the records and also rec that we send them to HCD and also OPR and also the deadline for sending the reports is a.
slide and also following slide. This first, first area is on the, general strategy record and this is just a picture of some.
of the significant jobs that we'' ve serviced or are reporting updates for, we'' ve obtained the terminal north Jesse road task,.
the city arts recuperation layout, or cards program, an update on the rail route as well as the go Santa Cruz task. an update on our purpose requirements function and also on the resistant message work and the one 30 facility street job upgraded on environment action strategy and also on the road sharp program and after that the last picture is four 15 national bridges next slide please. The housing component.
report, this is a report on exactly how the city is conference.
its regional real estate needs for RHNA, I'' m certain we '
ve been. with this lots of times, however the RHNA is comes down from the state to the neighborhood government agencies.Ours is, am bag and also there ' s a reporting an AE reporting duration. this year, It ' s this cycle it'' s nine years since they are, changing the cycle to.
match the transportation cycle and our overall RHNA task for this 5th cycle is 747 devices. Large enjoyment this past.
year they'' ve been working on the overalls for the.
6th cycle and also statewide, those numbers have actually risen four times, that'' s the average statewide number. The most recent draft number we'' ve seen. The total amount is 2,736 devices for the city of Santa Cruz, so it'' s nearly five times the dimension of our following slide. And also this table highlights.
where we go to meeting RHNA in this duration, so we have 2 years left with 2022 and 2023.
as well as we have actually surpassed all of our real estate requires except in the very reduced revenue classification, this year we had one really.
huge 205 system job that had no reduced income devices because they had give residential or commercial property that adjoined our Pacific station job in lieu of giving the affordable real estate units.So can obtain a whole lot much more systems by acquiring that home, but it implies that we put on ' t see multitude of budget-friendly systems for this year. Next slide. And this, I was attempting to. provide you sort of a summary of
what the record is informing us therefore this is a general. housekeeping task. We had 709 preparation applications submitted that consists of not just application, however developing applications that did not need planning authorization which a lot of no more. need a planning license.
So, so they remained in. that category also after that for preparation, allows authorized had an overall of 445 structure licenses issued the 11 and building permits last 78 and also as you can see in the income groups, as you go throughout in the planning.
applications, submitted preparation applications we'' re doing actually well on the very reduced revenue tasks. As well as we'' re additionally doing well on, on reduced end, since we'' re, we ' ve satisfied our moderate and over moderate, we wear'' t even need to consider those, yet it'' s fascinating to see just the overall numbers and I have to inform you these, these are not additive, some projects sent their applications as well as exactly how their applications
. accepted or had their applications approved.
and also gotten building permits, so there'' s some overlap here, so you can'' t simply count those tombs totals.Next slide.
In our, when we presented our report in 2014, there was a whole lot of concerns regarding how we.
calculated the prices that rents out for the ADUs as well as back then we had actually been utilizing a survey that was done during the procedure of upgrading our ADU statute, so the survey had actually developed to obtain details for.
the, or collaborates, not necessarily to use.
for the annual report.So this year we prepared a brand-new survey that was especially obtain. the sort of details
that we need for this report as well as the housing division in ED, the real estate department in.
the economic advancement, department sends yearly.
reporting letters to ADU owners as well as piggy back on their letters as well as sent a link to the survey as well as also enabled individuals to publish out the study and also submit a paper copy and the outcomes of that survey revealed that our leas both the mean and the tool rents were well below the.
HCD low income rental fee restrictions. We were able to use to categorize the ADUs that had.
structure allows this year as low revenue units, the various other intriguing that we found from the ADU survey was.
that a big tier of devices, almost as many units as are.
being leased to (indistinct) of their houses are.
being made use of by members, member of the family, or good friends.
at low or no rents.So although those rental fees are not reflected in this populace, it. ways there ' s one more, I think it was 47 devices out.
there that are primarily being rented out because either, either rent charge or at substantially reduced rent and also there were additionally a number I think it was around, it was less than more than 5 units that were reported as being utilized for 5 loved ones or as visitor housing, so they would certainly come for weekends yet not spend for it like, like an Airbnb or something, following slide. In addition to the real estate.
that was hectic in the record, there are some projects that
. were accepted in one group or applied in one classification.
in 2020 and also did not advance to the next group in 2021.
As well as then there ' s two other. And they sent their application in February of this year,. They weren ' t included in
that last report recordAnd also
I ' m sorry, I ' m sorry that we were voting on the second one. Okay, I'' d also wonder if city team and there was a customer who made a remark concerning programs and I wonder if any kind of council participant could make or making a motion or we can direct team to.
We'' re returning from. The latest draft number we'' ve seen. As well as we'' re likewise doing well on, on reduced end, because we'' re, we ' ve satisfied our moderate as well as above moderate, we wear'' t also require to look at those, however it'' s intriguing to see just the total numbers and I have to inform you these, these are not additive, some projects submitted their applications and exactly how their applications
.If we have fulfilled our above moderate photos, however not our
lower or really low, after that we'' re in the placement that we'' re in now where if tasks are submitted with 50% or more of reduced earnings devices, anything for 80% AMI or much less, after that they are qualified for that enhancing process.If we have actually not met
our over modest goals, or if, obviously share then would be subject SB35 for tasks that as a state regulation checks out that are at 10 %of are
offering 10% lower in for city'' s. inclusionary demand, whichever is better and also considering that practically tasks are called for.
to satisfy the inclusionary need, if we do not fulfill the above moderate total amounts by the midyear of our following cycle all tasks would have to go via this improve procedure and also this table below programs the difference between the 6th cycle, which gets on the top and the fifth cycle, which is the reduced cycle, which is the one we'' re in now, so this cycle
, we constructing. 180, really reduced income units as well as following cycle, we require to provide 857 and also the other numbers.
Previous housing elements we ' ve shared in house, yet there are extra requirements currently that( indistinct) we simply, we wear ' t have the staff as well as we.'we will be looking for an expert to aid us with that, the various other point we must be mindful of is that ' reason numbers for on this 6th cycle RHNA are so high. We may need to rezone homes in order to demonstrate that there are enough, properly zoned properties to satisfy our RHNA, it ' s feasible that mix of SB9, which permits second systems on a lot of single family members parcels and our midtown development job, which is most likely to broaden the enabled housing in the midtown.
– Thanks for that. discussion, Kathryn, allowed ' s see are any type of council participants you have any kind of council member Brown, thank you for the presentation, thanks for every one of your. work, make understands the very tough. reporting demands and give us with really clear review.
I have a number of concerns associated to section as well as I value explanation with the fly that you offered us in exactly how you made that resolution as well as I am recalling that in the discussion we had concerning LA can ' t bear in mind was that 2 years, 3 years earlier currently where EDS finished up being placed in the moderate revenue category as an outcome of that years survey that it, it felt like there was within that there was type of pretty broad LA amongst the rental fees bill for those and also so and the survey inquiries that you offered us that shared attached to schedule package were truly interesting.And I ' m just questioning. if there ' s a possibility of council members, unsure if public getting more details at a, at an extra granular degree, since you just look at well for a, a great deal of the locations, however when you simply check out the fads as well as the means that ' s computed both the meat and also typical rent yes. Reduced income, but that low revenue classification. However it doesn ' t actually tell. us the amount of are really, rented at reduced revenue level, It doesn ' t tell us the amount of units rental fee, for instance, listed below or above, to ensure that ' s the kind of info that I assume had a better understanding of the. character of that'market.And it ' s simply hard based upon what I understand and also again, it ' s unscientific it ' s difficult to think based on what
I understand buddies pay when ADU is. that, they ' re actually revenue.'Like it'just feel it doesn ' t concerning it, that simply doesn ' t seem like'. it matches the experience, so I presume that ' s why the. study data may be handy or, yeah, well, I have to claim the very first point that'I discovered truly shocking is what is taken into consideration reduced earnings leas, I suggest, to me, those are not reduced income rental fees, they ' re fairly high and also. that ' s because it ' s based upon the average earnings as well as our mean earnings is quite high right here. I think I can let me check lawfully whether I can share the outcomes of the private studies with you, and also if there ' s no issue with that said, I can send you the spread sheet. It ' s pretty intriguing. I didn ' t get as a lot, I imply, we obtained'79 actions, however we probably obtained less than 40 of them included the rents, so it wasn ' t as helpful as it could have.- I recognize that it was not necessarily stand for, however it was. and also yeah, anonymized', if that word always tripped me up
, without the determining– Thanks Council participant Brown, that was really one. of my concerns too around the ADU, numerous response. That was extremely useful to learn. If, and also I was interested.
it was for member of the family that low or free lease, that component I didn ' t include at all, because I, that I just altered whatever,. so it personally, I believe yes, have all those devices that are being utilized either reduced or totally free revenue, yet that isn ' t agent of what somebody who ' s not. relevant to someone with an ADU is gon na pay, so I, they were not those were not included. Since I would assume that.
I think it ' s a one mean a target of the low income target of a hundred just. I ' m simply trying to comprehend restrictions versus non-ED, it looks like 101 are deed limited, is that, that are those units that are gon na go offline or? Due to the fact that you understand that right now, it might be that it ' s in.
have to do to please HCD as well as the other is what ' s occurring there on the ground and if it.
were not a concern of HCD, wasn ' t, we didn ' t need to load a RHNA, I wouldn ' t count those ADUs in all, I wouldn ' t matter anything,. that ' s not de-restricted
' reason there ' s absolutely nothing.
holding it at that rental fee, yet because we do have RHNA.
and HCD does limited systems and they wear'' t require us them.I go on and also capitalize on that. That'' s not to state that ' s. refraining everything we can to obtain as many need limited, low end devices as we can as well as I'' m, I'have to say, I ' m delighted at what ' s going on now, we have, we have a lot budget-friendly housing in the pipe,.
It'' s actually a mentioning I just wish I could declare it to make sure that we would certainly obtain equally as 123 units we require and after that the remainder of on the next cycle, they won'' t allow us conserve the following cycle, so we just have to that the timing is right. Appreciate that solution, thank you, thanks exist any kind of other council member inquiries before I take it bent on public? Okay, so at this time I will certainly take it out to public comment, if you were fascinating talking about product.
number 31 annual housing component as well as general progression report, elevate your by dialing celebrity nine on your phone or, or picking Raise.
No hands increased. Member Cumming as well as vice Mayor Watkin, I ' ll step to accept personnel report and really I just mention that approve component lem me claim that I approved. The golden state division of housing create.
Thank you,( indistinct ). -I ' ll second that. -We have a movement by. council participant Cummings as well as a 2nd by vice mayor Watkin. More comment, or else. we ' ll a roll call ballot and we have a roll call vote'.( indistinct) -Aye.- Aye. -Aye. -[ Clerk] Brown. – Aye. – Aye. -[ Staff] Mayor Watkin. -Aye. – [Staff] Mayor Brunner. – Aye. Activity passed with one voice. Thank you a lot for signing up with.
us, Katherine Donovan, and for your details progress. Okay, following step on our.
agenda is product number 32, walkway fending regulation.
program and also training course demand for members of the general public portioning this meeting, if this thing is one you wish to talk about currently is the moment in the guidelines on your order will be a presentation of the item by adhered to by counsel questions and after that.
we will take public remark (indistinct) So right now I will turn over to staff discussion and also it appears like we have Elizabeth.
Smith, welcome Elizabeth.Thank you so much for your Bruner. We are here tonite to speak concerning pathway vending, I have a presentation that I ' ll share we can begin. Thanks for having us to chat. about this actually crucial problem
for the city, now, especially as we ' re moving right into the extra into the busier traveler periods we are below to discuss a problem that is pressing. first I wan na recognize Sarah da on who recently left the city has actually been servicing this problem. over the previous numerous months and also I grabbed the Baton as well as I ' m below
with you today,. in addition to my associates who I also wan na. recognize in divisions throughout the city the city city attorney ' s office, the preparation as well as. area advancement department works and. leisure, the authorities department and also public works are the depart who are really working on this problem throughout the city as we bring it tonite. so I ' ll start with some background of how we got where we are today, we ' re here as a result of the regulation SB9-46 and that was passed in 2018 as well as it claims, it was actually concentrated on entrepreneurship as well as making sure that low revenue immigrant business owners can develop businesses as well as make a living with street vending.And so the legislation was truly concentrated on making it. much easier for those folks to do that work, it defines what cities can do as well as what they can ' t do, so it says database at the highest level, we could regulate vending, sidewalk finishing based. on public health and wellness safety and well-being concerns and also so you ' ll see those things attended to, as we chat via the ordinance. with you this evening it states that we can ' t control based on viewed financial competition for not suching as that a supplier is out on the road in front of an organization which we are'there are extremely places where we can do full vending restrictions and so it makes produces challenging ordinance therefore we invite you to come on the sidewalk, venting trip with us as we undergo every one of the elements that we ' re offering this evening.Just a little get to obtain a little bit extra granular, we are generally limited to the manner ins which we can control are based upon time, way as well as area. So how is a person vending? When are they vending? Where are they vending? And making certain that we are meaning out what those time area and. way limitations are. We can ' t control certain location or making individuals ask approval. from another business or in public parks or a number of vendors, unless it really routes.
straight relates back to that welfare, safety and wellness. So you ' ll hear that over. and also over once again tonight, wellness security as well as fair as the core aspect of just how we constructed the order. Simply a little bit of background on vending and also Santa Cruz. we ' ve had two locations where. we'' ve had a considerable pathway vending in the city, in the past and as we think. concerning the pre SB9-46 time as well as the post SB9-46 time Pacific avenue, there is vending on Pacific avenue today, it is not regulated.It is– oh, froze up right here, yes. Got you ' re back. Okay, excellent, sorry regarding that in the … Before SB9-46, we had permitted. spaces on Pacific method, we had a 4 hr time limit, and also it was an initial come. Solution system. So you'had folks lining. approximately obtain the rooms that were there, we ' ve had a couple of pilot programs on, on beach street, one in 2019 where we had permitted spaces and also those were additionally. first precede offer as well as after that most recently. in the summer season'of 2021, we designated areas on. the perfect deck to permit street vending and we ' re gon na … As well as Tony, Elliot ' s gon na talk. about kind of the experience that we
had in the summer season of 2021 next, yet I simply wan na say,.
like every one of these rubrics had problems. And what we are wishing to do.
tonight is to advance some clear laws to make sure that people that wish to vend and also the city folks
that are implementing the regulation,. have a clear understanding and also a clear concentrate on this is just how we as a city or citywide, we. are handling the issue.So I ' m gon na turn it over to per supervisor, Tony Elliot and he '
s gon na talk us through what we experienced last summer season.- Right, thanks, Elizabeth and also yes, excellent afternoon or great evening,
council members value the opportunity to speak concerning this with you.'all as well as value your involvement in this, I recognize. we did our Mayor ' s Cumming tidy up program last year,. so I recognize you were all really, extremely involved hands. on, down on the beach are conscious of a great deal of these.
issues from last summer.But I ' ll briefly cover some.
of the issues that we deal with as well as truly, type of speaking.
On behalf of a few various departments right here. absolutely from the parks as well as leisure standpoint. and the Dock as well as coastline staff including a few of our temporaries seasonal team and our genuine boots on the ground staff job throughout.
the was last summertime. Next slide please.
All right, so in terms of programs last year, so what did we
do? Last year we attempted a new technique, we had a lottery game system. We had unsafe road conditions and
this in the next item product.
In terms of the police department, PD was doing nightly. patrol look at the coastline and beach road. They had at least 2 CSOs. existing, I believe even more than that lean on Lieutenant CROs that,. yet CSOs provide all
day, two officers on overtime. every weekend break PD was working straight with the area.
Ecological health and wellness department.I ' ll talk to that on the complying with slide, but a great deal of control, parking enforcement, parks and rec. Faced last summer? Next slide.
one, this belongs to area environmental.
health and wellness as well as I know that area environmental health. spent over$ 300,000 last year in staffing to be onsite relevant. to a few of the food vending on, so they were available. to get rid of risky and also unpermitted suppliers keep this 12
hr daily visibility this truly the 2nd half summer back then they scaled back seven hours on weekdays, 12 hours on the weekends compounded 17 food card and also as you see on the screen right here in fact about almost
350,000 in workers expenditures from. region ecological health and wellness. The influences were considerable. And as we ' ve functioned via
this, both the discussion, however this.
thing for the council to take into consideration, we ' ve truly tried to focus on what is the issue,. what is the issue that we ' re attempting to solve? And I think basically that problem is based in public safety. individuals getting pressed into the street, a. result of the congestion.It ' s an actually, actually active location, a whole lot happening with bikes, pedestrians, train preferred, very busy location and after that undoubtedly ecological effects also and so what we ' re trying to do right here is search for undaunted to resolve those'those core concerns encountering. Thank you and with that, I
will will certainly it off the next speaker, thank you.- Good night, I see councilman. Stone has her hand up, I didn ' t understand, are we. gon na wait up until completion of the questions or
,.'all right, we ' ll await that.Okay, well, good night,. I ' m really pleased to be here with you to speak about the. draft pathway in the ordinance. Let ' s obtain into it', following slide please.
Previous housing elements we ' ve shared in house, yet there are added needs now that( indistinct) we just, we don ' t have the team and also we. I have a pair of concerns connected to section and also I value description with the fly that you gave us in just how you made that decision as well as I am remembering that in the conversation we had about LA can ' t bear in mind was that two years, three years ago now where EDS finished up being placed in the moderate earnings group as an outcome of that years survey that it, it seemed like there was within that there was kind of rather wide LA amongst the rents bill for those and so as well as the survey questions that you offered us that shared connected to agenda packet were actually interesting.And I ' m simply questioning. It personally, I think of course, have all those devices that are being made use of either free or low income, however that isn ' t rep of what somebody who ' s not. I ' ll begin with some background of how we obtained where we are today, we ' re right here due to the fact that of the regulation SB9-46 as well as that was passed in 2018 and also it says, it was truly focused on entrepreneurship and making certain that reduced revenue immigrant entrepreneurs can construct businesses as well as make a living via street vending.And so the legislation was really focused on making it. Got you ' re back.so prior to I study the details, it'' s essential to just obtain as, or like vocabulary principles down and these concepts come from SB9-46, one idea is that of the fixed vendor, that'' s someone that airs vent from a repaired location, a roaming supplier is somebody who relocates from
Next slide, please.
This is another language straight from SB9-46.
So on the community battle this was location that was very important to the parks leisure division that the there ' s just not a great deal of space out there'to speak let alone that kind of business therefore those, it was very important to the parks department that that restriction be consisted of, also within the portion of the main beach over which the city has leisure, the scenario in Key beach is a bit complicated.Part of Main coastline is not practically owned by the city, however is owned by the seaside come and also the city has an entertainment easement only
over it and per this easement that is not permitted to allow vending for this 1930s judgment and that would be vending by both individuals that would traditionally consider us a walk vendors. And additionally, that ' s also kind of what keeps the side company from sending from selling in that location. That was essential to consist of as well on the B road professional'deck and also an additional location where personnel really felt that it just obtained incredibly, super congested and there truly is not a great deal of area to be able to involve sales.And then additionally simply on a bike path street consisting of within on-street garage a driveway or a public car park. these are simply clarifications and also SB9-46 truly talked regarding vending from a walkway, yet we believed that it was essential to additionally consist of,, that are likewise contained within within various other cities( indistinct) place, alright. And then it was as well as after that the the proposal below is essentially developed that in the summertime season, implying it rule via October that there would be no fixed or roaming vending loud on the B street pathway, It just obtains really crowded, there ' s not a lot of room that Okay, enforcement the ordinance con administrative in system, which is called for by SB9-46, much this section is, 5.82110 as well as a whole lot of this is taken basically precisely from SB9-46 as well as there ' s additionally as needed by SB9-46, there ' s a built a determination that is consider by the personnel planner, right? Failing to abide, this was a major concern that team had there'was a major worry that we creating these citations folks wouldn ' t pay the citation, or they might obtain a capability, a pay resolution that would certainly lower them to incredibly low amount and also that the citations themselves wouldn ' t be reliable to complete what is laid out to be accomplished.So we made a few tweaks to attempt to resolve that, one is we defined that management citations can be released on this same
day. Long that hr has broke down administrative. Once more, the concern right here was that some individuals would literally simply take the citation as well as possibly they meant to take, possibly they didn ' t as well as they would certainly just take it as a price company as well as they would certainly not, to ensure that was one arrangement that we included in address that we also included a restricted
empowerment section to be able to address the failure to conform too, this is something that has actually been done in Santa Monica and San Diego likewise simply usually, or that consists of empowerment area, we tried to make it restricted to ensure that it ' s really just individuals that make use of to relocate their things when they ' re asking go, yet we ' ve got that and we believe that it will be efficient in order to really achieve conformity, all right and after that I ' m virtually done, however as we were undergoing the regulation day something showed up that as well as we resembled, oh, perhaps this must be cleared up, so I assumed we would add it right into the presentation as the last slide, we
were contemplating the parks vending permit and also it was,'I think it was most of our
understanding that a parks vending license would be required for any type of vending that would be allowed on road on the walkway there, simply since that pathway is really a part of the park, there are benches, there are, individuals are watching beach ball, it ' s truly the entrance to the park as well as so we do really feel that it ' s vital to have the park spending license requirement for that as well, however it wasn ' t extremely clear in exactly how the regulation was drafted that that would certainly be required.So we would certainly suggest that you add this underlying language below, which is to specify that the park spending would certainly be'needed for pathway
vendors who wish to operate the City Park coastline or other center within the territory of the parks recreation division, consisting of that portion of the coastline street
walkway run by the parks recreation division. So that ' s simply to make clear what our understanding was which would certainly be our recommend. I think that ' s my whole discussion
.- Thank you.- I ' m gon na walk you with simply the execution of the statute. The statute itself and making sure that it audio and also clear is the initial component. And then'exactly how we roll it out is going to be crucial to the success for both suppliers and also the city team that are billed with handling the application of the regulation.'You know we ' re really based in dealing with the threats, all of the regulation as well as then how we ' ll be implementing our concentrate on public wellness and safety, shielding the natural surroundings, making certain that we are utilizing our fiscal resources properly as well as that we are serving these varied populations that we know are engaged sidewalk maintaining and vending with
the spirit of SB9-46 as we roll this regulation out, so to get grounded in what individuals needed, we did a great deal of outreach as well as a great deal of engagement, Sarah, prior to she left.And after that I grabbed the baton, as I stated. And also did some extra in the recentlies prior to we brought this statute and also presentation to you this evening we chatted with walkway vendors, chatted with beach services as well as beach area organizations as well as midtown businesses, area based companies that are offering especially the the Latino populations in Santa Cruz. We chatted to our chosen officials last year when we remained in the midst of our 2021. All of the issues that we were having in 2021, some of our state elects and neighborhood elects obtained involved. And so we ensured to obtain them in the loophole.
The went out to city to employees as well as really ask their point of views about exactly how we should be applying this ordinance.
That we ' re making certain that our blocks and
mortar businesses organizations not poorly badly influenced the ordinance.And then after that compliance easierSimpler I think assume '
s complicated. It will certainly explain the
intended time manner way place location vending on the permitLicense Making sure that we ' re.
issuance and also monitoring, is that we ' re offering it.
in English'and also in Spanish. We ' re education and learning and outreach. we ' ll make use of the moment, presuming.
Between now and when
the if we obtain your blessing on the ordinance this night. statute goes into result to start interacting'with people in the primary vending locations producing those program products,.
bilingual program materials. Deal with some outbound.
vendor communications.
I sort of walked and.
How are we, how do they interact with communications and. We believed this was. The team came with each other.
Exactly how are we making sure that people understand what they need to do? And exactly how do we additionally frontload. We have to be concentrated.
on, on that actions.
We have a map, these are.
the existing areas on Pacific avenue that are.
the demarcated vending areas and as you can see, there ' s plenty of up and also down Pacific
opportunity. And these are the addresses. as a part of the education and learning we ' ll be working to. truly, make these maps conveniently available and also as well as.
make all of the products were for your'factor to consider today.We sort of got some more reduced technology versions to check out and afterwards if we consider beach street, simply, I intended to mention kind of where those restrictions that we discussed in the past, so as you can see below along coastline road, that would be the pro throughout throughout April to October Powell coastline has a concessionaire ' s contract and also so it would certainly strolling vending would certainly be enabled,.
It would need a parks allow and also so it would'be at the discernment of the parks as well as rec below in front of here in front of, the seaside company is where the 1933 judgment guidelines that there ' s no vending from various other folks, yet after that
there ' s this space here below on around
ideal bar and as well as and the volleyball. court would certainly require a parks allow, there are. different depending on if there ' s private residential property,. there are little fingers of restrict, fully restricted that are in there and we ' ll obtain those really clear as we head out and after that certainly the WARF is banned as wooden structure and as a jampacked structure we actually felt like that restriction on,. on the WARF was effect, So, we did speak with a few of you beforehand about,. concerning this ordinance to get your responses therefore thanks all for those of you that involved with us.We heard some worries concerning the restriction on beach road, I wan na explain that that. is staff ' s recommendation due to the fact that our team believe that. the behavior modification is so excellent and the
staffing requirements are so fantastic to make that behavior change occur that having any kind of kind of having any kind of type of vending on beach road will make it really difficult, however, it goes to the enjoyment of. the council, certainly. Therefore if you want pursuing some kind of restricted. vending on coastline road, the rubric that we think of together that appeared to be one that.
we might experiment with is a concentrate on craftsmen,. so an emphasis on arts and craft vendors and also those folks that we understand are out there, like the person in this image, octavo his his other half makes all
the arm bands that are on his on his board there therefore having that minimal focus, I feel.
like they'have a smaller sized footprint there ' s much less garbage and also that we are, if, if there was a restricted day finishing areas on that street area in between the beach. company as well as suitable baring grill that we can still function to manage the well-being, safety and also health influences, that we experienced last summer season, nevertheless, by not locking it down it does call for by knock, securing it down, completely feel like that exchange will certainly require even more staffing to make it successful.Just a last little bit, we.
Legislator, legislator Allen was putting forward a. costs it ' s in for right now ' reason SB 1290, our contributions actually made it in as well as I ' m very thrilled to say as well as the things that we wanted to put in. As you saw in the package, we have actually some suggested actions for you. I ' ll quickly run via.
a new pathway vending fee, or that pathway
vending. permit that we discussed that ' s concerning$ 30.
As well as also, that ' s additionally kind of what maintains the side firm from sending out from selling in that area. From SB9-46 as well as there ' s also as needed by SB9-46, there ' s a developed a resolution that is consider by the team organizer? I believe that ' s my whole discussion
. That we ' re making certain that our bricks and
mortar businesses services not poorly inadequately influenced the ordinance.And then after that compliance easierSimpler I think it '
s complicated. Senator, legislator Allen was putting ahead a. expense it ' s in for right currently ' reason SB 1290, our payments in fact made it in as well as I ' m very excited to claim as well as the things that we desired to place in.And after that permit for a budget plan
change around the enforcement team that we require to make the make the regulation successful as well as
then direct human resources to build out an elderly
co-compliance category to ensure that we can hire that
person for the 20.
Currently we'' ll respond to any of your concerns. -Thank you, Elizabeth, I will certainly
take out to council member inquiry and direct raised Renee gold council member Rock
and also after that council participant Myers. – First, I simply wan na claim
thank you so a lot, Elizabeth, for grabbing where Sarah ended. And also thanks to Cassie as well as Bernie and also Tony and everybody else that had
like a hand in developing this. I assume you did an actually remarkable work of capturing the neighborhood worries while addressing you understand,
this statewide issue.And so I am prepared to move this recommendation after we go out for public comment, yet I did have a pair of questions. As well as the first one that I was asking yourself was … And also I also wan na say give thanks to
you for the stakeholder interaction as well, I think that was truly essential to making it a successful referral. Does anybody else wan na add? I have one'even more inquiry.
– I ' d most likely be( indistinct )concern.
– That ' s an excellent phone call, thank you. -Yeah, I understand the concerns, there were numerous scenarios that we we checked out'over the summer for the last few summer seasons, those are really challenging instances to prove.And generally you have to assemble an instance over an amount of time. And also I think we absolutely check out those as well as some of them are concerning, but I put on ' t think anything expands to the level of criminal actions. you recognize and also some of those instances are actually tough to obtain prospective victims if they are victims of the'human trafficking to speak out and also remain in a situation where they ' re comfortable to share information with us, yet I assume as you saw, a great deal of people saw that the, several of the children in these conditions were extremely young as well as simply around all day long, every day as well as all weekend absolutely something we can pay a little bit a lot more focus to.
– Thank you.
Council participant Myers and also then council member Terry Johnson. Yeah, I ' d be prepared to, I ' d be satisfied to that movement, do that, just a pair of inquiries, did'we, was there ever last year existed ever before any type of follow up, as an example, from parks from public jobs? Did you ever before point out anyone for any of these storm drain disposing? Existed ever any citations released under our code regards to storm essentially tornado drainpipe, illegal disposing into the tornado drains by either? I was just curious, I. saw fairly a little bit of that when I was, I am not conscious. of those side patients, but Nathan is gon na inform us,. no, we did not point out anyone.I assume currently that we have the, or it ' s all in one area as well as.
we as well as it gives us the capability to truly be clear concerning what.
tastes we ' re looking for and also so we have that.
opportunity going onward.- To ensure that would go across.
over Cassie with regards to, we have our storm water ordinance with events services therefore those
2 points speak with me, that activity was taking place, it would certainly obtain … There would be some citation.
Is that kind of. Yeah, so, I imply, we.
I assume one of the significant problems with tornado water dumping is actually simply
like catching capturing, I meanIndicate maybe possibly might. -And I believe, I indicate,. -Thank you, council participant Terry Johnson.
And afterwards council participant— Thank you a lot( indistinct )additionally restate( audio decreases )Did have, sorry, I ' m like,( indistinct). I did have this pair. of remarks and also inquiries. Elizabeth, you talked about the vendor ID, it addresses the combination condition, listening to a little bit extra about that,
what is needed for a vendor ID and also exactly how can we kind of. those neighborhood participants that are undocumented that. they can be remainder ensured that they can have equal accessibility?- Cassie could be able to speak. to the extremely specific terms, but I can talk normally. that we are requesting some identification, yet they do not have to. be documented citizens.Is that right, Cassie?- That ' s correct, that ' s available.- So there is a requirement.
– Okay, fantastic, thank you. As well as I was actually additionally satisfied to listen to about the outreach. I ' m interested in remaining.
I understand this perception pass tonight, but also for us to take into consideration. truly use our wellness in all plans framework,.
as an assisting framework to create what implementation appearance like.
Believe concerning that we can … I ' m certain we ' re gon na have to. Were all resolved, so, thank you
.- Thank you, council participant Terry Johnson.
And the work ' s being done on this.I recognize it ' s been a couple of years
and this initially originally during COVID. It ' s excellent that we ' re trying to figure out a way to figure out a way
to work for everyoneEvery person I did have a couple questions inquiries associated IDs permits licensing.So, I guess presumeInitial As well as I ' m simply, so there ' s no.
We ' re going to address it with our existing team now. And as we mentioned with the partnership with the other departments, along with the region, like and also in, in addition to the exclusive security vendor, that layered method was, was a far better fit
for this coming summer, seems excellent, I simply, I saw that in the personnel.
I was just wondering if that was gon na be a concern relocating this onward. Therefore thanks and also that ends my comments or my inquiry,. I ' ll have remarks back.- Say goodbye to inquiries, we ' ll then take it bent on public remark. Currently, we ' re interesting talking about sidewalk vending ordinance. program as well as resource request. You can raise your hand by dialing celebrity nine on your phone.
or pick raising hand on webinars devices on your computer. When it ' s your resort to speak,. you ' ll listen to a news and the timer will certainly after that.
be established three minutes Going
bent on the one. attendee with a hand elevated. Zachary Davis, welcome. – Hello there you. All?- Yes. -Okay, yeah, just genuine quick, I intended to claim as a local business owner, I support entrepreneurialism.
I assume great for anybody concerned. I do wan na express a little.
little bit of frustration for organizations that have extension areas,. walkway expansion areas, parklets, even nonprofits. that utilize our road as well as sidewalks for events, they ' re all required to have insurance policy. And also I ' m a little dissatisfied that that won ' t be a need, does appear like
that I believe one. of things regarding this is while I might not be super. fed of an ice lotion cart brought up in front of my gelato store and began offering ice. lotion, I get it, competition.That just means that we.
That ' s my one( indistinct), many thanks.- Thank you for your comment. Okay,'wear ' t see various other participants.
Allow ' s see, council participant Cummings and council member Rock,. I have your hands please.
policemans reply to this, it ' s just one added. thing that we would certainly previous years or in different. times include to their plate and also I assume it '
s good that. we ' re entering direction of moving this towards code. conformity as well as various other people. I don ' t like, I assume. One, due to the fact that if we have a strip where no one ' s being there ' s. constantly gon na be individuals going down there attempting to as well as.
Enabling individuals to.
street in between the local and also third street and also. offer car parking licenses, suppliers spent for those
in. the 2021 program failings, after that under the statute language for 58.80.080, I simply desired. to clean up some language to ensure that it ' s clear that this. is associated with limiting vending times as well as places. that under 5.82.080.- Council member Golder had. an intent to make a movement, little baffled on the top. None of us can be, can. seem to be with your hand up things, so, sorry, (indistinct). We had 2 council members. who attempted to reveal that they were gon na make. an activity and also so, anyways.
– I just like to ask, what is the plan around making a, because. in the past it was we waited till the end of public remark and also then if people were focusing they put their hands up and after that today it ' s shift making activities before things head out to public remark,. so this is'clearly off topic
conversation, yet it ' s took place in the past as well, that council participants made expressions that they want to make a motion before going to public comment.And other council.
members have elevated their hands and afterwards were. contacted made movement. So I ' m attempting to do what was historic technique as well as so I waited till the individual had actually made their remark, I raised my hand. And also in addition, I had.
As well as we ' ll telephone call on council member Stone.- Council member Cumming, then we will certainly comply with.- Thank you.
solely residential, including within stay.
zone park as well as this is under that'bullet factor, 58.0.080, this is where vending might be. If you have a permit.And then 582.080 P1 including, located. in from April 1st to October 31st roads as well as walkways street in between the municipal 3rd. street without a permit as well as outside marketed areas as well as in screen areas as established of. parks and also rec division 5.82.080 before all year on the road promenade dress up department and outdoors demarcated areas and. Display screen zones as set up by the parks as well as rec department as well as then in 5.82.110, this is relevant to charges or the penalties and also citations, it'' ll be$ 100 for a. infraction after a warning.
So once more, attempting to ensure. that we ' re making sure that people are educated. and if they ' re coming in and making as well as they ' re.
attempting to establish vending, that they ' re at least given a caution for their problem citation. That ' s end of the motion.Second it.
– That ' s right, that ' s out there. And also the job ' s being done on this.I recognize it ' s been a couple of years
and and also initially started begun Throughout. It ' s good that we ' re trying to figure out a way to figure out a method
to work function everyoneEvery person I did have a couple questions related connected IDs permits allows, I guess thinkVery first And I ' m simply, so there ' s no. One, since if we have a strip where no one ' s being there ' s. constantly gon na be people going down there attempting to as well as.Sandy council member, fine, we have an activity by council participant Cummings and a second by council participant Brown. (indistinct) I take explanation
really quick on the 2nd. – The highlighted word. – Yeah, council participant Cumming said outside city market locations, however movement language stated
And without an authorization.
Outside the area, yeah, must be outdoors, sorry. – May I ask a clarifying question? Is that what you (indistinct).
Initial bullet, yes, second bullet, yes, 3rd bullet, it'' s the enhancements are … The addition begins without. It ' s not really securing anything in, it'' s just stating that these are areas that belong to the city where we'' ve seen coastline vending previously, we ' ve advised coastline vending before as well as leaving those open as– – Can you clear up the free authorization? And also so it ' s not fair that these individuals went through
the process procedureAssisted
for them to be able to vend, there was no enforcement and also that was and consequently, it was.
simply an unreasonable circumstance for them to be in, so. – Great, supervisor Tony Elliot.
as well as supervisor Lee Butler with hands up. Therefore I'' d like to provide,. they have input or remarks on that. If anyone has, and likewise ask.
a concept of the amount of individuals that would relate to permit? The amount of vendors (indistinct).
– Yeah, mayor Brunner. This is Tony Elliot of parks recreation. We had six suppliers in 2015.
that were allowed and paid the start of the season, as a result of the concerns dealt with which council participant.
Cummings simply determined, we actually did reimburse.
every one of those vendors at the end of the season in 2015 due to the fact that of the problems that they dealt with, so they'' ve all been. repaid currently. – Thank you for that input. Supervisor Lee Butler. Thanks, Mayor Brunner,.
I was simply gon na go back to one of the inquiries that you asked about the slide that Elizabeth shared.And actually, I was assuming. If the– Let ' s see, 5.82, no it ' s the O9OA, is what Cassie had defined, which was just that a parks.
I just wanted to call. – I'' ll simply say it ' s the staff as well as recommendation with. – Great, that functions, thank you.
And so I think it would certainly be great to simply that'' s a certain. – To send it to me genuine or … – I assume I did, I'' ll.- And also after that we have( indistinct)
,.
I simply wished to comment concerning the the addition warning.I believe that we appreciate. the intent behind that,
we all, I believe all departments.
From code compliance to the county, to the cops division, plan on education and learning.
on this kind of point. There'' ll be a lot of signs, but I do wan na give your.
focus, the problem with trying to track alerting amongst several divisions, if the police department of.
a social work officer is releasing or talking to a supplier, how close the track that.
perhaps code conformity gave this individual caution (indistinct). That just is difficult as well as actually difficult and once again, I shape the intent as well as objective behind that. Yet I believe that that'' s. gon na be the intent of all city personnel from the start anyways, so that addition adds some issue.
– Well, I'' m happy to. remove that if the intent and also if it can be the. education as well as outreach, such that we ' re providing.
people with spoken warnings. I'' m satisfied to remove that. – Council member Cummings.
are you likewise considering removing the complimentary authorizations? – Understanding that were … – Yep. – So, you individuals (indistinct) seems like council participant Cummings has deleted after cautioning.
and permit the bottom bullet. – And where is it trying.
– The bottom bullet in the direction of the bottom scroll down, right there, that last part of the sentence. (indistinct) The second of the movement council member Brown amenable truth I will certainly take it out to council member Rock and also then council member Myers, so I'' d like to supply us activity and that ' s gon na be the. And I just wan na reveal.
you control the motion to fight this really details language that personnel hasn'' t had time to assess. We haven ' t had time to evaluate.
and also after that you have us discuss with you throughout night.We all had
an opportunity to offer input on this, I know Elizabeth that.
with each and also every one people as well as you could have dropped.
this onward before tonight at nine o'' clock during the night,.
not just that 20 mins, changing no point of order. I'' m calling the concern. I'' ll 2nd the movement.'- I ' m gon na call a point of order.- Okay, we have a point of order called. We ought to have quit all discussion, when a factor of order is called. – What'' s your point of order? – The inquiry prior to that. – Point of order can be heard, today there is a movement.
on the floor also, so I think you can hear.
council participant Cumming'' s point of order might continue to motion, It'' ll be another 20 minutes.The point of order
is that we are supposed to be complying with rules, as well as component of those policies. discussion forum are that we talk to the things before us, not. strike each various other as associates, council participants and also we ' re. intended to be setting an'example of area. Therefore factor of order is that. we ' re supposed to be speaking'to the thing,. – Okay. – And also I'' ll make better. remark later, thank you. – Okay, as well as currently– – There is an alternative.
before the council, the ballot would certainly be approve.
the and also the activity council participant Boulder is.
made by council participant Rock as well as it'' s personnel referral. With added with language.
added and also there'' s a second by council member– Can I ask a making clear inquiry? – Yes. – It'' s my understanding, we require to vote whether or not to accept movement before we vote on the movement. I thought I say voting on the activity. – No, you'' re proper,.
council member Brown, that substitute activity is.
whether to approve subs, there'' s also a phone call to.
concern out there as well. So sure where that suits this. ' ' Trigger the inquiry was called whether it was a 2nd question was called on whether that'' s. a great vote on the subs.Okay, roll
phone call. Vote on whether to approve.
We ' re ballot to approve', you ' re ballot on whether to accept this as a motion – Yes, aye. Member Terry Johnson. And for the document, I'' ve been.
to make recommendations, make changes to motion.
And I'' ll see, my more document comment will certainly speak about that. Actually, I'' ll say it now
,. It'' s my understanding that.
the role of common council as a legal body is enact laws, mull over to our organization in public, that is what I, when I.
was elected to workplace and so often it'' s untidy. Sometimes it takes a long.
time, yet mulling over and in some cases words,.
a thing, agenda products, these typical method, it has actually prevailed method on this council,.
I started following it three decades back, I have.
– Council member Myers. And also I just wan na make a.
comment staff, I wan na take staff team all their work on this, the last two years haveHave actually have have actually reallyTruly really truly down there, everyone every person As well as think believe and And also and and also whole teamGroup I'' m really.
a (indistinct) every single facet, a truly solid method to approach this and also you understand, I learnt through a.
great deal of service individuals down there that they'' re very, really, so they went 2 years where it was really, actually chaotic down there and I spoke with local business owner down there, staff individuals whose youngsters operate at the boardwalk every person is very, extremely satisfied and everyone intends to see some thanks for everyone'' s deal with this as well as I ' m an eye on this.Mayor, hi as well as Mayor Brunner, no. I actually want to assume.
the collaborative method of all the staff, nonetheless having.
some limited vending along. I assume and when we speak about equity and also we speak about some.
of the spirit of SB9-46, I heard several times and individuals access. I actually, after speaking with.
several perspectives on this, I do concur.
that restricted might function. Either way it will certainly be.
a lift off the ground, that just like every little thing.
we can continue to improve and also look at this as we move on. Allow'' s see, it looks like the. below the staff recommendation with Cassie Ronson'' s pass.
with a fourth three vote. Let'' s see, I still have a.
couple hands up Watkins, – I'' m gon na reduced my hand, – As well as it appears like that.
ends our meeting today.And this meeting will now be adjourned. Thank you everybody for being right here with us.
It ' s not actually securing anything in, it'' s just saying that these are locations that belong to the city where we'' ve seen beach vending in the past, we ' ve recommended beach vending before as well as leaving those open as– – Can you clear up the free authorization? If the– Let ' s see, 5.82, no it ' s the O9OA, is what Cassie had defined, which was simply that a parks. – I'' ll just state it ' s the team and recommendation with. As well as so I believe it would certainly be good to just that'' s a specific. (indistinct) The second of the movement council participant Brown open reality I will take it out to council participant Rock as well as then council member Myers, so I'' d like to offer us movement and that ' s gon na be the.